In California, Republicans are divided over McCarthy’s deal to avoid government shutdown

Two vehicles and a crowd of people outside in a sea of Trump banners and American flags
Supporters of former President Trump rallied Friday outside the California Republican Convention in Anaheim.
(Myung J. Chun / Los Angeles Times)

As House Speaker Kevin McCarthy was turning to Democrats for help passing a stopgap government funding bill, his fellow California Republicans were busy at the party’s state convention in Anaheim, bantering about the party’s platform and ogling presidential candidates.

McCarthy’s deal to fund the government through mid-November passed the House with more support from Democrats than Republicans, demonstrating his inability to hold his caucus together on key votes. Ninety Republicans opposed the measure.

The short-term funding bill, which passed the Senate on Saturday night and was later signed by President Biden, avoiding a government shutdown, excluded support for Ukraine.

Congress has voted to prevent a government shutdown. But House Speaker Kevin McCarthy had to rely on Democrats to get the bill to President Biden’s desk.

Sept. 30, 2023


Attendees at the state Republican Party convention were just as divided as their representatives in Congress.

Cynthia Kaui, 28, president of San Diego Young Republicans, said the club’s members are mixed about whether to send more aid to Ukraine. Support for Ukraine is divided sharply along ideological lines, with 62% of conservatives believing the U.S. is doing too much to support the nation against Russia’s invasion, compared with just 17% of liberals, according to an ABC/Washington Post poll released this week.

More important than any particular aspect of the spending bill, Kaui said, was that Democrats and Republicans work together to keep the government operating.

“That’s one thing, in general on the national side, that we’ve lost sight of, is the ability to have discourse and dialogue,” Kaui said. “I hope ultimately that both of the sides can come together and compromise.”

A government shutdown could negatively affect Republican candidates’ chances in next year’s elections. A Morning Consult Pro poll released Tuesday indicated that 34% of voters would blame a government shutdown on congressional Republicans, compared with 23% who’d put the onus on Biden, and 21% who’d blame Democrats in Congress.

There are moments when it’s important for Republicans to take a stand and draw attention to budgets they see as bloated and social programs they consider problematic, Sacramento County Republican Party Chair Betsy Mahan told The Times as she stood in line for a platform committee meeting.


This, she said, was not one of those moments.

“There are a few people holding it up over purity tests,” she said of the funding. “It’s fine to speak up, but you need to go along with everyone else at some point.”

GOP delegate Randall Jordan of Paso Robles disagreed.

“I don’t believe in the big tent. I believe in a tent that will house like-minded people,” he said.

Jordan, who owns a construction company, said that when there is a downturn or he can’t meet his budget, he lays people off. He acknowledged that a shutdown could put some Republicans in swing districts at risk. But one has to happen, he said.

“In the short run, I think it could hurt us,” he added. “But I still believe that most of our citizens are conservative, and it will be OK.”

Generally, attendees to the weekend convention seemed more concerned with the spectacle of visiting presidential candidates or local matters than the budget battle happening across the country.

A woman in red, white and blue seen in the gap between two red vehicles as she rolls by with a speaker strapped to a scooter
Kimberly Nguyen of North Pasadena arrives at the California Republican Party Convention in Anaheim on Friday.
(Christina House / Los Angeles Times)

“Today the real threat to us is not even from Congress on the eve of whatever artificial shutdown debate they are having at a given hour today,” GOP presidential candidate Vivek Ramaswamy said to a luncheon crowd of about 500 people Saturday. “That’s not the real threat we face. The real threat we face in the United States is the rise of that managerial class from our universities to corporate America to the ultimate model of that managerial class in the administrative state in the federal government today.”

In particular, convention attendees were caught up Saturday with a vote on whether to change the state party’s platform to make it more welcoming to LGBTQ+ people. That effort failed, frustrating some delegates who had hoped to see the party remove language that says “it is important to define marriage as a union between one man and one woman.”

“This will hamstring California’s Republican Party as voters wonder what decade the party is focused on ... the past over the future,” said Charles Moran, a Los Angeles County delegate and president of Log Cabin Republicans, a national group representing LGBTQ+ conservatives and their allies.

The proposed platform overhaul by the California GOP would be a remarkable break from conservative dogma in the state that nurtured Presidents Ronald Reagan and Richard Nixon.

Aug. 18, 2023

Covina Mayor Walt Allen said that, as a former FBI employee, he feels for the families who could yet face a government shutdown if no deal is reached in November. But he said the government has to send a message about the nation’s “tremendous deficit.”

“So I’m hoping that there’s going to be a resolution brought to bear. I know Kevin McCarthy is trying real hard to have a united front and to not shut the government down,” Allen said, before acknowledging that the Bakersfield Republican had lost the support of several hard-right members of his caucus.

Green branches frame several stories of a hotel with curving balconies, two of them draped with American and California flags
Flags hang from balconies of guest rooms at the Anaheim Marriott Hotel during the California Republican Party Convention.
(Christina House / Los Angeles Times)

Montecito resident Thomas Cole, 66, who said he is planning to run for Congress next year against incumbent Rep. Salud Carbajal (D-Santa Barbara), said it would be fine with him if the government were to shut down, which he hoped would send a message to voters that they should be concerned about the national debt.

“I’m not worried about [a possible shutdown]. I’m sorry a few people won’t get their paychecks on time, but they all get paid eventually,” Cole said. “The government is way too big, in my opinion, so let it shut down. … Let them have a break from spending money.”

Convention delegate Beth Holder said Saturday that she supported McCarthy’s move to push through a stopgap bill to continue funding the government, without funding for Ukraine.

“I really don’t think the shutdown is a good idea,” Holder said. “Anytime we freeze government, it kind of puts everybody in a paralyzed situation.”