Guatemala high court apparently restarts ex-dictator’s trial

Share via

MEXICO CITY -- Guatemala’s highest court issued a ruling late Thursday that appears to have broken the complicated legal logjam in the case of former dictator Efrain Rios Montt, who is facing genocide charges in the slaughter of ethnic Maya during the country’s civil war.

The decision by the Constitutional Court appears to avert the possibility that prosecutors might have to start the trial from scratch, re-creating a case in which more than 100 witnesses have already given testimony, including graphic and emotionally wrenching details of the slaughter of men, women and children.

The trial of Rios Montt, an 86-year-old former army general who ruled the country from 1982 to 1983, is the highest-profile criminal case in modern Guatemalan history. The possibility that it would have to be rebooted was raised a week ago when, just before closing arguments, a judge who had presided over the case many months earlier surprisingly ordered that the trial be annulled, based on a technicality.


With Thursday’s ruling, though, it appears that prosecutors may pick up where they left off -- but Jo-Marie Burt, director of the Latin American Studies Program at George Mason University, warned that more surprises could be in store. She noted that the high court must still rule on a number of other complex legal petitions that could affect the case in myriad ways.

“It’s not that it’s completely over,” Burt said.

The high court’s ruling Thursday ordered the judge who annulled the case, Patricia Flores, to hear some evidence that had been in dispute. But it ordered Flores to then return the case file to the trial court where, barring any further developments, a three-judge panel will eventually issue a ruling.

Rios Montt and his former military intelligence chief, Jose Mauricio Rodriguez Sanchez, are facing unprecedented charges of genocide and crimes against humanity for allegedly sanctioning the execution of 1,770 Ixil Maya Indians and the destruction of numerous highland villages.

The fact that the former strongman was even brought to trial was viewed as a victory by international human rights groups.

Many conservative Guatemalans contend that Rios Montt is a hero who did what he had to do to save the country from the scourge of communism.



Iraq fighting leaves at least 41 more people dead

South Korea chides Japan after lawmakers visit war shrine

U.S. lawmakers call for action on Syria’s chemical weapons