'American Idol' Buzzmeter

Ann Powers

Los Angeles Times

Shirley Halperin

Los Angeles Times

James Cantiello

MTV

Brian Mansfield

USA Today

Michael Slezak

Entertainment Weekly

Jessica Herndon

People Magazine

Mara Reinstein

Us Weekly

Steve Gidlow

In Touch Weekly

MJ Santilli

mjsbigblog.com

Rickey Yaneza

Rickey.org

Lyndsey Parker

Yahoo

Joseph Kapsch

Zap2It

Crystal Bowersox

Lee DeWyze

RELATED LINKS:
'American Idol' Poll: Who do you think will go home?
Idol Tracker

Comments (7)

Add / View comments | Discussion FAQ

JimmyJam at 9:39 PM May 14, 2010

I'm just glad Siobhan is gone! Can't stand that one note wonder screaming that same note in almost every song she sings. 99% nasal and 1% screaming in most songs.

mlesherr at 1:03 PM May 12, 2010

I miss Siobhan! It's so boring without her!!!

allenjames9 at 8:14 AM April 29, 2010

Whats it gona take to get Mike off, he can't sing and he dresses like a pig you people sent the wrong person home, Siobhan is a much better singer then that fat ace Mike. Which tells me the show is rig, I would love to see the total votes for this week.

Comments are filtered for language and registration is required. The Times makes no guarantee of comments' factual accuracy. Readers may report inappropriate comments by clicking the Report Abuse link next to a comment. Here are the full legal terms you agree to by using this comment form.