Torpedoing ‘Supercarrier’

After reviewing the made-for-TV movie “Supercarrier,” I am compelled to write the following:

In the past, we in naval aviation have been tolerant of technical inaccuracies in motion picture portrayals of our profession if the story was exceptional, or if the sheer visual effect tended toward the awesome.

We commented to the media on the reckless flying shown in “Top Gun” as not at all typical of naval aviators--wings would disappear from chests quickly as a result of such flying.

However, we cannot sit by and condone gross stereotyping to be foisted on the viewing public in the name of entertainment. We are professional pilots and sailors who suffer long family separations, and who put our lives on the line at sea. We do not appreciate the portrayal of us as unprofessional, self-serving bunglers.

Just a few of these inaccuracies: the total unconcern of the Command Master Chief for the welfare of the Seaman, who would never be left to wander the ship for days without assistance; the pilot’s theft of his medical record and resultant unauthorized flight; the meandering of dogs about the ship; the impression that the ship was maneuvered specifically for golfing off the fantail; or the cavalier action of the Chaplain.

I realize the license that must be taken at times for characterization, but I do not accept character assassination.

But “Supercarrier” does not typify the proud professionals it has been my honor to serve with at sea. If serious rework in dry dock cannot be made expeditiously, I suggest this fictional ship of fools be mothballed by ABC immediately.

JERRY D. PALMER

Captain, U.S. Navy

Commanding Officer

NAS Lemoore