Elon Musk pits an army of Tesla fans against Wall Street analysts, short sellers
On Feb. 2, the day before Tesla’s stock would rocket to a new high, Chief Executive Elon Musk announced an event at his house for computer programmers on Twitter and invited Vivien Hantusch, a student in Germany, to attend.
Hantusch, who studies product design, will sell a single share in Tesla to buy her flight from Düsseldorf to California to take part, she said. Musk frequently responds to her tweets, but “he hasn’t told us anything yet” about the event.
Hantusch is part of a global Tesla fan base who own the electric car maker’s stock and champion the views of Musk online. They also fight back against Tesla detractors, such as the short sellers who have sparred online with Musk for years and bet that Tesla’s shares will fall.
“It was the first stock I ever invested in — with Tesla, I felt I had to support the company, especially [given] the short sellers,” said Hantusch, who bought the shares in 2018. “I don’t do this to get a profit or a job, I do this because I love the company.”
It’s a sunny day in March and “Machine Planet” is flying a single-engine Cessna over Northern California.
In November Hantusch and a group of Tesla fans launched Third Row, a podcast focused on the company. Last month they recorded an episode with Musk in one of his Los Angeles houses, the former home of Gene Wilder on the slopes of Bel-Air. Musk brought his dog, Marvin the Martian, and his mother, Maye Musk, the fashion model, who also brought her dog.
“The dogs were running around and Marvin the Martian was sitting on my lap,” said Sofiaan Fraval, a software engineer in Santa Barbara, who produces the podcast and also owns a Tesla and stock in the company. “That was so cool.”
Tesla’s online fan base has spawned podcasts, dedicated channels on YouTube and an incessant stream of social media posts that frame the company as an agent of change at the crossroads of technology and the environment, not simply a carmaker struggling to turn a profit.
In nurturing this group of supporters with daily tweets and face-to-face meet-ups, Musk has struck a chord with his customers and retail shareholders. In the process, he has built an arsenal of defenders who amplify his views online and take up arms against critics.
Last month Tesla announced a $105-million fourth-quarter profit that set the share price alight. On Feb. 4 the stock hit a new high of $887 before easing later in the week. At their Monday close of $771.28, the shares have gained 84% so far this year. These types of moves are driven by institutional investors and momentum-driven automated trading strategies, but retail investors also play a role. Tesla is the 15th most held stock by investors on the Robinhood stock trading app, with more than 150,000 users owning its shares.
Electric vehicles can cut greenhouse gases and carmakers have big plans for them. But so far, few car buyers want them.
The rising price marks a win for Musk against the short sellers and skeptical Wall Street analysts who complain about the company’s financial picture.
The billionaire founder has stoked an “us versus them” war between his retail investor and car-owner fan base and Wall Street. In 2018 he stated in a tweet that he had secured funding to take Tesla private at $420 a share. In the discussion online that followed, he promised retail investors that he would find a way to keep them on as shareholders. The funding was not secured, and Musk later settled claims with the Securities and Exchange Commission over the episode.
On a public conference call to discuss Tesla’s earnings, Musk said many retail investors “have better insights than many of the analysts.” In 2018 he declined to respond to one analyst’s question, saying, “boring, bonehead questions are not cool,” and spoke at length instead to Galileo Russell, a retail investor.
Russell has since launched a dedicated YouTube channel called HyperChangeTV, where he speaks supportively of Tesla. The channel has become a full-time job delivering “six-figure revenue,” he said. He has met Musk multiple times, had a private tour of a Tesla factory and has partnered with a start-up to crowd-source questions from retail investors to pose during Tesla’s earnings calls.
A growing army of hot rodders is cannibalizing crashed electric cars and turning them into custom vehicles with electric power trains.
“I think the Wall Street complex is crumbling,” Russell said. “People don’t listen to analysts anymore because they were wrong on one of the biggest, most disruptive companies in this era, potentially in this whole century.”
Toby Clothier of Mirabaud Securities in London is one such analyst. His sober views of Tesla based on its financial data indicate the current stock price has detached from reality. He points to weakening market share in Europe and a fear the profit generated in the fourth quarter will wither. But he has adapted to the rally.
“We have prefaced virtually all of our work on this stock for the last month with the caveat that this stock has developed a life of its own,” he said.
Clothier worries retail investors will buy the stock after the sharp rise of recent weeks just in time for it to lose value. “There is a dream aspect to this whole story that has nothing to do with what is happening now,” he said.
“It’s strange, I’m a 38-year-old man and I’m getting excited when a middle-aged man responds to me on Twitter.”
— Sam Kelly, Tesla car owner and shareholder
Sam Kelly, a U.K. expat who lives outside Valencia in Spain, owns Tesla stock and a Tesla car. He frequently posts positive news about the company on Twitter, where Musk has responded to his tweets.
“He’s a geeky guy like the rest of us, and that’s why I think people feel that connection with him,” he said. “It’s strange, I’m a 38-year-old man and I’m getting excited when a middle-aged man responds to me on Twitter.”
These Tesla supporters acknowledge their support is beneficial to Musk and Tesla, but insist the interactions with the billionaire are genuine.
“We’re not being used,” said Fraval, from the Third Row podcast. “We love this technology, and we really appreciate what Elon is doing.”
© The Financial Times Ltd. 2020. All rights reserved. FT and Financial Times are trademarks of the Financial Times Ltd. Not to be redistributed, copied or modified in any way.
The view from Sacramento
For reporting and exclusive analysis from bureau chief John Myers, get our California Politics newsletter.
You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times.