Prosecutors have decided not to charge two El Monte Police Department officers who kicked a car chase suspect in the head and hit his arm with a flashlight as he was lying on the ground at the end of a televised high-speed pursuit, saying they used “reasonable” force.
The Los Angeles County district attorney’s office noted in its decision that officers George Fierro, 41, and James Singleterry, 40, were confronting a “highly dangerous and unpredictable” gang member who had evaded parole supervision and demonstrated no regard for human life during the 34-minute pursuit May 13.
Prosecutors said Fierro had reason to fear that the suspect, Richard Rodriguez, was positioning himself to attack or attempt to escape when he turned his head to face the officer while lying on the ground with his arms outstretched. Under such circumstances, they said, El Monte officers are trained to deliver a “distraction blow” -- in this case, a kick to the head -- to give them time to apply physical restraint.
Prosecutors said Singleterry struck Rodriguez’s right arm four times with the flashlight because the suspect had moved his hand under his body and was resisting being handcuffed.
Use-of-force experts have criticized the officers’ actions as unprovoked and unnecessary.
Samuel Walker, a criminology professor at the University of Nebraska, called Fierro’s reasoning for kicking Rodriguez in the head “a ridiculous rationalization.” He said the decision not to prosecute was “wrong in and of itself, and it also just confirms the belief among many in the community that officers are not going to be disciplined for excessive use of force.”
The American Civil Liberties Union of Southern California issued a statement Wednesday condemning the district attorney’s decision.
The incident began May 13 when gang officers spotted Rodriguez driving a 1992 Toyota Corolla with two passengers, who gave them “nervous” looks, prosecutors said.
According to an investigation by the L.A. County Sheriff’s Department, the officers were trying to determine if the car was stolen when Fierro noticed a 10-inch necklace hanging from the car’s rear view mirror, potentially obstructing the driver’s view, which is a traffic violation.
Fierro tried to pull the Corolla over, using his siren and emergency lights. But the vehicle sped off, blowing through stop signs and red lights at speeds up to 100 mph, prosecutors said. When it crashed into a Lincoln in the 9400 block of Whittier Boulevard, Rodriguez sprinted away on foot.
Prosecutors noted that Fierro was alone when he first cornered Rodriguez in the walled backyard of a condominium, and that the suspect hesitated before obeying Fierro’s instructions to “get on the ground.” The video footage shows Rodriguez turning to face Fierro as the officer approaches with his weapon drawn.
“Fearing that Rodriguez might try to get up to fight him, Fierro kicked Rodriguez on the right side of his face as a distraction blow to get him to submit to the arrest,” prosecutors said in their decision. “Rodriguez then slightly raised his upper torso as if to get up to fight, so Fierro pepper-sprayed him in the face.”
Medical records show that Rodriguez suffered “superficial abrasions” to the face.
Rodriguez pleaded guilty Aug. 6 to recklessly evading a law enforcement officer and was sentenced to four years in prison, prosecutors said.