U.S. retail sales unexpectedly fell in December, posting the worst drop in nine years in a sign of slower economic momentum at year-end amid financial market turmoil and the government shutdown.
The value of overall sales fell 1.2% from the prior month after a downwardly revised 0.1% increase in November, according to Commerce Department figures released Thursday after a four-week delay due to the partial shutdown of the federal government. That drop missed all economist estimates in a Bloomberg survey that had called for a 0.1% gain.
Stocks and the dollar fell and Treasuries rose Thursday morning as the broad weakness across most sectors added to signs that U.S. economic growth is cooling from prior quarters — potentially by more than projected. It may reinforce investor expectations that the Federal Reserve will hold off on raising interest rates this year amid concern about trade and global growth.
“These numbers are horrible,” said Ward McCarthy, chief financial economist at Jefferies. “It appears to contrast quite sharply with reports of Christmastime sales that were generally seen as quite healthy,” and for the Fed, “rate normalization is on the back burner for a long time to come.”
Excluding automobiles and gasoline, retail sales slumped 1.4%, the biggest drop since March 2009, after a 0.5% advance the previous month.
Sales in the “control group” subset, which some analysts use to gauge underlying consumer demand, also fell short of estimates: The 1.7% decline was the biggest drop since the Sept. 11, 2001, terror attacks. That followed a 1% advance the prior month. The measure excludes food services, car dealers, building-materials stores and gasoline stations.
While the steep drop follows other data pointing to slower growth, it’s at odds with figures showing a healthy job market and steady wage gains. The slump also may prove temporary as stocks have regained ground following the biggest December plunge since the Great Depression, and the government shutdown ended in late January.
All but two of 13 major retail categories showed a decline, with non-store retailers — which includes online stores — falling 3.9%, the most since November 2008. The broad-based weakening reflected lower sales from clothing stores to and gasoline stations. Auto dealers and building materials stores were the only sectors to record increases.
December’s drop is likely to hit estimates of consumer spending following the best back-to-back quarters of economic growth since 2014 and of consumer spending since 2015. Economists surveyed by Bloomberg before the data came out Thursday had forecast consumption to grow at a 3.4% annualized rate in the fourth quarter and 2.4% in the first three months of this year.
Filling-station receipts slumped 5.1%, the report showed. The Commerce Department figures aren’t adjusted for price changes, so the readings can reflect fluctuations in both costs and sales.
Sales at automobile dealers rose 1% in December after increasing 0.7% the previous month. Industry reports previously showed unit sales rose 0.6% in December and fell 5.1% in January.
A separate report Thursday from the Labor Department showed filings for unemployment benefits unexpectedly rose last week, a sign of potential residual effects of the shutdown. In addition, producer price inflation cooled in January, according to a Labor Department report.
Estimates in the Bloomberg survey for retail sales ranged from a 0.2% drop to a 1.2% gain. Receipts at health and personal care stores fell 2%, the most since October 2016. Sales at sporting goods, hobby, book and musical instrument stores tumbled 4.9%, the biggest drop since September 2008.
The release of January retail-sales figures — originally scheduled for Friday — has been postponed by the shutdown and has yet to be rescheduled. Processing and data quality were monitored during the shutdown, and response rates for the December survey were at or above normal, the Commerce Department said.