Opinion
Get Opinion in your inbox -- sign up for our weekly newsletter
Editorial
Opinion Editorial
Editorial

A reasonable gun measure prompted by Isla Vista rampage

Mentally ill people with violent tendencies should not possess firearms

Among the many tragedies that intersected during Elliot Rodger's violent rampage near Santa Barbara in May — killing six people and wounding more than a dozen others before he killed himself — was that Rodger's parents had sought police help as their son's life spiraled out of control. Unfortunately, until he started killing people, Rodger violated no law that would have justified police action.

That frustration was widely felt, and the Isla Vista tragedy moved the Legislature to approve a measure last week that would let relatives seek a court order to confiscate weapons from a family member who displays signs of violence. At its heart, the law extends the authority police already have to disarm someone under a domestic violence restraining order. It's a sane measure, one that Gov. Jerry Brown should approve.

AB 1014 empowers a judge to issue a "gun violence restraining order" after being presented with reasonable cause to believe a gun owner could "in the near future" harm himself or others. Under its authority, police would be allowed to search the subject's residence and remove weapons. Guns owned by another resident of the home could also be confiscated unless they are secured beyond the reach of the restrained person, such as in a locked gun case.

The legislation arose after it was discovered that Rodger, despite a history of mental illness, legally bought all three of the guns he used. Notably, they were only part of his arsenal: Rodger killed his first three victims with knives, and he injured several others by striking them with his car.

That has prompted some critics of this legislation to argue that it would not have prevented the rampage that inspired it. That may be true — or at least partly true — but it misses the larger point that mentally ill people with violent tendencies should not possess firearms.

Gun-rights advocates also argue unpersuasively that this law infringes on the 2nd Amendment. The U.S. Supreme Court, in the same ruling that found an individual right to bear arms in the Constitution, explicitly left room for restrictions of that right and seemed almost to anticipate this legislation. "Nothing in our opinion," the court wrote in its 2008 Heller ruling, "should be taken to cast doubt on long-standing prohibitions on the possession of firearms by felons and the mentally ill."

That's especially true here, since the bill before the governor also provides for the restraining order to be lifted after a hearing if a judge concludes it is not justified, and the law requires it to end after a year unless the judge renews the order. The law also makes it a misdemeanor to file a false petition, which offers protection against spurious requests.

This is a reasonable approach that the gun lobby should join in supporting, and that Brown should sign into law.

Follow the Opinion section on Twitter @latimesopinion

Copyright © 2015, Los Angeles Times
Related Content
  • California needs a Gun Violence Restraining Order

    California needs a Gun Violence Restraining Order

    California legislators have spent much of the last two decades strengthening the state's gun laws, but last weekend's multiple killings in Isla Vista, Calif., by a young man previously identified by family to police as being a potential danger prove there is far more progress to be made.

  • A Biden candidacy could divide the Democrats

    A Biden candidacy could divide the Democrats

    Joe Biden hasn't decided whether to run for president, but he tells almost everyone who asks that he's giving it serious thought.

  • Egypt's muffling of news media is an outrage

    Egypt's muffling of news media is an outrage

    In sentencing three Al Jazeera television journalists to three years in prison for crimes that look suspiciously like committing journalism, an Egyptian court has ruled in direct contradiction to international human rights and press freedoms. That an American ally — and the recipient of $1.3 billion...

  • Beyond $15 an hour: The new generation of labor leaders

    Beyond $15 an hour: The new generation of labor leaders

    In the 121 years since Labor Day became a national holiday, millions have taken it as a day of rest. For labor leaders, though, it's a day about work: working the politicians, working the issues of pay and benefits in a country where wages for many of those millions have hit the skids. Laphonza...

  • Where 'God's authority' ends

    Where 'God's authority' ends

    On Thursday, Kim Davis, an elected clerk in Rowan County, Ky., who has steadfastly refused to issue marriage licenses to same-sex couples, is expected to appear before a federal judge who could find her in contempt of court and jail or fine her. Neither sanction will be necessary if Davis does...

  • California, finally coming out of solitary

    California, finally coming out of solitary

    New limits on solitary confinement in California prisons are a long-delayed but welcome step in the evolution of a system that only recently subjected inmates to a degree of abuse that approached torture.

  • Why a car-centric transportation plan is folly for L.A.

    Why a car-centric transportation plan is folly for L.A.

    The knock on L.A.'s Mobility Plan 2035 is that it will slow down traffic. After the City Council approved the blueprint, the community group Fix the City wrote that "MP2035 is not a mobility plan, it is a plan designed to create immobility." It has a point. The city wants to redesign several thoroughfares...

  • Doesn't the 1st Amendment apply outside the Supreme Court?

    Doesn't the 1st Amendment apply outside the Supreme Court?

    From race relations to abortion to gay marriage, the Supreme Court plays a crucial role in American life. So it's understandable that activists want to demonstrate on the grand plaza in front of the court's building. Such a majestic backdrop lends force to a protest and increases the possibility...

Comments
Loading
71°