Tech-rights group sues Trump to stop social-media order

President Trump speaks at a campaign rally in 2019. His executive order seeks to regulate social media.
An executive order from President Trump, shown at a campaign rally in 2019, is the target of a tech-focused civil liberties group. The president aimed to rally his supporters after Twitter put fact checks on two of his tweets.

A tech-focused civil liberties group on Tuesday sued to block President Trump’s executive order that seeks to regulate social media, saying it violates the 1st Amendment and chills speech.

Trump’s order, signed last week, could allow more lawsuits against internet companies such as Twitter and Facebook for what their users post, tweet and stream.

The order was more political than substantive, with many experts questioning whether it was constitutional. The president aimed to rally his supporters after Twitter put fact checks on two of his tweets. Trump, without evidence, has long accused tech companies of being biased against conservatives.


The order targets current law — you may have heard recent references to Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act — that protects internet companies from lawsuits. They can’t be sued for hosting videos and posts from users, or for moderating their services, with some exceptions.

Trump is only pretending to attack Twitter

June 1, 2020

In its suit, the Center for Democracy and Technology said that Trump’s executive order violates the 1st Amendment because it attacks Twitter for putting the fact checks on the president’s tweets, which the center said is Twitter’s right as a private company. More broadly, the order is trying to curb speech of all online platforms and people “by demonstrating the willingness to use government authority to retaliate against those who criticize the government,” it said.

“The government cannot and should not force online intermediaries into moderating speech according to the president’s whims,” Alexandra Givens, the center’s CEO, said in an emailed statement. The organization filed the federal suit in the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia.

There was pushback against Trump’s order from various sources. Tech industry groups, unsurprisingly, said it was bad for innovation and speech. Civil rights and libertarian organizations and the U.S. Chamber of Commerce also criticized Trump’s order.