Grading City Hall: See our report card for L.A. City Council President Herb Wesson
Opinion Editorial

How to keep Hollywood in Hollywood

Should California subsidize Hollywood? It undoubtedly has to, but the system needs safeguards

Faced with a crisis of "runaway production" that is threatening one of Los Angeles' signature industries, California lawmakers are poised to quadruple the amount of money available to help persuade film and television productions to remain in the state. But before legislators and Gov. Jerry Brown expand the annual film tax credit program to $400 million, they must assure taxpayers that the money will deliver the greatest number of jobs and the highest public benefit.

For the last six years, California has relied on a lottery to dole out $100 million a year in film tax credits. Productions were selected for subsidies with no consideration of how many people would be employed or how much would be spent locally. More than half a billion dollars have been awarded based on the luck of the draw. That's not a smart way to target economic development funds, and the initial decision to keep the lottery system intact cast a shadow over Assembly Bill 1839, an otherwise strong proposal that The Times has supported. AB 1839 would increase the amount of money available for tax credits and expand the program to include big-budget movies and certain TV programs that were previously excluded.

Now, a last-minute amendment by state Sen. Kevin de León (D-Los Angeles) would remove that shadow by replacing the lottery with a competitive system that would award incentives to the productions that create the most new jobs and the greatest economic impact. This improvement, including a points-based system to judge the merit of applications, would give Californians more confidence that their tax dollars were being used to greatest effect. And that's important. There is still considerable — and understandable — pushback from people concerned about subsidizing Hollywood at the expense of social services, education and other state programs. Others worry that California is engaging in an unwinnable race to the bottom as states and countries seek to steal film and TV production from one another. We share some of those concerns.

But the reality is that there is a worldwide competition on, with generous tax breaks being offered to film and television productions that shoot in New York, Georgia and nearly 40 other states as well as Canada, Australia, Iceland, most European Union countries and elsewhere. The availability of subsidies means major movies often won't get made without the promise of a tax credit. California can't rely on its talent pool or climate anymore to attract filming, and, as a result, the state has in recent years hosted far fewer of the high-value productions that provide local revenue and middle-class employment. In L.A. County, feature film production has fallen by half since 1996, and the region's share of TV pilot production has fallen 73% since its peak in 2007. Over the last decade, California lost 16,000 entertainment jobs that pay, on average, $98,000 a year. That loss has a ripple effect, reducing business for prop houses, sound stages, caterers, dry cleaners, security companies and all the people who earn a living on entertainment industry spending.

As legislators and the governor negotiate the final details of AB 1839, they must focus on the long-term sustainability of the entertainment industry in California. That means backing films and TV shows that produce lots of jobs, but also supporting the lower-budget and independent productions that are the training ground for the next generation of professionals. The California Film Commission, which would develop the scoring criteria, should include production spending as a factor in addition to job creation, because it captures the equipment, supplies and rentals that are part of the larger industry economy, beyond the direct hires on film and TV shoots.

Finally, the new, competitive system must be impartial. That was the biggest advantage of the lottery system, and in dismantling it, California should not create a new cottage industry of tax credit lobbyists using political influence to seek benefits for favored clients. There should be a clear application and scoring process, with results evaluated by independent, qualified commission staff, and penalties for productions that overstate their job creation to game the competition. There also must be oversight, including audits, to ensure that the system is unbiased and free of corruption. If taxpayers are to be asked to give financial incentives to private industry, lawmakers should at least guarantee that the state is getting the most economic development bang for the tax subsidy buck.

Follow the Opinion section on Twitter @latimesopinion

Copyright © 2015, Los Angeles Times
Related Content
  • How California does, and should, grade its schools

    How California does, and should, grade its schools

    The Academic Performance Index, by which California schools have been judged over the last 14 years, is about to get an overhaul. That's fine; the index basically boiled down standardized test scores to a single number. As a result, it overemphasized testing in math and English while giving short...

  • Senate maneuvering spares Planned Parenthood -- for now

    Senate maneuvering spares Planned Parenthood -- for now

    A series of hidden-camera videos by anti-abortion activists capturing Planned Parenthood executives discussing tissue harvesting from aborted fetuses has renewed calls by Republicans to eliminate all federal support for the organization. But as bad as it's been lately in Washington for Planned...

  • Fast-tracking VA firings makes for bad policy

    Fast-tracking VA firings makes for bad policy

    The scandals that rocked the federal Department of Veterans Affairs last year rightly had some high-reaching consequences, including toppling secretary Eric K. Shinseki. Whether Shinseki’s successor, Robert McDonald, has been able to effect much of a cultural change within the department that provides,...

  • Drilling for oil in the Chukchi Sea isn't worth the risk

    Drilling for oil in the Chukchi Sea isn't worth the risk

    The Obama administration is being at least somewhat more cautious this time around in allowing Royal Dutch Shell to drill in the Arctic waters of the Chukchi Sea. The company must keep its drills from reaching the oil reserves until it has the equipment in place that can shut down a well in case...

  • Would L.A. be better off without the Olympics?

    Would L.A. be better off without the Olympics?

    As epic collapses go, Boston's bid to host the 2024 Olympics wins points for speed, if nothing else. On Monday, Mayor Marty Walsh announced that he didn't intend to sign the International Olympic Committee's required pledge to cover any cost overruns on the Summer Games. Within hours, the U.S....

  • Trans-Pacific Partnership must not undermine U.S. rules on intellectual property

    Trans-Pacific Partnership must not undermine U.S. rules on intellectual property

    U.S. negotiators recently concluded a 50-nation agreement to promote free trade in about 200 high-tech products, a pact that has drawn praise from seemingly all quarters. The goodwill generated by the new Information Technology Agreement may not last long, however. This week, negotiators may complete...

  • Can a Dear Cal letter get you into Berkeley?

    Can a Dear Cal letter get you into Berkeley?

    High school seniors vying for acceptance at UC Berkeley face daunting odds. Until about 50 years ago, Cal admitted any applicant with a B average in college-prep classes. As recently as 1985, the acceptance rate was above 50%. With a record 79,000 applicants in 2014, Berkeley now admits only 17%,...

  • Richard Henry Dana's second act

    Richard Henry Dana's second act

    Richard Henry Dana Jr. told no one that he was turning 28 because, he wrote on Aug. 1, 1843, “birthdays are not pleasant occasions for hilarity with me and friends always feel bound to make them so.” Nevertheless, I trust Dana would have been delighted to know that friends of his classic “Two Years...