Homeless people face relentless abuse in Lancaster, an ACLU report alleges

During the 2016 homeless census, Derrick Chambers checks out an encampment in Lancaster
During the 2016 homeless census, Derrick Chambers performs a count of homeless people at an encampment in an open area of southern Lancaster.
(Irfan Khan / Los Angeles Times)

A report released Monday by the American Civil Liberties Union of Southern California alleges widespread abuse of homeless people in the Mojave Desert city of Lancaster.

Sheriff’s deputies contracted by the city routinely push homeless people into the inhospitable desert, where they often face additional pressure from county officials, the report contends.

The report, “Banished and Abandoned,” describes a “dragnet of criminalization” within the city limits in which deputies and city code enforcement officers “regularly bulldoze encampments of unhoused people and order them to move by threat of citation.”


The actions push them out of the city into remote areas where they have to walk long distances for water and food, the report said.

ACLU researchers said they analyzed public records, including two years of misdemeanor citations, and interviewed 53 homeless in preparing the report. They found that citations were disproportionately issued against homeless people.

Lancaster Mayor R. Rex Parris defended the city’s procedures, which, he said, are consistent with a 9th Circuit Court of Appeals ruling in the case of Martin vs. City of Boise, which found that the arrest of homeless people for sleeping in public was unconstitutional if no other place to live can be provided.

Boise is a midsize city with a manageable homeless population. But it is setting standards for how much bigger cities deal with homeless encampments.

Oct. 15, 2019

Parris said the city has done more than its share to serve its homeless population, having opened the Kensington Campus, a 14-acre complex with a shelter, permanent housing, jobs, counseling and other services.

“I’m trying to create an environment where people who are disabled can thrive,” Parris said. “I’m not going to just let people live wherever they want, camp where they want, extort money from people who are shopping.”

The report follows a lawsuit filed earlier this month in Superior Court by the ACLU and the UC Irvine Consumer Law Clinic alleging that Lancaster’s practice of assessing fines of up to $1,000 for violations of anti-homeless laws is unconstitutional.


The lawsuit alleges that people are cited for sleeping in a vacant lot or even sitting outside “without a reason.” The penalty is $500 for a first citation and $1,000 for a second. Full payment is required before an appeal can be filed.

Lancaster has proposed changes to the municipal code that would prohibit charitable groups from feeding homeless people in almost every public space.

Dec. 14, 2019

ACLU senior staff attorney Adrienna Wong said the lawsuit developed independently over an incident in which the plaintiff, 68-year-old Leroy Butts, was cited while passing out pamphlets in Lancaster Park

Parris said the law has been amended to allow hearing officers to waive the fine, and that full payment is no longer required to appeal.