Battle in Ohio reinforces GOP divide


Mitt Romney squeezed past Rick Santorum to win Ohio’s presidential primary, capturing the biggest Super Tuesday prize but raising enough doubts to quash hopes of quickly ending the Republicans’ bruising nominating fight.

A week after the former Massachusetts governor seemed to take command of the presidential race with victories in Arizona and, more significantly, his native state of Michigan, the contest was pitched into renewed upheaval.

With more than 99% of the Ohio votes counted, Romney was clinging to a narrow lead of about 12,000 votes.


The former Massachusetts governor also won five other states: Virginia, Vermont, Massachusetts, Idaho and Alaska, piling up nominating delegates in the process.

“We’re going to get more before this night is over,” Romney told cheering supporters in Boston, as the returns rolled in. “We’re on our way.”

His mood, however, appeared less celebratory than resigned to at least several more weeks of hard campaigning, which he and many in the party had desperately hoped to avoid.

Santorum won North Dakota, Oklahoma and Tennessee. The latter two denied Romney the Southern breakthrough he had sought to show his appeal among religious voters and cultural conservatives, underscoring their stubborn resistance toward his candidacy.

Santorum, speaking before the results in Ohio were known, struck a proud and defiant note.

“We’ve won races all across the country against the odds,” the former Pennsylvania senator said at a late-night rally in Steubenville, Ohio. “When they thought, OK, he’s finally finished, we keep coming back.”


Former House Speaker Newt Gingrich carried Georgia, home of the district he represented for years in Congress. He too said victory proved the naysayers wrong, and expressed his determination to fight on.

“I want you to know, in the morning, we are going to Alabama, we’re going on to Mississippi, we’re going on to Kansas — and that’s just this week,” Gingrich told cheering supporters in Atlanta, referring to the next sets of contests.

In all, voters in 10 states were casting ballots in Super Tuesday contests. But while Georgia dispensed the most delegates, the greatest attention was focused on Ohio, a November battleground where Romney and Santorum devoted the bulk of their time and resources.

Both candidates focused on the economy in a Rust Belt state that hurt long before the rest of the country sank into deep recession, then emerged to a fitful recovery.

Santorum touted his roots across the border in a Pennsylvania steel town, saying he would seek to strengthen the economy by restoring America’s manufacturing might. Romney unveiled a new slogan — “more jobs, less debt, smaller government” — and jabbed at Santorum’s digression into subjects like contraception and the separation of church and state.

“During this campaign there has been discussion about all sorts of issues,” Romney said in Canton. “I keep bringing it back to more jobs, less debt and smaller government. That’s what my campaign is about.”


Ohio is vital to GOP hopes of winning the White House: No Republican has even been elected president without carrying the state. Romney’s struggle to fend off Santorum — despite considerable advantages — seemed certain to seed further doubts about his ability to win over working-class and blue-collar voters who are vital to Republican success in the battleground states of the Midwest.

The results flashed other caution signs. Romney trailed Santorum and Gingrich, respectively, among the most conservatives voters in Ohio and Georgia, according to exit polls. He also showed continued weakness among evangelical Christians, perhaps because of concerns about his Mormon faith.

While those voters — who represent the base of the party — are likely to rally behind the eventual winner, the resistance has kept Romney from wrapping up the nominating fight as quickly as he would like.

The fourth candidate in the race, Rep. Ron Paul of Texas, was hoping for his first victory in one of the three caucus states. (Voters in Wyoming were also caucusing, but they will not finish for some time.) Paul, however, came up unavailing.

Overall, 437 delegates were at stake Tuesday, considerably more than in the 12 previous contests combined; 1,144 delegates are needed to secure the GOP nomination.

Even before the first ballots were cast, Romney was assured a victory in Tuesday’s delegate count, thanks in part to the organizational failings of his main rivals.


Paul was the only Republican other than Romney to qualify for the ballot in Virginia, one of the larger states voting Tuesday and another important target for both political parties in November. Santorum also forfeited more than a dozen Ohio delegates by failing to qualify representatives in several congressional districts, including the one in which he held his election-night party.

The shortfall underscored the advantage that Romney has maintained throughout the ups and downs of the turbulent nominating fight: his big financial and organizational advantages.

Both were brought to bear on Super Tuesday. Repeating a pattern seen throughout the contest, Romney vastly outspent Santorum on the television airwaves, strafing his chief rival with a relentless barrage of negative advertising.

Santorum sought to make Romney’s spending and attack ads an issue — as Gingrich had in earlier states — but most voters did not seem as upset.

Party leaders and other insiders have grown increasingly concerned, however, about the toll the contentious nominating fight has taken on the GOP and its candidates, reflected in polls showing gains by President Obama and increasingly sour views of the GOP field. That played to Romney’s benefit, as he continued to rack up endorsements from within the party establishment in recent days.

With a string of three wins — in Arizona, Michigan and Washington state — Romney increasingly sought to project an air of inevitability, hoping to hasten a close to the contest. His strategists, knowing he was sure to win the delegate count, insisted that was the chief arbiter of success Tuesday.


“More important than winning this state or that state is achieving the requisite number of delegates to achieve the nomination,” Eric Fehrnstrom, a Romney advisor, told reporters Monday as the candidate flew between stops in Georgia and Ohio. “That’s what our focus is.”

But there were many ways to slice Tuesday’s results and thus many ways for a candidate to claim victory and justify continuing to campaign, even if it becomes mathematically impossible for anyone but Romney to win the nomination outright.

So the race continues. Next up among the major contests are caucuses Saturday in Kansas, and on Tuesday, primaries in Alabama and Mississippi and caucuses in Hawaii.

Times staff writers John Hoeffel in Vinings, Ga., Seema Mehta in Steubenville, Ohio, and Maeve Reston in Boston contributed to this report.