Full House : Huntington Park: Five lunch periods. Three sets of recesses. At Miles Avenue, the nation's biggest elementary school, it takes strict organization to make everything work.


Principal Lucille Derrig clings to her class schedule like a life preserver as she oversees the education of more than 2,800 pupils at the nation's largest elementary school.

Miles Avenue School has about a dozen classes at each grade level. It takes five lunch periods to serve the school's pupils and three sets of recesses to keep its playground from being overrun.

Despite the numbers, there is a surprising order and calm at the school. Classrooms average 27 to 29 pupils, in line with the state average, according to a state Department of Education official.

Common areas, such as the playground and cafeteria, are heavily used but not packed. Throughout the day, hundreds of pupils flow like columns of ants from classroom to playground and back again, always making room for the next group.

"We're highly organized to create a sense of smallness," Derrig said during a recent interview. "The one area that is difficult is scheduling, because we have to repeat so many things."

Miles is an example of how the giant Los Angeles Unified School District has approached educating children in crowded areas where vacant land is scarce. In fact, seven of the nation's 10 largest elementary schools are located in the Los Angeles district, according to the U.S. Department of Education.

In 1979, Miles became one of the district's first elementary schools to be placed on a year-round schedule, which increases the school's capacity by keeping a quarter to a third of its children on vacation at any given time. Nearly 2,000 pupils in kindergarten through fifth grade attend Miles at a time.

But the district has since abandoned the practice of building giant schools. The capacity of new elementary schools is now limited to 1,000 pupils, and officials say they are planning several new schools in the Huntington Park area to reduce enrollment and help relieve some of the crowding at Miles. Construction starts this month on one of the schools.

"There's a feeling that smallness may be better because of the connections staff can make with students," said Assistant Supt. Maria Casillas, who oversees the district's Region B, which includes Huntington Park schools.

The new policy went into effect in the mid-1980s, shortly after the Board of Education had approved another building to expand Miles' capacity to its current level. The decision to enlarge the school "was a good idea at the time because we didn't have much money and there wasn't any land," said Rodger Friermuth, the district's facilities project manager.

But critics began attacking the district's large-school approach.

The Mexican American Legal Defense and Educational Fund, the Legal Aid Foundation of Los Angeles and other groups filed a lawsuit against the district in 1986. The lawsuit alleges, among other things, that low-income minority students are shortchanged by being educated in facilities that are larger and more crowded than those in predominantly Anglo communities.

Critics of large schools say administrators and teachers are unable to give individual students as much attention as in smaller schools. The students at a smaller school also may have access to more resources. The school library, for example, is not as likely to be overburdened.

Attorney Liz Guillen, who represents the Mexican American legal organization in the suit against the Los Angeles district, said Miles is "the type of school we want to stop having. It's difficult to know everybody in (a giant) school, which increases a feeling of anonymity and aloneness. A kid needs to feel like he knows his environment and the kids around him. That contributes to self-esteem, which is necessary for a learning environment."

The district has denied any intentional inequities. The case is expected to go to trial this summer.

Derrig, the Miles principal, says that size also has some advantages. Miles, for example, has a full-time nurse and a psychologist, while other district schools must share such personnel. There is a district-run day-care center adjacent to the school.

Miles School is next door to City Hall in this poor city of about 56,000 residents, 92% of whom are Latinos, according to the 1990 Census.

Its student body is about 98% Latino, including recently arrived immigrants from Mexico, Nicaragua, El Salvador and other Latin American countries. Many come from poor families: the annual per capita income of Huntington Park is $7,235 compared to the county average of $15,331, according to the National Planning Data Corp.

Vacant space is at a premium at the school. Nine permanent buildings, some of them two stories, surround an asphalt playground. Bungalows rest on part of the playground, and there are only a few trees. But school hallways and classrooms sport fresh coats of paint, and generally are well kept.

On a recent afternoon, an instructor used a public address system to talk to more than 300 second-graders who had formed a huge rectangle on the playground. The pupils soon separated into groups of about a dozen for physical education--jumping rope and playing ball, among other activities. Aides supervised most of the groups.

In all, more than 100 aides help teach and supervise the throngs of children throughout the year at Miles, Assistant Principal Leonard Deutsch said. The school administration tries to bring in as many aides as possible to provide more individual attention, he said.

Lines of children snaked into the cafeteria, which serves about 975 breakfasts and 1,700 lunches a day. Lunch periods last 45 minutes.

Parents and students have mixed views on whether large is bad.

PTA President Eva Aguilar, who has two children attending Miles, said "we need big schools" to be able to educate more kids.

"It doesn't matter how large or small the school is. If you have responsible people, the school is fine," Aguilar said.

But Maria Elena Vallejo wishes her son attended a smaller school. Vallejo has been a volunteer worker at Miles for several months.

"In general, it's very well organized," Vallejo said. "But maybe they'd get a little more attention at a smaller school."

Children interviewed at Miles said they did not realize they were attending the nation's largest school, and raised no concerns about size. "It's better to have a bigger school so more kids can get educated," said fifth-grader Sergio Benitez as he waited in a line eight-deep to play handball after lunch.

But size has brought inconveniences for pupils and the more than 100 teachers at Miles.

One teacher said she has had problems obtaining books for her pupils from the school's 7,600-book library because they often are checked out. Another teacher said it is difficult to schedule time in the school auditorium for special programs. Supplies can sometimes be in short supply, but that happens at smaller district schools as well, the teachers said.

But many also pointed out that class size--the most important element--is normal at Miles. "Once you're in your classroom, it doesn't matter how big your school is," said third-grade teacher James Pierson.

District and school officials say it is difficult to know precisely how the bloated student body has affected the quality of instruction at Miles.

On the California Assessment Program test, for example, the school's third-graders scored near the bottom in reading, written expression and math in 1989-90 statewide testing. But scores have improved somewhat since 1986-87.

"We really have been working on (developing) high expectations for our students," Derrig said. "We're working to give the kids the top program they deserve."

The principal said the school's size should not be blamed for the low scores. More significant is the fact that Miles has a transiency rate of nearly 40%, Derrig said. That means about four out of 10 students at the school leave and are replaced by other students each year. Students suffer when the continuity of their education is interrupted, she said.

Officials say Huntington Park's large immigrant population accounts for much of the high transiency rate.

A spokesman for the state Department of Education said there is no evidence that indicates school size alone hurts the quality of education.

Nevertheless, the state Department of Education recommends that elementary schools on a year-round schedule be no larger than about 800 students, said Milton Wilson, a psychologist and state Department of Education consultant. Grade schools on a traditional schedule should be no larger than 600 students, according to state guidelines.


School City Grade Levels Enrollment 1) Miles Avenue School Huntington Park K-5 2,829 2) Hoover Street School Los Angeles K-5 2,380 3) Jenks East Elementary Jenks, Okla. K-5 2,293 4) Union Avenue School Los Angeles K-5 2,227 5) Hooper Avenue School Los Angeles K-6 2,217 6) Hobart Boulevard School Los Angeles K-6 2,204 7) Magnolia Avenue School Los Angeles K-5 2,136 8) Middleton St. School Huntington Park K-5 2,053 9) PS-189 New York City K-6 2,008 10) PS-86 New York City K-6 2,001

Source: U.S. Department of Education. Figures represent enrollments during the 1989-90 school year.

Copyright © 2019, Los Angeles Times
EDITION: California | U.S. & World