Giuliani associate gets one year in prison in foreign donor case
A Florida man who helped Rudolph W. Giuliani seek damaging information against Joe Biden in Ukraine was sentenced to a year and a day in prison and fined $10,000 on Friday in an unrelated campaign finance case.
Igor Fruman was told to report to prison March 14. He pleaded guilty in September to a single charge of solicitation of a contribution by a foreign national.
As part of the plea, he admitted soliciting $1 million from a Russian entrepreneur, Andrey Muraviev, to donate to Republicans in Nevada, Florida and other states as part of an effort to launch a recreational marijuana business.
Federal prosecutors in New York had urged Judge J. Paul Oetken to sentence Fruman to three to four years in prison. Defense lawyers had argued he should face no incarceration because he has otherwise led a law-abiding life.
Oetken said the crime of soliciting foreign money for U.S. political campaigns was serious and deserved incarceration.
“It undermines the integrity of elections in our country,” he said as he announced the sentence. “It undermines democracy.”
The House committee investigating the Capitol insurrection has issued subpoenas to some of Donald Trump’s closest advisers, including Rudy Giuliani.
Fruman, 55, the father of four children, told the judge he had reflected on his crime.
“It’s a shame that will live with me forever,” he said through a white face mask as several family members watched from wooden benches in an area for spectators.
Assistant U.S. Atty. Hagan Scotten had urged a sentence of at least three years behind bars, saying the crime had caused “incalculable damage” because it harms the trust the public has in U.S. elections.
“That all the things they fear are happening with politicians are happening,” he said.
Scotten said the crime does “grave damage to the integrity of the electoral system.”
Defense lawyer Todd Blanche said his client had suffered from eight days in jail after his arrest and two years and four months of home incarceration.
“That’s punishment enough, your honor,” he said.
The pair served as liaisons between Giuliani and Ukrainian officials and business tycoons as the former New York City mayor tried to persuade prosecutors in that country to investigate Biden’s son Hunter over his work for an energy company.
Like all good villains, Rudolph W. Giuliani, who continues to lie about a stolen election, seems at peace with what he’s become.
U.S. prosecutors haven’t brought any charges in connection with the Ukrainian influence campaign, which was the subject of one of former President Trump’s impeachment trials, but focused instead on donations that Fruman and Parnas made to U.S. politicians as they sought to build influence in Republican political circles.
Parnas was convicted in October of campaign finance crimes and awaits sentencing.
Politicians who got the illegal donations, including Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis and former Nevada Atty. Gen. Adam Laxalt, have said they were unaware the money secretly came from a foreign source.
Muraviev was not charged in the case.
Giuliani, who worked for Trump as a personal attorney, faces a continuing investigation into whether he was required to register as an agent of a foreign government during his dealings with Ukrainian authorities.
The inquiry partly involves an examination of whether Giuliani offered to lobby or influence the Trump administration on behalf of Ukrainian figures. Giuliani has said that everything he did in Ukraine was done on Trump’s behalf and that there is no reason he would have had to register as a foreign agent.
After raids on Giuliani’s home and business last year, a judge appointed former federal Judge Barbara Jones to determine what materials on electronic devices seized in the raid can be turned over to criminal prosecutors.
In a four-page report issued Friday, Jones said only a few dozen items among tens of thousands of communications on seven of his electronic devices have been prevented from being turned over to prosecutors because they contain privileged communications. She said she was awaiting further assignments.
Must-read stories from the L.A. Times
Get the day's top news with our Today's Headlines newsletter, sent every weekday morning.
You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times.