These two new movies go inside the horrors of Auschwitz
It’s a wound that can never seem to heal over, and some would argue that it should never be allowed to — that keeping it fresh keeps it from ever happening again. The directors of “Labyrinth of Lies” and “Son of Saul” would likely agree. Their movies, leading contenders for the foreign-language film Oscar, manage to find new ways to plunge us into the civilization-wide madness that was the Holocaust.
Both pictures examine the infamous death factory known as Auschwitz, but with different approaches. As “Labyrinth” director and co-writer Giulio Ricciarelli says, his jumping-offpoint was discovering his own ignorance.
He discovered, as does his protagonist, idealistic young prosecutor Johann, that German postwar schooling actively papered over the worst atrocities of the Nazis. Johann must learn what happened in the camps by taking survivors’ testimonies as he tries to bring Auschwitz war criminals to justice. Johann, a composite character inspired by actual prosecutors (including one Gerhard Wiese) in the early 1960s Auschwitz trials, digs into the extremely uncomfortable pasts of friends, neighbors and family.
“It’s almost unbelievable, the story,” Ricciarelli says of the notion that so many Germans could be ignorant of what happened. “But that’s the reason to make the film.”
In “Labyrinth,” the face of the resistance to Johann’s inquiries is a senior prosecutor, who asks, “Is it truly important that every son in Germany should wonder if his father was a murderer?” It’s a question also in the documentary “What Our Fathers Did: A Nazi Legacy,” and one that haunted a generation of Germans.
(Ben Glass / Orion Pictures Corp.)
The very first best picture winner stars Charles “Buddy” Rogers and Richard Arlen as two hometown boys whose rivalry for the affections of a girl, played by Clara Bow, carries them from America to the war in France against the Germans.(AP)
The German side of WWI is portrayed in this film adaptation of author Erich Maria Remarque’s famed novel. The academy presented it awards for best picture and best director, Lewis Milestone.(UCLA Film & Television Archive)
Producer David O. Selznick’s epic Civil War romance brought Scarlett O’Hara (Vivien Leigh) and Rhett Butler (Clark Gable) to the big screen. Despite a troubled production, the film was a box office triumph and went on to win 10 Academy Awards.(AP)
Director William Wyler’s film shows the day-to-day life of an upper-middle-class British family in England during the early days of World War II. It starred Greer Garson, right, and Teresa Wright and won six Academy Awards, including best picture.(AP)
War-torn North Africa is the setting for this classic best picture winner about an American expat named Rick (Humphrey Bogart) who reunites with his former lover, Ilsa (Ingrid Bergman), who is fleeing the Nazis with her husband.(AP)
Gregory Peck has a word with other officers -- Gary Merrill, left, Hugh Marlowe and Dean Jagger -- before a B–17 bombing raid in “12 O’Clock High.” The best picture nominee centered on the Allied airmen who conducted daylight bombing raids against Nazi Germany in the early days of WWII.(Twentieth Century Fox)
Henry Fonda, left, William Powell and Jack Lemmon joined James Cagney in this best picture nominee about a cargo ship attempting to steer clear of conflict in the final days of WWII.(Warner Bros.)
David Lean’s best picture winner stars Alec Guinness, right, as a prisoner in a Japanese POW camp tasked with building the titular bridge -- not knowing, of course, that his own military is planning to destroy it.(Keystone-France / Gamma-Keystone via Getty Images)
The David Lean-directed biopic stars Peter O’Toole as T. E. Lawrence, the British army officer who took part in the Arab Revolt against the Ottoman Turks during WWI. Nominated for 10 Oscars, it won seven, including best picture.(Michael Ochs Archives / Getty Images)
George C. Scott starred as controversial U.S. Gen. George S. Patton. The film won seven Oscars, although Scott refused to accept his lead actor award.(Silver Screen Collection / Getty Images)
Robert Altman’s anarchic war comedy, starring Elliot Gould, left, Tom Skerritt and
(Andrew Cooper / AP)
Based on the novel by Michael Ondaatje, this best picture winner stars Ralph Fiennes as an injured Hungarian geographer who ends up in the care of Juliette Binoche’s French-Canadian nurse.(Phil Bray / Miramax)
(David James )
After a 20-year absence, writer-director Terrence Malick returned to filmmaking with this WWII epic, boasting a huge cast of stars. It was nominated for seven Oscars, including best picture.(Merie W. Wallace / Fox 2000)
Benedict Cumberbatch, pictured, appeared in Steven Spielberg’s best picture nominee, which follows the journeys of a WWI cavalry mount.(Kathy Kennedy / DreamWorks)
“When I was 8, somebody brought a pack of pictures from Auschwitz to school and I was devastated. I couldn’t believe it. I couldn’t believe my eyes. I was really devastated,” says Ricciarelli.
“In a way, that feeling has never left me. I know it happened. I know what happened. But I cannot understand it.”
Whereas the beautifully photographed “Labyrinth” unfolds in a familiar genre — the crusading lawyer’s investigation — “Son of Saul” takes on the abomination from a different angle: inside the beast.
The titular Saul is a member of the Sonderkommando, groups of prisoners at Auschwitz and other death camps who were forced to participate in the herding of other prisoners into the gas chambers, rifle through their belongings and dispose of their remains. Director and co-writer László Nemes drops the viewer into the experience, using hand-held, close-to-the-subject camera work with short focus to reveal information only as Saul receives it. Sound design by Tamás Zányi simultaneously immerses the viewer in the soul-destroying machinery and increases the desperate disorientation that strips the prisoners of their humanity.
“The very starting point was when I read the so-called Scrolls of Auschwitz, the manuscript of the Sonderkommando, which they put in the ground and were found after the war,” says Nemes. “These texts are so immersive. It transports you as a reader directly to the heart of the extermination machine. You feel it is happening here and now.”
One result is a deeper understanding of how prisoners could bring themselves to serve in the Sonderkommando. The deeply traumatized Saul emotionlessly goes about his frenzied work until a discovery sends him on a near-impossible quest.
“All these things combine to deprive the individual of thinking. The individual can only feel. The ‘thinking’ comes from the postwar [looks back at history]. People become sort of robots. That was also something that guided us: how to be in the scenes and not project postwar emotion onto this.”
The immediate, real-time feeling of the film necessitated realistic locations, so a concentration camp set was constructed in Eastern Europe.
“I think it was difficult for everybody to be there,” says Nemes. “It was not in a studio. All the levels were interconnected. We had the feeling of being in a real place, not on a movie set. I think it was difficult, but they had a sense of mission. It was part of the experience.”
For Ricciarelli, one of the highlights of the “Labyrinth” process was working with Wiese, a leader of the team that brought about the first war-crimes trials of a nation against its own soldiers.
The filmmaker says the trials were Wiese’s “life’s work, and it basically was forgotten. Now, we had an opening night in Frankfurt and an 87-year-old man who gets a standing ovation for what he did. He told me his grandchildren said, ‘Oh, Grandfather was a hero!’ But he was kind of a forgotten hero.
“And he’s in the film. Just before they enter the court — we had always rehearsed it that he was the last guy to get in, to get a seat. But the one take that was perfect, somehow he didn’t make it into the courtroom,” Ricciarelli says with a laugh. “He’s the small guy with the hat, and he gets shut out. That’s Gerhard Wiese.”
From the Emmys to the Oscars.
Get our revamped Envelope newsletter for exclusive awards season coverage, behind-the-scenes insights and columnist Glenn Whipp’s commentary.
You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times.