Advertisement

Man to Be Tried in Beating That Left Boy ‘Vegetative’ : Courts: Testimony from the tot’s twin sister is excluded by the judge. Fateheen Rahman is accused of attempted murder of the 4-year-old boy, who he says fell.

Share
TIMES STAFF WRITER

A Glendale man faces trial on attempted murder and child abuse charges, even though the prosecutor was unsuccessful in coaxing testimony from a 4-year-old girl--the only other person who witnessed an alleged June 12 beating that left her twin brother severely brain-damaged.

Fateheen Rahman, 22, who told police the boy hurt himself in a fall against a marble coffee table, will be arraigned later this month in Van Nuys Superior Court. After a preliminary hearing this week, Municipal Judge Jessica Perrin Silvers ordered him to stand trial on attempted murder and child endangerment charges.

So small that most courtroom observers could see only her blond curls as she climbed onto the witness stand, Jessica Thivener sang into the microphone, asked for her mother and said, “I want to see Jason.” She looked at pictures of twin brother Jason, who a doctor testified is “in a vegetative state”--perhaps permanently--from his injuries. She occasionally glanced at Rahman.

Advertisement

But she seemed afraid. She wouldn’t tell Deputy Dist. Atty. Lea Purwin D’Agostino what she, and she alone, had seen, despite the prosecutor’s gentle questions.

“Jason’s sleeping,” Jessica said before trying to run from the witness stand on Wednesday. “Is Jason hurt?” D’Agostino prodded, and the child replied, “Yes.”

But when asked how Jason had been hurt, Jessica said, “I don’t want to tell.”

The child’s age and reluctance left Silvers little choice but to exclude her testimony. Later, away from the courtroom and safe in the arms of her mother, Jessica again was asked what happened to Jason. “Fateheen,” she said, grabbing a toy clown by the neck and hurling it forcefully to the floor.

Silvers ordered Rahman, a native of Bangladesh, held on $500,000 bail. She also ordered him not to call or write the twins’ mother, Tammi Thivener, 25, of Van Nuys.

Outside the courtroom, Thivener said she blames herself for leaving her children with Rahman when she suddenly was called in to work at a department store where she had just gotten a job.

She had planned to marry him, she said, but “I don’t have any feelings for him right now. I can’t believe that someone so loving, so nice, could do something so horrible.”

Advertisement

Paramedic Dennis Archie testified that Rahman told him that the children had been playing and that Jason stopped breathing when Jessica sat on him. Archie also testified that he saw Rahman “strike the baby with his fists, harder than you or I would.”

Detective Irene Frizzell of the Los Angeles Police Department testified that Jessica had earlier told her that Rahman had choked them. The child first demonstrated by putting her hands around the detective’s neck, Frizzell testified. Later, she grabbed a Barbie doll by the neck and threw it to the floor, Frizzell said.

*

Frizzell recounted that when she interviewed Rahman in the Van Nuys Jail the day after Jason was injured, he “was crying and distraught.” He told her that he was tired and was trying to sleep on the couch, but the children were crying. He said he spanked them, and that made them cry more. The detective said he told her that he shook Jason, who broke free and accidentally banged his head on the coffee table.

Because of his brain injury, Jason will probably spend the rest of his life “in a vegetative state,” and his prognosis for recovery is grim, testified Antonio Galvis, a pediatrician at Childrens Hospital of Los Angeles. The 4-year-old underwent surgery for the second time Tuesday, so doctors could install a permanent shunt to drain from his skull the fluid that gathers there because of his injuries.

Galvis, on duty at the hospital when Jason arrived by helicopter June 12, said the boy’s brain was swelling so quickly his life was in danger.

Jason was bruised on the left side of his head, neck, face and ear. Tiny blood vessels in his face had ruptured, indicating he had been choked, Galvis said.

Advertisement

Questioned by defense attorney Richard S. Plotin, Galvis said he doubted Jason received his injuries by falling against a coffee table. He said the boy’s injuries were the type he usually sees “only in the ones who fall from buildings or are in automobile accidents.”

Outside of court, Thivener said she holds her son for hours at the hospital. It’s the only thing that seems to calm his whimpering.

“He’s lying there, his eyes are open, and he’s crying,” said Thivener. “I know he’s in pain, that he feels everything, every poke,” she said. “He needs a miracle. They said he’d die. For him to still be alive is a miracle.”

Plotin said outside court that Rahman felt so remorseful that Jason was injured under his care that he wrote Jason a letter. “He expressed his remorse and said he was sorry. He said he loved Jason and hopes he gets better,” the lawyer said.

“He feels devastated and ashamed,” Plotin said. “He never intended any injury. This is a tragedy for everybody concerned.”

Said Thivener: “Maybe he didn’t mean to do it, but he still did it.”

Advertisement