Which Toronto International Film Festival movies are Oscar material?

“The Imitation Game”
With a cast including Keira Knightley, Matthew Beard, Matthew Goode, Allen Leech and Benedict Cumberbatch, “The Imitation Game” could be a best-picture Oscar contender.
(Jack English, The Weinstein Co.)

The Toronto International Film Festival, which kicks off Thursday and runs through Sept. 14, is a key indicator not only of the upcoming fall movies but of the awards season. Eight of the last nine best picture Oscar winners built awards-season momentum at the festival.

There are any number of hopefuls in this year’s TIFF lineup, but some films have better chances than others of breaking through. A positive response — enthusiastic crowds, strong early reviews — can boost a film’s awards trajectory. A negative response can mean a failure to launch.

What movies might be this year’s beneficiaries? Here’s a look at the promise of some of the high-profile titles playing at the festival.

‘The Theory of Everything’


Premise: Theoretical physicist Stephen Hawking (Eddie Redmayne) gets the biopic treatment, focusing on his relationship with his first wife (Felicity Jones), his ALS diagnosis and subsequent struggles and triumphs.

Pedigree: Director James Marsh directed the Oscar-winning documentary “Man on Wire,” demonstrating the ability to deftly convey a complex, true story.

Best case: Redmayne shoots to the top of the lead actor field with costar Jones finally earning mainstream acclaim.

Worst case: Critics spend more effort debunking the film’s veracity (the couple’s marriage ended in an acrimonious divorce) than they do praising its quality.


‘The Imitation Game’

Premise: Brilliant, asocial mathematician Alan Turing (Benedict Cumberbatch) leads British effort to crack Nazi Germany’s Enigma code and shorten World War II.

Pedigree: Period, Anglo-centric movie from the Weinstein Co., the studio that took “The King’s Speech” to the best picture winner’s circle.

Best case: Crowd-pleaser cheered by audiences; critics respond to film’s measured handling of Turing’s personal story of being a closeted gay man.

Worst case: More “Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy” than “The King’s Speech” with star Cumberbatch generating buzz but the movie failing to catch on.

‘St. Vincent’

Premise: Cranky old-timer (Bill Murray) learns that his life has meaning through the help of a 12-year-old neighbor boy.

Pedigree: Murray has just one Oscar nomination (“Lost in Translation”) to show for a career filled with iconic performances. Can you say “overdue”?


Best case: Movie’s third-act emotional roundhouse connects, leaving audiences awash in tears and Murray accepting accolades.

Worst case: Reviews aren’t much better than the last time Murray took a movie to Toronto (“Hyde Park on Hudson”).


Premise: Troubled woman (Reese Witherspoon) takes tortuous, transformative hike on the Pacific Crest Trail following her mother’s death.

Pedigree: Director Jean-Marc Vallee’s last movie, “Dallas Buyer’s Club,” won acting Oscars for Matthew McConaughey and Jared Leto.

Best case: All right, all right, all right! Witherspoon becomes a regular on the awards-season dinner circuit, as does Laura Dern, who plays the mother in flashbacks.

Worst case: Witherspoon is seen as too old and not entirely convincing in flashback scenes highlighting character’s drug-addicted past.

‘Men, Women & Children’


Premise: Men, women and, yes, children deal with Internet angst in this dramedy about the high-tech ways people relate (or fail to) these days.

Pedigree: Co-writer and director Jason Reitman has four Oscar nominations. Last time he teamed with Jennifer Garner (“Juno”), good things happened.

Best case: Movie hailed as Reitman’s return to form after last year’s Toronto misfire “Labor Day.” There’s even awards buzz around star Adam Sandler.

Worst case: Online reaction toxic. Worst. Movie. Ever.

‘Black and White’

Premise: A custody battle between an attorney (Kevin Costner) and the paternal grandmother (Octavia Spencer) of a biracial child provides the framework for an examination of race.

Pedigree: Costner and Spencer both have Oscars; director Mike Binder has done decent work on thorny subjects such as marital rancor (“The Upside of Anger”) and grief (“Reign Over Me”).

Best case: Strong reviews propel Lionsgate to finalize distribution deal and get behind an awards-season push for the film and its actors.

Worst case: Movie’s handling of race will bear extra scrutiny in wake of Ferguson, Mo., events. Can it handle that weight?

‘The Judge’

Premise: Jaded L.A. lawyer (Robert Downey Jr.) returns to his rural roots to defend — and make amends with — his estranged father (Robert Duvall).

Pedigree: Downey and Duvall have eight Oscar nominations between them, with Duvall winning 20 years ago for “Tender Mercies.”

Best case: Critics welcome Downey as a prodigal son returning from the Comic-Con stratosphere to high-end drama. He and Duvall join the Oscar conversation.

Worst case: Too Grisham-y to be taken seriously. When’s that next “Avengers” movie, again?

Get our daily Envelope newsletter

The Awards and Industry Insider brings you exclusive awards season coverage, the business of show business and more.

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times.