Review: Doc ‘Whale of a Tale’ is too low-key to make its point
As influential documentaries go, few have achieved the outrage-fostering success of 2009’s Oscar-winning “The Cove,” which spotlit the barbaric-sounding practice of engineered dolphin slaughter/capture in the town of Taiji, Japan, and made lifelong fishermen into ready-made villains.
But filmmaker Megumi Sasaki sees a more complicated standoff in this environmentally framed fight between Western activists and the Japanese traditions of dolphin and whale hunting, and her tempered answer-doc, “A Whale of a Tale,” tries to frame that debate in a way that paints it as global versus local, contextualizing Taiji’s whale-centric history as a story of sustenance and culture, while showing visiting protesters as impassioned, but also occasionally invasive and crass bullies.
With Japanese-speaking, mediating American journalist Jay Alabaster as an occasional on-camera guide, Sasaki’s movie explores a middle ground — respect for sensitivities and an acceptance of realities (Japan eats less and less whale meat each year) — that could have prevented Taiji from being turned into a high-tension town out of an old western.
But Sasaki is also strangely vague on where she stands on the things “The Cove” cared about: the gruesome killing of highly intelligent animals and their being sold into water-park lives of ritualized abuse. Its cooler-heads heart is in the right place, but “A Whale of a Tale” is an unfortunately directionless, low-gear rebuttal that hardly ever stirs up emotions as effectively as “The Cove” did.
‘A Whale of a Tale’
In Japanese and English with English subtitles
Running time: 1 hour, 37 minutes
Playing: Starts Aug. 24, Laemmle Music Hall, Beverly Hills
Only good movies
Get the Indie Focus newsletter, Mark Olsen's weekly guide to the world of cinema.
You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times.