‘Catholic Differences’ Are Misstated

The table labeled “Catholic Differences” (“Tiny St. Matthew Rattles the Roman Catholic Diocese,” Nov. 28) contained inaccurate statements about the official teachings of the Roman Catholic Church. The source of the table was cited as “St. Matthew Old Catholic Church,” with no mention of input from the Roman Catholic Church.

While it is true that the Roman Church does not approve the ordination of women, it is not clear from the article that the “Old Catholic Church” ordains female priests either.

The statement that “women’s involvement in ministry encouraged” applies to the Old Catholic Church and not to the Roman Church is untrue. Short of the ordained priesthood, women have always been encouraged to play an active role in service within the Church.

Especially since Vatican Council II, the Church has actively encouraged women to aspire to positions of leadership within the Church and has opened new opportunities of ministry to women.

Also, the statement that in the Roman Church “Bishop, priests, deacons have elevated status” in contrast to the Old Catholic movement where “laity plays prominent role in Church” is ludicrous. Virtually all religions apply some sort of “elevated status” or respect to their clergy, and I am sure that the Old Catholic Church is no exception.

The Roman Catholic Church teaches that the role of the laity is essential to the life of the Church. This has been particularly emphasized by our current Pope, John Paul II.

The major difference between the two churches is the disagreement over papal authority.

LIZ GABAY

Huntington Beach