Advertisement

Panel Urges More Tribal Control of Indian Affairs

Share
TIMES STAFF WRITER

Individual tribes should be allowed to assume control of Indian affairs programs administered by the government as a way to end “massive fraud, corruption and mismanagement” by the federal officials who oversee them, a Senate panel recommended Friday.

The report, the product of a two-year investigation by the investigations unit of the Select Committee on Indian Affairs, disclosed widespread abuses by the federal agencies assigned to oversee existing programs.

The panel reported that federal officials knew of possible oil theft from Indians but refused to stop it, hired teachers at reservation schools despite known records of sexual abuse of children and failed to heed warnings that minority contracting programs were dominated by fraudulent shell companies.

Advertisement

Committee investigators also documented kickbacks and other illegal financial dealings by some tribal officials.

“Not only do American Indians, but the American taxpayer as well, suffer from this extreme waste,” said Sen. Dennis DeConcini (D-Ariz.), the investigations unit chairman. “Year after year, all American taxpayers must foot the bill for a negligent and unresponsive bureaucracy from a limited federal budget.”

The report, which advocates a “New Federalism for American Indians,” proposes that individual tribes negotiate agreements with the President to establish self-governing bodies that will function “in the same sense as state governments.”

For those tribes that reach such agreements, the government would provide tribal officials with an annual entitlement grant equal to the amount that the tribe would have received through existing federal programs.

The grants would be used by the tribal governments to provide services for their members. In return, the tribes would be accountable to a constitution ratified by a majority of all adult tribal members.

Officials at the Interior Department, which supervises the Bureau of Indian Affairs and administers the federal government’s $3.3-billion Indian affairs budget, said they had not yet read the report. But they praised the committee for its work and noted that agency officials already are working with Indian tribes to achieve self government.

Advertisement

“The report reflects a trend currently growing stronger within tribal communities--the assumption of greater self-determination by tribal governments,” said Eddie Frank Brown, assistant Interior secretary for Indian affairs.

The special report is harshly critical of the government’s current supervision of Indian affairs.

“Paternalistic federal control over American Indians has created a federal bureaucracy ensnarled in red tape and riddled with fraud, mismanagement and waste,” the report said. “Worse, the committee found that federal officials in every agency knew of the abuses but did little to stop them.”

DeConcini said that congressional intervention is necessary to stem the abuses, adding that he would send draft legislation to the Select Committee on Indian Affairs.

DeConcini said that not all of the $3.3 billion annually earmarked for Indian programs reaches the nation’s Indian population. “In fact, the total household income for American Indians from all sources, including the federal government, is actually less than the entire federal budget of $3.3 billion,” DeConcini said.

If the panel’s recommendations were adopted, the Bureau of Indian Affairs would continue to provide services to those tribes that chose not to switch to self-governance.

Advertisement

Officials predicted that as tribes negotiate agreements and began to receive direct federal grants, the Bureau of Indian Affairs would play a smaller role in tribal affairs.

Advertisement