Review: L.A. Phil, Dudamel reinvigorate Tchaikovsky’s ‘Nutcracker’

Gustavo Dudamel is the dad of a son turning 3 in April, the husband of a classically trained ballet dancer, and a Tchaikovsky nut whose next big project will be a “TchaikovskyFest” with the Los Angeles Philharmonic and the Simón Bolívar Orchestra in late February.

This year also happens to be the first time he is in Los Angeles for concerts during the holiday season. It is no surprise, then, that Thursday night Dudamel warmed up his Tchaikovsky with the first of four performances of “The Nutcracker” at Walt Disney Concert Hall Thursday night.

Nor is it any surprise that Dudamel makes “The Nutcracker” irresistible. He recognizes everything interesting in it. He overcomes pretty much all of the ballet’s problems that can be overcome, including a few that I thought couldn’t be. Yet another non-surprise is Dudamel’s tendency to savor every Tchaikovskian second. But the real marvel of his performance was that more than anything else this season it revealed a young conductor’s growing maturity as an interpreter, a maturity that arises from, rather than surmounts, boyish enthusiasm.

CRITICS’ PICKS: What to watch, where to go, what to eat


The first joy is that this concert performance of the “Nutcracker” is about the music, not the Petipa’s ballet that had its only mildly successful premiere at the Mariinsky in St. Petersburg in 1892. The L.A. Phil program does not list the dances. There are complete program notes, but following along as you listen is really not possible. For those many for whom the images of dancing snowflakes, the Sugar Plum Fairy and violence to mice are inextricably connected to the music, this will be a revelation.

Seeing and hearing a large and great orchestra in Disney Hall is a radically different experience from seeing the ballet accompanied by a lackadaisical pit band, to say nothing for the increasingly common use of recorded music by dance companies. Dudamel all but liberates the score from the dance.

The tempos are far too fleet for children on stage to ever manage. Physical a conductor Dudamel may be, he offers here the grace of sound waves, unlike a leaping ballerina, barely gravity-bound. Joy flows very easily from this.

PHOTOS: Arts and culture in pictures by The Times

Dudamel’s maturity shows in the broad symphonic scope that he brings to the score. There is no need to wait for staging needs or applause after each dance (although there was some of that in Disney on Thursday), and Dudamel, a once episodic conductor, now made each of the two 45-minute acts flow as a whole more successfully than I have heard before.

He did, of course, exalt in Tchaikovsky’s exuberant orchestral colors. The Waltz of the Flowers was utterly gorgeous and goose-bump grand. The Spanish Dance brought out Dudamel’s trademark Venezuelan fire. The snowflakes were exquisite. It was all there, all the traditional “Nutcracker” anyone could ever desire, including too many musical sweets.

The Los Angeles Children’s Chorus in red vests marched out for the end of Act I. The beaming kids, with but a few seconds to prepare for their cue, added wonderfully, to borrow from Orrin Howard’s lovely description in the program notes, waltzing wordless sighs.

CHEAT SHEET: Holiday arts preview


But anything rhythmically or instrumentally novel in the music was also there. This was an L.A. Phil “Nutcracker” all the way. Dudamel took full advantage of his orchestra’s flexibility and modern sound. Next week he conducts Stravinsky, but this, too, was a kind of Stravinskian Tchaikovsky, completely fresh.

Tchaikovsky’s score became also, in the proper spirit of this time of the year, a great occasion to draw attention to some of the players who don’t regularly get it. Sarah Jackson’s piccolo supplied the gobs of necessary sparkle. Principal percussionist Raynor Carroll provided the pistol shot, vaulting castanets and supernaturally shimmering cymbals. Lou Anne Neill’s harp solo was sheer abracadabra.

For final proof that Dudamel has produced a Scrooge shield with his “Nutcracker,” there was this — big, broad smiles on faces of the musicians trained to be stony. Walking off stage, Dudamel high-fived an audience member. You might want to see if any of seats in the front row are available for the remaining performances through Sunday. The L.A. Phil is recording the performances for possible future release.



‘The Nutcracker’

Where: Los Angeles Philharmonic, Walt Disney Concert Hall, downtown L.A.

When: 8 p.m Saturday and 2 p.m. Sunday


Cost: $82.50-$205

Info: (323) 850-2000 or