Opinion Op-Ed

The contentious, complicated fight for water in California

Politics are hard enough in California; water politics are particularly tough
Here's how to address California's fragile water infrastructure

California's water system is an engineering marvel, a testament to generations of sustained investment and a vast, complex web of infrastructure. It makes Los Angeles possible. It is also in trouble.

The system's brilliance is that a snowflake can fall in the Sierra, trickle down the western slope, drift through the Bay Delta and into the state water system and then travel hundreds of miles and over mountains to Southern California. The system's delicacy was on display this month when that melted snowflake burst through a broken water main on Sunset Boulevard and ended up in a flood at UCLA.

And if Los Angeles' water infrastructure is in need of help, so is the state's, where the stakes are even higher and the debates over who gets water and how to pay for it are invariably fierce.


Water: The caption for the photograph that illustrated Jim Newton's Aug. 11 column on a water bond was incorrect. The Los Angeles Aqueduct was pictured, not the California Aqueduct. —

Last week's maneuvering over a proposed water bond for the November ballot was a case in point. Proponents have been pushing a bond for years, but the proposal they initially put together was so larded up with extras — bike paths, museums and other pet projects intended to ensure the votes of legislators whose districts they fell in — that it crumbled under its own weight.

This time, famously frugal Gov. Jerry Brown has counterpunched. He announced his "no-frills, no-pork" proposal last week, trimming the $11.1-billion package to $6 billion. If approved, it would fund dams, reclamation and ecosystem restoration, among other things, though at lower levels than many want.

The objections came swiftly. Agricultural interests complained that $2 billion allocated for dams wasn't enough. Assembly Speaker Toni Atkins worried the package was too small overall (only in California would a $6-billion bond strike anyone as small).

And farmers and environmentalists in the delta raised their own, unique concern: They are fearful of a proposed pair of tunnels that would divert Sacramento River water to Southern California, and even though this package includes no money for that project, they worry that investment in habitat protection could make the tunnels easier to build down the road. They're now in the odd position of questioning ecosystem restoration even though they're fighting to protect an ecosystem.

Jeff Kightlinger is general manager of the Metropolitan Water District, which supplies much of Southern California with its water, and he's seen these debates before. When I asked him last week about the delta group's response to the ecosystem investment, Kightlinger let out a long sigh. "Well, they're free to oppose anything," he said. But the bond would invest more than $1 billion in watershed protection and ecosystem restoration throughout the state; defeating it to block the tunnels would be a high price.

Water politics, always complex, are particularly tricky this time. Critics of the delta tunnels may withhold their support, which would leave supporters in search of a few Republican votes to reach the two-thirds necessary in the Legislature. They're likely to insist on more dams, however, which would push up the price and risk losing other potential backers, even Brown himself.

Yet one historical divide on these issues has gradually receded. I grew up in the Bay Area, where in the 1970s common wisdom held that Los Angeles was stealing San Francisco water and using it to hose down driveways and fill swimming pools. The state has grown up since then, and that caricature — never quite true, and much less so today — has faded. As even my old neighbors would now grudgingly admit, Los Angeles has made extraordinary strides in curtailing water use, and that helps the entire state. Every drop not used here is a half-drop not taken from somewhere else (typically, L.A. gets about half of its water from the State Water Project; this year, it's been higher, about 75%).

The bond would not invest in Los Angeles water infrastructure, the source of the recent troubles at UCLA. But Marcie Edwards, general manager of the Department of Water and Power, said it's crucial anyway. She's pressing for an increase in the amount of groundwater cleanup it would fund — an especially important priority here, as contamination beneath the San Fernando Valley limits the city's ability to store water once it arrives. Moreover, money for groundwater cleanup could free up other money locally — to address infrastructure, for example.

It takes water to survive. And in California, it takes a monumental effort to capture that water and get it where it's needed. After all, as Kightlinger noted, in California "the people do not live where the water is."


Twitter: @newton_jim

Copyright © 2014, Los Angeles Times
Related Content
  • California needs to get a grip on its groundwater
    California needs to get a grip on its groundwater

    It's not just reservoirs and aqueducts that are drying up in the state's drought. Under the ground, aquifers that store water relied on by more than three-quarters of Californians are being over-pumped, often to such an extent that the earth above them sinks. Other states regulate pumping, or...

  • Amid climate change, what's more important: Protecting money or people?
    Amid climate change, what's more important: Protecting money or people?

    At the latest round of international climate talks this month in Lima, Peru, melting glaciers in the Andes and recent droughts provided a fitting backdrop for the negotiators' recognition that it is too late to prevent climate change, no matter how fast we ultimately act to limit it. They now...

  • Schools should help the children of immigrants become truly bilingual
    Schools should help the children of immigrants become truly bilingual

    Many students in Los Angeles, from kindergarten through college, speak a language other than English because they grew up hearing it. They are “heritage speakers,” the children of immigrants who communicate at home in their parents' native language. Yet many of these students have...

  • Would it hurt City Hall to look into rise in worker injury claims?
    Would it hurt City Hall to look into rise in worker injury claims?

    The cost of paying salaries to Los Angeles civilian workers who are temporarily disabled because they have been hurt on the job has gone up 50% over five years, reaching $18 million last year. Employees are claiming more injuries and taking longer injury leaves. City officials don't know why...

  • Should non-citizens in the U.S. vote?
    Should non-citizens in the U.S. vote?

    As of Jan. 1, 2012, an estimated 13.3 million lawful permanent residents lived in the United States, and 8.8 million of them were eligible to apply for U.S. citizenship but had not done so. In California, 2.48 million out of 3.4 million green-card holders were eligible to apply but chose not...

  • Obama's fourth-quarter foreign policy surprises
    Obama's fourth-quarter foreign policy surprises

    Six months ago, President Obama's foreign policy looked stymied. Negotiations with Israel and the Palestinians were at a dead end. Russia was gaining ground in eastern Ukraine. U.S. efforts to end the war in Syria were ineffective. A new extremist army, Islamic State, was marching into Iraq.

  • Ukraine should put Russia to the test
    Ukraine should put Russia to the test

    Ukraine is now strong enough to seize the initiative to create a lasting cease-fire in its Donbas Rust Belt, currently occupied by Russia and its proxies. And Russia may be weak enough to be receptive. It is in Kiev's interest to do so. A state of permanent war with Russia would damage...

  • The great fear of the great outdoors
    The great fear of the great outdoors

    Americans find ourselves in a period — arguably, the first in our nation's history — when our unease about being in nature is coming to outweigh our desire for it. We have a growing intolerance for inconvenience, a feeling well captured by the suburban fifth-grader who memorably...