Filmmaker says Beyonce stole his ideas to make ‘Lemonade’

Beyoncé's ‘Lemonade’
Beyoncé, center, poses with some of the women featured in “Lemonade.”
(Parkwood Entertainment)

An independent filmmaker filed a federal lawsuit against Beyoncé on Wednesday alleging that ideas from his 2014 short film were used to create the trailer that accompanied her new visual album “Lemonade.” 

Matthew Fulks alleges in his lawsuit that his 2014 short film, “Palinoia,” had been seen by members of the team working on the “Lemonade” video and that Beyoncé's video was created months later and was “visually similar.”

Fulks, who lives in Louisville, Ky., alleges that the pop singer and her management company, Parkwood Entertainment, as well as Sony Music Entertainment and Columbia Recording Corp., infringed on his copyright. 

The lawsuit, filed in U.S. District Court in Manhattan, points to nine instances — about 39 seconds of the 65-second trailer — that Fulks says are visually similar. It seeks unspecified monetary damages. 


The “Lemonade” trailer is “substantially similar” to Fulks’ film, including a similar mood, setting, pace and fonts, he says in the lawsuit. 

The video, posted on YouTube on April 17, had received nearly 11 million views by Wednesday afternoon. 

Representatives for Beyoncé and the corporations did not immediately respond to requests for comment Thursday. 



Meet the L.A. director who helped make Beyoncé's ‘Lemonade’

Beyoncé's superpower: Keeping us guessing as she takes charge of her narrative

Hey L.A., what does ‘black girl magic’ mean to you?

Beyoncé has long found strength in secrecy and silence

Get our daily Entertainment newsletter