‘Beloved’ Deemed Too Violent for Teenagers

Despite recommendations from a committee of parents and teachers, the Anaheim Union High School District recently rejected adding the Pulitzer Prize-winning book “Beloved” to the core reading list for 12th-grade English classes.

Trustees voted 4 to 1 against adopting the book by Nobel Prize-winning author Toni Morrison, citing its graphic themes. The novel, which tells the story of a slave who murders her daughter to spare her from slavery, contains passages board members said they believe are inappropriate for high school students.

“I cannot, as a parent and former educator, approve adopting this book,” Trustee R.A. “Molly” McGee said. “This is not in the best interest of the students.”

The book was tested in one classroom this year and was recommended for adoption by teachers. But some parents objected, saying several passages were too violent.

The board formed a committee of parents, teachers and residents to review the novel, as outlined in district policies about book adoptions. After deliberations, the committee concluded the book should be considered as a whole, and should not be disqualified because of certain passages. Supporters said the book provides students the opportunity to discuss bigotry and prejudice in society.

Trustee Joanne L. Stanton cast the lone vote in favor of adding the book to the reading list.

“I have problems with downright banning books,” she said.

The novel will continue to be available in campus libraries, officials said.