Editorial: State law trumps antiabortion centers’ attempts at obfuscation
This year state lawmakers moved to counteract the troubling and deceptive practices employed by some “crisis pregnancy” centers to deter women from considering an abortion. Their response — the Reproductive FACT Act, which Gov. Jerry Brown recently signed into law — requires licensed facilities primarily offering family planning or pregnancy-related services to notify customers that the state offers free or low-cost access to a variety of family planning services, including abortion, and to provide a phone number for the local county social services office. Unlicensed facilities offering pregnancy-related services must provide notice that they are not licensed by the state as medical facilities and have no medical personnel overseeing services.
Now, two religiously affiliated nonprofits that operate free pregnancy counseling services have filed suit, seeking an injunction to halt the law from going into effect in January. The plaintiffs — A Woman’s Friend Pregnancy Resource Clinic and Crisis Pregnancy Center of Northern California — argue that requiring such disclosure violates their 1st Amendment rights because it forces them to contradict their religious principles and their antiabortion message to clients.
But this is not a case of religiously affiliated businesses being forced by law to operate against their beliefs. The law ensures that every licensed facility that sets itself up as a pregnancy counseling center lets women know that all types of family planning and pregnancy counseling are available in the state at little or no cost. That’s a legitimate use of the state’s power to regulate public health facilities, not the state compelling speech.
Antiabortion practitioners have the right to make their argument against abortion, but not to bamboozle women to advance their cause. The state can and should make sure pregnancy counseling facilities that operate under a state license tell their clients where to get accurate information about the full range of options.
A cure for the common opinion
Get thought-provoking perspectives with our weekly newsletter.
You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times.