Simply Put, Scott D. Allen Has a Real Identity Problem : The Story of How a Skillful Liar Tripped Up Police

The article in the newspaper last week was news indeed to Scott D. Allen, 24, of Huntington Beach.

As he read it in his parents’ living room, it told him that he had been shot by Cypress police as he resisted arrest and that he was recovering in a Long Beach hospital.

It was not the first time Allen had been surprised to find his name erroneously attached to a criminal suspect.

There was the time he was arrested in Buena Park for drunk driving when he was actually in Provo, Utah, studying for exams at Brigham Young University.

He was also in Provo when police arrested him in Huntington Beach for car theft and when a jury convicted him of the charge.

The tale of how Allen, a devout Mormon newly married and about to start medical school, got into this mess and his partly successful struggle to get out is a story of how difficult “positive” identification sometimes is for police when a suspect is a skillful liar.

Fortunately for Allen, this time Cypress police had discovered their suspect’s true identity by the following day. They identified him as Kevin Mark Greene, 30, a transient whose name is by now very familiar to Allen.

When he was in high school, Allen said, he worked in a fast-food restaurant with Greene, whom he had forgotten until last year.

Apparently Greene, who has served two terms in the California Institution for Men at Chino for armed robbery, had not forgotten Allen. When Greene was arrested in November, 1985, on suspicion of stealing a car, records indicate, he told Huntington Beach jailers his name was Scott Douglas Allen, a transient, born Dec. 6.

He had no documentary identification, so jailers checked the drivers license computer files at the Department of Motor Vehicles. They showed there was, indeed, a Scott Allen with the middle initial, “D”--although the middle name was different--who, by what turned out to be an extraordinary coincidence, was born Dec. 6, although in a different year than the suspect had given. The suspect was four inches taller than the license description, but the license description was six years old.

Jailers accepted the identification as correct and filled in the missing information from the computer printout--driver’s license number, address. And when they put Greene’s fingerprints on a fingerprint identification card, they put Scott Allen’s name and address on it, too.

The jury trial of Kevin Greene, known to the courts as Scott Allen, proceeded normally, and he was convicted. In March, 1986, as he was awaiting sentencing, he was arrested in Buena Park for drunk driving and again told police he was Scott Douglas Allen.

Buena Park police checked the suspect’s fingerprints, and this time there was proof: The fingerprints matched the prints taken by Huntington Beach police that were now in the files of the state Department of Justice in Sacramento. The state had opened a brand new criminal file for Scott D. Allen because he had no previous criminal record.

According to Buena Park police officer Ken Patrick, who later helped set the record straight, the fingerprints had fallen through a crack in the Sacramento system. The erroneous fingerprint card had arrived at a time when Greene’s previous cards had been sent out to be included in the system’s new computer.

If they had still been in the old files, someone would have compared the new prints to the ones already on file and found that they matched Greene’s.

But now Buena Park police had Scott Allen in their records, too. When Kevin Greene began to miss his scheduled hearings, police began looking for Scott Allen, and they knew where to find him.

When letters from police departments and court officers began to arrive at the Allen household, Jack E. Allen, 49, an aerospace executive and Scott’s father, said he didn’t take them seriously at first, thinking them to be clerical errors or jokes.

When they began to take on ominous tones, however--citations for drunk driving, warnings that arrest warrants had been issued--he took action.

With his son away at Brigham Young University, Jack Allen called the police himself. He said officers were more than a little skeptical when he telephoned. But when he appeared at the Buena Park police station, he got some help.

Patrick, who talked to Allen at the police station, said Allen was so straight looking, “I knew right away there was something totally wrong with the name.” The father and the police photograph of the suspect--longhaired and past college age--just didn’t fit together, he said.

Scott Allen sent his fingerprints to Patrick via the police department ion Provo, Utah, and Patrick issued Allen a card explaining the identity mixup that was intended to prevent a mistaken arrest.

Patrick and detectives from Huntington Beach began trying to set the various records straight. So did a former county probation investigator, Jeffrey Fagot, who recalled that it wasn’t a simple chore.

“There were some police officers and even jailers who got involved trying to straighten these things out,” he said.

“There were numerous calls. I sat sometimes for a long time letting (Jack Allen) vent his frustration, and I don’t blame him.”

Last July, while Scott Allen was home from school for the summer, a deputy marshal appeared at the Allen home to arrest him, and even though the card provided by Buena Park police prevented the arrest, Scott Allen recalls trembling for a long time afterward.

The marshal “told us later he just couldn’t believe Scott was a car thief,” recalled his mother, Carolyn Allen.

Even after police had figured out they were looking for Kevin Greene, the identification system still failed them. Greene was arrested in Huntington Beach in April, 1986, for petty theft and again gave Scott Allen’s name. He was turned loose with a citation. It was several days before his true identity was discovered.

Jack Allen said that a frustrating string of telephone calls finally led him to a Buena Park police investigator. Allen explained the identity mix-up, the investigator said he had known about Greene for years and knew where to find him.

“He just went right out and arrested him,” Allen said.

“He’s a local,” Patrick said. “Lived in our city for a number of years. Some of the older officers looked at the mug shot later and knew him on sight.”

Shortly afterward, all was set straight, Patrick said. Scott Allen’s criminal record was annexed onto Greene’s. Scott Douglas Allen was listed as one of Greene’s known aliases.

The Department of Justice’s fingerprint classification computer has since become operational. It discovered Greene had used Allen’s name again in Cypress on July 12, police said.

Justice officials said the computer will find the prints you’re looking for 94% of the time. It may take a few minutes, perhaps a few hours, a spokesman said.

Which means Scott Allen can relax?

An envelope arrived at the Allen household last week addressed to Scott D. Allen. It was from the helicopter ambulance service that had rushed “Scott Allen” from the crime scene after he had been shot by police. It was a bill for $1,959.10.

“I’m trying to get loans for med school,” the real Scott Allen said. “No one’s going to give me a loan with that on my record.”