Financial Planning: A Midyear Guide 1987 : part one: Planning Ahead : Even Small Savings Can Earn More
If you have less than $2,500 to work with, you don’t have a lot of investment options these days. Yet one of the most durable instruments, the regular savings account, is alive and readily available at banks, savings institutions, credit unions and thrifts and loans.
Although some financial advisers scoff at its low return and growth potential, they can’t deny the advantages of safety and being able to withdraw your money at any time. Moreover, savings accounts often are the only way small savers can ever accumulate enough for a larger investment.
The personal savings rate of Americans is expected to decline again this year to a 40-year low of 3.6% of disposable income, according to a survey of 51 forecasters by Blue Chip Financial Forecasts of Sedona, Ariz. Recent tax reform didn’t add much in the way of saving incentives. Yet many people still follow Ben Franklin’s pronouncement that “A penny saved is a penny earned.”
Of course, there’s more to saving than tucking away a few dollars every month, according to Andrew Tobias, author of “The Only Investment Guide You’ll Ever Need.”
What can you do with your hard-won savings once you’ve accumulated them? Since government deregulation of interest rate ceilings and minimum balance requirements was completed last year, institutions now set their own requirements. Keep in mind that account specifications vary from institution to institution.
Here’s what is available today for savers with $2,500 or less:
Regular savings accounts. Savers are provided records of accounts either through passbooks or statements mailed periodically from the institution. Accounts may pay variable or fixed interest rates, currently ranging around 4.75% to 5.5%. Minimum deposit requirements to open an account and minimum balance requirements to earn interest vary.
Some institutions will open an account with as little as $1, but may not pay interest on a balance under $100 and charget a quarterly fee of $4.50 if the minimum balance isn’t maintained.
Interest on checking. Technically there are negotiable orders of withdrawal (NOW) accounts, and SuperNOWs, which pay higher interest for higher minimum balances. Many institutions are merging the two accounts, which are available at
banks, savings and loans, and credit unions, but generally not at industrial thrift and loans. Some institutions pay interest on any size balance but require a $100 minimum deposit to open, and may charge a monthly fee of $4 if the balance is below $500.
Money-market accounts. These generally allow six pre-authorized withdrawals per month without incurring a fee. Most require $1,000 or $2,500 to open, and some will pay interest on any balance. But if you fall below minimum balance requirements, monthly fees can eat up all your interest and then some. Interest rates are not necessarily higher than with regular savings accounts, and rates depend on what tier your balance falls into. Tiers vary by institution but are frequently in $500 increments.
Certificates of deposit. The most popular deposit accounts, CDs pay fixed or variable rates and lock up your money for a specified period. The most popular terms are 3, 6, 12, 18 and 30 months. Minimum deposits for one-year CDs can run as little as $250. Interest rates depend on your balance, and there usually are penalties for early withdrawal. (Please see “Banks Tailoring CDs,” Page 33.)
Banks, savings banks and S&Ls; generally offer the same types of savings and interest checking accounts, although surveys by Consumer Action of San Francisco show that California S&Ls; generally pay higher interest on savings than banks. Accounts are insured up to $100,000 by the federal government through the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. for banks and the Federal Savings & Loan Insurance Corp. for savings and loans.
Credit unions offer most of the same accounts as larger institutions but pay an average of one-half or three-quarters of a percentage point more because of their not-for-profit nature. Each credit union has its own membership requirements based on criteria such as place of employment, neighborhood, group or religious affiliation. But a few credit unions are open to everyone. The California Credit Union League will help match you up with a union that would accept you as a member if you call (714) 628-6044 and ask for the research and information department. Accounts at credit unions are insured up to $100,000 by the National Credit Union Shares Insurance Fund.
Industrial thrift and loans or consumer finance companies have no membership requirements and generally do not offer checking accounts. Some are insured by the FDIC for accounts up to $100,000. Others insure deposits up to $50,000 through the California Thrift Guaranty Corp. These generally offer a quarter to half a point higher interest on savings because they’ve historically been viewed as having less protection.
Which account and institution do you choose? It’s a matter of educating yourself about what choices are being offered and determining your needs.
Some advisers recommend against an interest-bearing checking account as a receptacle for savings because it’s too easy to spend your savings by writing a check. If you’re the type who needs the external discipline of a bank telling you that you can’t have your money back for several months, put your money in a certificate of deposit.
For those who already have a checking account--and a little self-discipline--look at the balance you normally maintain in your checking account now and how many transactions you make each month.
“It gets more complicated, but it has the potential to save you much more money,” says Ken McEldowney, executive director of Consumer Action. If you have both a checking account that would charge you no fees if you maintained a $500 balance and a 5% passbook or statement savings account, you’d be wise to transfer passbook funds into checking to avoid $5 to $6 monthly charges. “Your checking is costing you $60 to $70 a year in fees. By moving $500 from your savings into the checking account, you’d save that and probably only lose $25 in interest.”
Shop around. Opening deposit requirements, minimum balances, interest tiers, fixed versus variable interest and fees vary widely from institution to institution. The first rule is to compare annual yields, not rates, on savings instruments. The yield takes into account the method and frequency of interest compounding, to tell you what you’ll get over a year. But be careful in comparing yields for three- or six-month CDs. For the same type of account, one institution may quote a rate and a yield which are the same, while a second quotes a yield higher than the rate because it assumes a reinvestment of the interest.
In Los Angeles County in mid-May, institutions quoted low and high rates of 5.75% to 7.5% for a one-year CD with a $2,500 deposit, says Alan Meyer of the Meyer Weekly Interest Rate Survey in Woodland Hills. Over an annual period, that can mean about $40 difference in interest.
One-year CD rates hit bottom in February, 1987, but started to show a sharp increase in May in California, Meyer says. With interest rates rising, don’t invest in CDs of terms longer than six months to a year, he advises. If you don’t mind doing your transactions by mail, consider a CD from an out-of-state institution, many of which offer a higher return than those in California.
Check the withdrawal privileges and what fees are charged against the account. A Consumer Action/Consumer Federation of America survey conducted in April compared net income from savings accounts and money-market accounts, including monthly fees and interest, assuming no transactions and just under $1,000 balance.
Among 15 large California institutions surveyed, the net income on a one-year deposit would be $40.61 for savings accounts and a loss of 85 cents for money-market accounts because the fees exceeded the interest. (Fees may be based on balance tiers that do not correspond to the balance tiers for interest rates.)
Find out if the interest rate on the account you are considering is variable, whether it is tied to an index or set by committee, how often it can change and by how much, and whether there are notice requirements to account holders when it changes. Ask for a disclosure brochure that spells out the institution’s fees and charges.
You also might look at other services, such as automatic teller machines and safety deposit boxes.
McEldowney of Consumer Action advises checking the yields at savings and loans if you are saving at a bank and shopping for a fixed rate of 5.5% in a savings account, because he believes such rates are still available. If you’ve got as much as $2,500 that can be tied up for three to six months, he suggests putting it in a CD rather than a money-market account.
