OpinionOpinion L.A.
Opinion

What Obama didn't explain in his foreign policy speech at West Point

Wars and InterventionsGeorge W. BushInternational Military InterventionsWest PointU.S. Military
Obama's foreign policy speech was notable for what he didn't say
Obama talks terrorism, tactics, U.S. goals and limits

President Obama’s foreign policy speech at West Point on Wednesday didn’t break any new ground, not even rhetorically. But it wasn’t intended to. It was meant as a rebuttal, an answer to critics who have harried Obama for months complaining that America’s adversaries (Russia, China and Syria, for example) are pursuing their goals with more success than the United States has found in stopping them.

The criticisms have gotten under Obama’s skin. He gripes about them frequently, in public and in private. So, with a speech already promised for West Point’s graduation ceremony, he seized the opportunity for a longer, more considered version of his side of the argument.

His core message was familiar and entirely reasonable: The United States needs to remain engaged in the world but should not think of military intervention as its primary tool. “American isolationism is not an option,” he said. “The United States is the one indispensable nation,” the only country capable of organizing big multilateral coalitions to fix big international problems.

But then, alas, the president took aim at a whole battalion of straw men. “U.S. military action cannot be the only, or even primary, component of our leadership in every instance,” he said.

But no one has argued that military action should come first — not even George W. Bush, who took the nation to war in Iraq and Afghanistan.

“A strategy that involves invading every country that harbors terrorist networks is naive and unsustainable,” Obama said, knocking down another argument nobody has made.

The real questions are harder, but Obama mostly ducked those. The hawkish critics of his cautious policy in Syria, for example, never proposed putting U.S. troops on the ground; instead, they proposed setting up a no-fly zone and arming Syria’s moderate rebels. Obama initially rejected both ideas as reckless, but he has now belatedly embraced the second — a nuance he didn’t explain Wednesday.

The larger missing element was this: The fundamental challenge for any nation’s foreign policy consists in defining its most important interests — and then making sure its commitments match its resources. Obama was clear on the first part but not on the second.

The most immediate threat the United States faces, he said, remains terrorism. The war against Islamist extremists isn’t over; in some ways, it’s expanding.

But the president wasn’t as candid on the most difficult adjustment he’s proposing, and the one that keeps causing him political trouble: When the United States reduces the resources (military and otherwise) it devotes to foreign affairs, it needs to downsize its ambitions as well.

If you read between the lines, that’s an equation Obama accepts; unlike Bush, he’s not promising to end tyranny, only to oppose it.

He’d like to square the circle — to keep American leadership effective, at lower cost — by working with other countries as allies and partners. But that’s been the core of American diplomacy for a long time, and it’s never quite as easy as it sounds.

In a speech whose principal goal was rebutting charges of weakness, it’s probably too much to ask for a clear-eyed discussion of which foreign policy goals are achievable at a reasonable cost, and which aren’t. We may have to wait for Obama’s memoirs for that.

Copyright © 2014, Los Angeles Times
Related Content
Wars and InterventionsGeorge W. BushInternational Military InterventionsWest PointU.S. Military
  • North Hollywood/Zev Yaroslavsky station? Stop the political madness
    North Hollywood/Zev Yaroslavsky station? Stop the political madness

    A Metro committee on Thursday backed a plan to rename two rail stations after termed-out Los Angeles County Supervisors Zev Yaroslavsky and Gloria Molina. If approved by the full Metro board -- which still includes the two supervisors -- on Oct. 2, the Red Line terminus would be called the...

  • Sorry, Apple fanatics, but the new iPhones aren't exceptional
    Sorry, Apple fanatics, but the new iPhones aren't exceptional

    It’s happening again. All around me, at social events, on social media and in publications I enjoy, people are brimming with enthusiasm for new Apple products. And I just don’t get it.

  • Don't turn down a Medi-Cal gift, Gov. Brown
    Don't turn down a Medi-Cal gift, Gov. Brown

    The 2010 federal healthcare reform law let states expand Medicaid, the joint federal-state health insurance program for the poor, largely at federal expense. California is one of 27 states that have taken up Washington's offer, and well over 1 million newly eligible residents signed up...

  • A simple fix for L.A.'s voter turnout problem
    A simple fix for L.A.'s voter turnout problem

    When fewer than 1 in 4 registered Los Angeles voters bothered to cast a ballot for a new mayor last year, it set off a round of soul-searching among city officials and political experts. Why were voters so disengaged? What would make them show up at the polls? What does it say about the...

  • For Superior Court, Jacqueline Lewis and Andrew Stein
    For Superior Court, Jacqueline Lewis and Andrew Stein

    Los Angeles County voters will see two judicial runoffs on their Nov. 4 ballot, and it's a shame they can't just pick the two best candidates of the four. That's because the two best are running against each other. Deputy Dist. Atty. Dayan Mathai is an accomplished prosecutor...

  • The dangerous, valuable work of U.N. peacekeepers
    The dangerous, valuable work of U.N. peacekeepers

    In mid-August, two United Nations peacekeepers from Burkina Faso were killed and several wounded in a suicide attack in the Timbuktu region of northern Mali. In early September, also in Mali, four peacekeeping troops from Chad lost their lives and many were injured when their convoy hit a mine.

Comments
Loading