‘Stan’s’ Not a No. 1

As a high school teacher, I can appreciate the value of “Stan,” Robert Hilburn’s top song pick for 2000, as a positive influence on the devout young fans of today’s pop stars (“After 1999’s Glitches, Y2K Offers Reassurance,” Dec. 23).

This is especially important coming from Eminem, a star from a pop movement that is so often criticized for its themes and attitudes. But the No. 1 song? Hardly.

Musically, it has nothing other than some parts taken from Dido’s excellent song, “Thank You.” Haunting, yes, but not his music.

Socially, “Stan” is a good song, but the storytelling style is pedestrian. It is contrived, utterly predictable and has been done so many times before. The only thing “new” is the attitude. I’m sure Hilburn would agree that attitude does not make a great song.

It amazes me that Hilburn can appreciate an incredible storyteller such as Bruce Springsteen and not see the deficiencies of a run-of-the-mill song by a mediocre rapper.

ANDREW SIMS

Hermosa Beach

*

What seriousness in Robert Hilburn’s pop music Top 10! All had heavy topics and not a single song was included for being fun. Is the implication that music should not be joyful? SALO DOUER

Los Angeles

*

To Reach Us . . .

For general Calendar inquiries, call (213) 237-7770. Write us at Calendar Letters, Los Angeles Times, 202 W. 1st St., Los Angeles, CA 90012, fax us at (213) 237-7630 or e-mail us at Calendar.letters@latimes.com. Please be brief and include name, address and phone number. All communications are subject to editing.