Grading City Hall: How is L.A.'s city controller doing so far?
Readers React
Opinion Readers React
Readers React

CHP beating shows we need to pick public servants carefully

To the editor: As a teacher with the Los Angeles Unified School District, I share and understand the California Highway Patrol's plight: trusted public employees in an authoritative role having to deal with odd and often unusual circumstances. ("CHP beating video spotlights a problem that needs more attention," Editorial, July 9)

In the case of the women beaten on a freeway, the punishment did not fit her "crime."

I was pulled over on the Hollywood Freeway by a CHP officer some time ago and given a $400 citation for dropping a single sunflower seed shell out of my window. Granted, by law I was wrong — but really?

This woman who wandered onto the freeway was obviously in the wrong as well. But to what extent?

Bullies aren't just an issue in school; they are prevalent in the professional ranks as well. We need to be cautious of who we empower to guide us through our schools, our roads and all walks of life.

Ed DeGrasse, Chatsworth


To the editor: Inadequate training, sexism, racism and failures of our mental healthcare system have all been put forth as possible causes of Marlene Pinnock's beating.

A more proximate cause may reside squarely with the CHP officer himself and his fitness for the job. He lost his cool while dealing with an uncooperative person. Unfortunately, much of the work of law enforcement involves uncooperative people endangering themselves and others.

This calls into question the vetting and supervision of law enforcement personnel. Individuals involved in questionable use of force are likely in the wrong line of work.

I cannot imagine that a teacher who repeatedly punched an uncooperative student in the head would be given the benefit of the doubt. It defies common sense that police would not be subject to the same level of scrutiny.

Diana M. Granat, Altadena

Copyright © 2015, Los Angeles Times
Related Content
  • CHP beating video spotlights a problem that needs more attention

    CHP beating video spotlights a problem that needs more attention

    The video is jarring in its brutality: A California Highway Patrol officer kneels on Marlene Pinnock, a 51-year-old homeless woman, and punches her repeatedly in the head. But wait — haven't we seen this movie before? In 2011, Fullerton police beat to death Kelly Thomas, a mentally ill homeless...

  • Another Olympics for L.A.? Leave the taxpayers out of it.

    Another Olympics for L.A.? Leave the taxpayers out of it.

    To the editor: Dear Mr. Mayor: If you are reading this, here's the answer you should give the U.S. Olympic Committee on having the city cover any cost overruns for the 2024 Summer Games: No. ("Boston ends bid to host 2024 Olympics, giving Los Angeles an opportunity," July 27)

  • The choice: Start World War III, or support the Iran nuclear deal

    To the editor: John Bolton's rush to a radioactive World War III was not palatable even to George W. Bush, the man who took us to war in Iraq and appointed Bolton as ambassador to the United Nations. ("The consequences of a bad deal with Iran," op-ed, July 26)

  • The 'low' average premium increase is nothing to cheer

    To the editor: Covered California Executive Director Peter V. Lee and UC Berkeley health economist James C. Robinson are not convincing as to the success of Obamacare in California. ("Obamacare works in California. Here's why," op-ed, July 27)

  • Local governments are picking up the slack on climate change

    To the editor: When Aaron Renn scolds local communities for challenging climate-destroying fossil fuel development like drilling in the Arctic, he's relaying Big Oil's message: Resistance is futile. ("Local environmental activists don't get to make federal policy," op-ed, July 27)

  • No, that horn from a poached rhino won't cure your hangover

    No, that horn from a poached rhino won't cure your hangover

    To the editor: Regarding your article about the rhino orphanage in South Africa founded to respond to the immense scope of the poaching going on there to obtain horns for purchase by people who consume it for, of all things, a hangover cure: ("After poachers slaughter their mothers, baby rhinos...

  • Utilities need to do their part to help renters save water

    To the editor: Sub-metering apartments for water places the burden of billing on owners, making each one his own mini-utility. We hate that. Why not require utilities to do their job and install individual meters for apartments? But that costs “thousands of dollars per unit,” claims the article....

  • In defense of unaccredited law schools

    To the editor: As a successful graduate of an unaccredited law school, I take exception to your article on the schools' high dropout rates. Not everyone is cut out to become an attorney, just like not everyone is cut out to be a journalist or a doctor. The failures of many do not make the system...