Powell to Step Down; Rice to Succeed Him

Times Staff Writers

Secretary of State Colin L. Powell, who often struggled for influence as the lone moderate in an administration dominated by foreign policy hawks, resigned Monday. National security advisor Condoleezza Rice will replace him, with an official announcement coming as early as today, senior officials said.

Rice, who is expected to be succeeded as head of the National Security Council by her deputy, Stephen J. Hadley, supported a hard-line approach to foreign policy during President Bush’s first term. A former provost of Stanford University and a specialist in Russian studies, she forged an unusually close relationship with Bush in the early days of his quest for the presidency.

Also on Monday, Agriculture Secretary Ann M. Veneman, Education Secretary Rod Paige and Energy Secretary Spencer Abraham submitted their resignations, as Bush continued to reshape the senior leadership of his administration on the eve of his second term.

Although postelection reshuffling had been expected, the departure of Powell and Atty. Gen. John Ashcroft, who announced his resignation last week, removes two of the heaviest hitters in the president’s Cabinet.


Powell, who served as chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff during the Persian Gulf War before being named the nation’s first black secretary of State, has been one of the most respected figures in the U.S. government both at home and abroad. His high standing in public opinion polls was not affected by his support for the Iraq war -- even after initial military successes gave way to chaos and continuing bloodshed.

In a statement, Bush hailed Powell, 67, as “one of the great public servants of our time,” saying: “He is a soldier, a diplomat, a civic leader, a statesman and a great patriot. I value his friendship. He will be missed.”

Defense Secretary Donald H. Rumsfeld -- who opposed Powell inside the administration on issues such as military policy in Iraq and U.S. relations with traditional allies -- praised the outgoing secretary of State on Monday and sought to dismiss the notion that they had a contentious history.

“He’s an enormously talented individual,” Rumsfeld said. “I’ve been kind of amused at the press’ desire to sell newsprint by constantly creating, trying to fabricate friction.”

Rumsfeld said give-and-take was natural among any president’s top advisors, calling it a “healthy thing” for the U.S. government.

The White House emphasized that Powell, Veneman, Paige and Abraham would remain at their posts until their successors were confirmed. “This will be a smooth process to get their replacements in position before these people leave,” White House press secretary Scott McClellan said.

McClellan rejected suggestions that Powell’s departure signaled the ascendancy of the hard-line foreign policy represented by Rumsfeld and Vice President Dick Cheney.

“That’s the typical D.C. speculation game that people like to engage in, no matter how wrong it is,” the press secretary said.


Yet despite the president’s praise, Powell’s cautious approach -- especially regarding the use of military power -- often was rejected.

Powell’s reputation was somewhat tarnished within the foreign policy community when, during the run-up to the Iraq war, he went before the United Nations and offered what he said was clear proof that Saddam Hussein had weapons of mass destruction -- proof that turned out to be based on flawed intelligence.

The resignations announced Monday were the latest in what will likely be a continuing exodus. Last week, in addition to Ashcroft, Commerce Secretary Don Evans announced that he intended to leave.

So far Bush has named only one replacement -- White House Chief Counsel Alberto R. Gonzales to take over for Ashcroft at the Justice Department. McClellan said White House Chief of Staff Andrew H. Card Jr., who Bush has announced will remain for a second term, was heading up the process of developing potential job candidates.


Although several of President Clinton’s Cabinet secretaries served the full eight years, the average tenure in recent history has been less than three years, said G. Calvin Mackenzie, a professor at Colby College in Maine who specializes in presidential appointments.

“These are hard, burnout jobs,” he said. “People typically come to these jobs later in their lives.... They’ve already accomplished a great deal. They’re not looking for merit badges. It’s not uncommon for them to do their job and then leave, and somebody else comes in.”

Mackenzie said one challenge facing Bush was to come up with Cabinet nominees who would not get entangled in partisan Senate confirmation battles. He predicted that at least some of the replacements would be officials now serving in the White House or in other government agencies, rather than high-profile outsiders.

Such officials can make appealing candidates because their strengths and weaknesses are known, and they provide policy continuity.


Towson University political scientist Martha Joynt Kumar said that Bush seemed to be moving quickly to assemble his second-term Cabinet so that attention could be focused on the administration’s policy agenda instead of personnel, as occurred during the lull between Clinton’s first and second terms.

“Their intention is to appoint their people by Thanksgiving. In the Clinton administration it was to do so by Christmas,” Kumar said. “Even though it’s only a month’s difference, it provides an opportunity to command the stage during a period when no one else in Washington is talking.”

But Paul Light, a professor of public service at New York University, warned that it may take significantly longer to fill an array of “sub-Cabinet” posts that were likely to become vacant as well.

“This is the beginning of a massive restructuring of the sub-Cabinet,” Light said. “But second-term presidents have only a very short time to make their mark.”


Other Cabinet secretaries who may resign soon, according to Washington insiders, include Homeland Security Chief Tom Ridge; Health and Human Services Secretary Tommy G. Thompson; U.S. trade representative Robert B. Zoellick; Labor Secretary Elaine Chao; and Transportation Secretary Norman Y. Mineta, the only Democrat in Bush’s cabinet.

Abraham leaves the Energy Department after a tenure marked by frustration. Despite Republican majorities in both the House and Senate, the administration failed to win congressional approval of Bush’s high-priority energy bill, which emphasized increased conservation but also increased energy production -- including drilling in Alaska’s Arctic National Wildlife Refuge.

Although Abraham, 52, a former Michigan senator, received mixed reviews as a salesman for Bush’s initiatives, some analysts said his role was overshadowed by the vice president’s involvement in formulating energy policy behind closed doors.

Abraham “shepherded Bush’s energy plan as well has he could,” said Philip K. Verleger Jr., an energy economist at the Institute for International Economics in Washington. “Cheney set the energy policy.”


Possible successors are said to include retiring Democratic Sen. John B. Breaux, a moderate from energy-rich Louisiana; Edison Electric Institute President Thomas Kuhn, who was a Bush classmate at Yale, and U.S. Ambassador to Mexico Tony Garza, a former Texas energy regulator.

As Agriculture secretary, Veneman, 55, led a sprawling agency with more than 100,000 employees and an annual budget exceeding $80 billion.

The daughter of a California peach grower, she headed the California Department of Food and Agriculture from 1995 to 1999.

Seen as an able farm trade negotiator and a loyal promoter of the president’s policies, Veneman was widely praised for the administration’s rapid response to the first reports of mad cow disease in the United States. But she also has drawn criticism for her role in the development of massive farm subsidy legislation that has undermined U.S. credibility in global trade talks.


One potential Veneman successor is said to be Rep. Charles W. Stenholm (D-Texas), a moderate who lost his reelection bid this month after 13 terms.

Other potential replacements include Agriculture Undersecretary William T. Hawks, U.S. agriculture trade negotiator Allen Johnson, White House agriculture advisor Chuck Conner, Agriculture Department conservation chief Bruce Knight, and Missouri Farm Bureau President Charles Kruze.

Paige, 71, the first African American to serve as the nation’s top education official, is best known for his role in promoting the president’s No Child Left Behind initiative, which imposed testing and accountability standards on elementary and middle schools.

A leading candidate to replace him is Bush’s chief domestic policy advisor, Margaret Spellings, who played a prominent role in the development of No Child Left Behind. Bush has said one of his top priorities for his second term is to expand the initiative to encompass the nation’s high schools.