Death toll rises to 63 in Pakistan train crash

Railway workers near crumpled train car
Railway workers try to clear the track at the site of a train crash in southern Pakistan late Monday.
(Fareed Khan / Associated Press)

The death toll from the horrific crash of two trains in southern Pakistan rose to 63 on Tuesday after rescuers pulled 12 more bodies from crumpled cars, officials said.

The crash happened Monday on a dilapidated railway track in Ghotki, a district in southern Sindh province, when an express train barreled into another that had derailed minutes earlier before dawn.

Most of the passengers — there were about 1,100 on both trains — were asleep when the Millat Express, traveling between the southern port city of Karachi to Sargodha in eastern Punjab province, derailed and many of its cars overturned. As passengers scrambled to get out, another passenger train, the Sir Syed Express, crashed into the derailed coaches.


Rescue work continued throughout the day Monday, overnight and into Tuesday. Bodies of passengers were taken to their hometowns for burial.

Shafiq Ahmed Mahisar, commissioner in Sukkar district, said 12 more bodies were retrieved after the overnight efforts. More than 100 passengers were injured, he said.

Army engineers and soldiers dispatched from a nearby military base assisted in the rescue, and heavy machinery arrived in Ghotki hours later to cut open some train cars.

A 2008 train crash in Chatsworth killed 25 people and broke a long congressional stalemate on a nationwide rail safety project known as “positive train control.” Twelve years later, that system is finally in place.

Jan. 2, 2021

It was unclear exactly what caused the derailment. Aijaz Ahmed, the driver of the Sir Syed Express, said he braked when he saw the disabled train but did not have time to avoid impact.

The more critically injured were taken to hospitals with better facilities in Sindh and also Punjab province, while those less seriously hurt were being treated in Ghotki hospital, said Usman Abdullah, who also confirmed the 63 fatalities.

Ata Mohammad, a passenger, said he was asleep on the Millat Express when it derailed. He woke to a big jolt and saw other passengers trying to climb out from overturned and derailed coaches. Then the other train hit.


“I feel as if I am still hearing cries,” said Mohammad, weeping. He lost family members in the crash.

A decision to change cars to be closer to a station exit may have saved Erik Bravo when a Mexico City subway line collapsed, killing 25 people.

May 7, 2021

Sher Muhammad, a 45-year-old farmer, was working on his land when he saw a train derail on the tracks some distance away. He rushed to the scene, but before he could reach it, the second train crashed into the first.

“I don’t know whether I will be able to forget that tragic scene,” Muhammad said, recounting how he saw women, children and men crying for help.

Villagers who reached the scene first started helping the victims, pulling the injured and the dead from the wreckage until ambulances started coming.

According to Azam Swati, the minister for railways, experts were still trying to determine the cause of the crash. Swati said all aspects would be examined, including the possibility of sabotage.

By noon Tuesday, the military said that the rescue operation was complete and that the railroad track in Ghotki was being repaired to resume train service.

Train accidents are common in Pakistan, where successive governments have paid little attention to improving the poorly maintained signal system and aging tracks.

In 1990, a packed passenger train plowed into a standing freight train in southern Pakistan, killing 210 people in the worst rail disaster in the nation’s history.