Do China’s claims of coronavirus on frozen food stack up?
China has stirred controversy with claims that it has detected the coronavirus on packages of imported frozen food, including from Russia and Norway.
Frozen shrimp imported from an Ecuadorean company was banned for one week Tuesday in a continuing series of such temporary bans.
While experts say the coronavirus can survive for a time on cardboard and plastic containers, it remains unclear how serious a risk that poses. As with so many issues surrounding the pandemic, the matter has swiftly become politicized.
The U.S. has questioned whether China’s crackdown is scientifically based and suggested that the bans may amount to an unfair trade barrier.
China has rejected such complaints, saying it is putting people’s lives first. Experts say they generally don’t consider the presence of the coronavirus on packaging to be a significant health risk.
A look at the issue and some of the conclusions so far:
Packaging first became a major issue with outbreaks in China linked to wholesale food markets, including one in June on the outskirts of Beijing. That prompted the removal of smoked salmon from supermarket shelves and has snowballed into multiple cases nationwide involving chicken, beef and seafood from nearly two dozen countries. At some supermarkets, imported meat now comes with a sticker declaring it to be coronavirus-free.
The new coronavirus can live in the air for several hours and on some surfaces for as long as two to three days, scientific tests have found.
Infections among freight handlers have also placed suspicion on packaging. Person-to-person transmission hasn’t been ruled out, however, and China has yet to release evidence that packaging was indeed the route of infection.
Trading partners, including the U.S., New Zealand, Canada and the EU, say they’re unclear on China’s methodology and have seen no solid evidence that their products carried the coronavirus.
Chinese foreign ministry spokesperson Zhao Lijian called the U.S. accusations “totally groundless and unreasonable.” China’s measures are “necessary following the spirit of putting people’s lives first and protecting people’s health,” he said last week.
In a statement to the Associated Press, the World Health Organization said cases of live coronavirus being found on packaging appear to be “rare and isolated.” While the virus can “survive a long time under cold storage conditions,” there is no evidence of people contracting COVID-19 from consuming food, it said.
The coronavirus is overwhelmingly transmitted through respiratory droplets and smaller-sized particles passed through the air, underscoring the importance of mask-wearing.
The research effort aims to paint a picture of how the virus moves through our world.
Yet the virus can also be present on surfaces, and public health officials have urged people to wash their hands carefully and avoid physical contact with others. In general, the colder and dryer that conditions are, the longer the coronavirus can survive on surfaces.
Wiping down countertops, handrails and other surfaces is a common way to ensure safety. Some people have also gone to the extreme of disinfecting packages brought into their homes, both by themselves or by delivery services.
What experts say
Coronavirus traces found on packaging can be infectious or non-infectious. The extremely sensitive tests being used can detect both active viruses and their remnants without being able to distinguish between them, said Timothy Newsome, a virologist at the University of Sydney.
“It is possible and may represent some risk, but it’s certainly at the lower end of risk for transmission,” he said. “We know low temperatures do stabilize the virus. Nonetheless, I think things which have been transported and surface transmission — there’s a low risk of it.”
A positive test “doesn’t indicate infectious virus, just that some signal from the virus is present on that surface,” said Andrew Pekosz of Johns Hopkins University’s Bloomberg School of Public Health.
“I’ve seen no convincing data that SARS-CoV-2 on food packaging poses a significant risk for infection,” he said.
Start your day right
Sign up for Essential California for news, features and recommendations from the L.A. Times and beyond in your inbox six days a week.
You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times.