‘Hobbit’ rules again as Cruise, Apatow, Streisand post soft debuts

No. 1, again
Martin Freeman stars in “The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey,” which was the No. 1 film at the box office for the second consecutive week.
(Warner Bros.)

It was a ho-ho-ho-hum weekend at the box office, as five new releases failed to draw moviegoers to the multiplex in droves.

“The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey” was the No. 1 film for the second consecutive weekend, collecting an additional $36.7 million, according to an estimate from Warner Bros. The film -- which has now grossed $149.9 million in North America -- saw its ticket sales fall 57% from its opening weekend -- an average drop for a big-budget tent pole.

Of the new releases, Tom Cruise’s action flick “Jack Reacher” fared best -- though its $15.6-million debut was still soft. Meanwhile, Judd Apatow had the worst opening of his directorial career by far with his comedy “This is 40,” which started off with an unimpressive $12 million.

VIDEO: Exclusive clip from ‘The Hobbit’


But the news was even worse for two movies that opened on Wednesday -- “The Guilt Trip” and a 3-D version of “Monsters, Inc.” The Barbra Streisand-Seth Rogen road trip comedy tanked with just $7.4 million over five days, while the updated version of the animated kids movie sold a weak $6.5 million worth of tickets during the same time period.

“Cirque Du Soleil: Worlds Away,” a 3-D event film based on the popular stage productions, played only twice per day over the weekend in about 800 theaters, but nonetheless its $2.3-million gross was disappointing.

As a result of the lackluster business, ticket sales were down 13% compared with the same weekend last year. Still, 2012 should end on a positive note, as receipts and attendance are currently up about 5% compared with 2011.

The weekend’s new films will face additional competition on Christmas Day, when Quentin Tarantino’s “Django Unchained,” the musical “Les Miserables” and the family film “Parental Guidance” hit theaters. However, movies that open the weekend before Christmas often hold up well in theaters, as families are looking for things to do between the holiday and New Year’s.


“Jack Reacher” stands to benefit from positive word of mouth, as the movie was best received of any of the weekend’s new releases. Though the film earned only middling critical reviews, audiences assigned it an average grade of A-, according to market research firm CinemaScore.

In “Jack Reacher,” Cruise plays a man on a mission to find the criminal behind a deadly shooting spree. The story is based on Lee Child’s bestselling “Jack Reacher” series, whose protagonist is a burly, tall blond ex-soldier -- far from Cruise’s 5-foot-7 stature.

PHOTOS: 60 images from ‘The Hobbit’

The movie, co-financed by Paramount Pictures and Skydance Productions for roughly $60 million, will need to rack up additional ticket sales not only in the U.S. but abroad to become a success. Cruise hasn’t had a good year with domestic moviegoers, as his star-studded musical “Rock of Ages” tanked with $38.5 million. Fortunately for the actor, international audiences still seem to be enamored with the 50-year-old star: His last three action movie all grossed more overseas than they did in America and Canada. 

This weekend, the film debuted in seven small international territories, including Turkey and Singapore, and grossed 2.5 million

“Internationally, this is a movie that will probably do 50% to 100% better than in the U.S.,” said Megan Colligan, Paramount’s president of domestic distribution. “Internationally, there is still such a thing as star vehicles. People come out solely to see their favorite stars, and the U.S. audience has become more discerning about that.”

As for “This is 40,” the comedy co-starring Apatow’s wife, Leslie Mann, and Paul Rudd started off with far less than even the filmmaker’s most recent disappointing performer, “Funny People.” That 2009 film launched with $22.7 million and ultimately collected $51.9 million.

With its B- CinemaScore, “This is 40" will have to work hard to reach that total. The movie, produced by Universal Pictures for $35 million, is loosely based on Apatow’s own marriage with Mann. The film attracted more women than men, as the opening weekend crowd was 57% female, and roughly 50% were over the age of 30.


Nikki Rocco, Universal’s president of domestic distribution, insisted she was pleased with film’s opening weekend because she believes the movie will play well in the coming weeks.

Best of 2012: Movies | TV | Pop music | Jazz | Video GamesArt | Theater | Dance | Classical music

“You couldn’t get within the vicinity of a shopping mall this weekend. It’s a busy one for adults,” she said. “There’s no way Judd has lost anything, in my perspective.”

Rogen, Apatow’s frequent collaborator, also had a rough weekend. Moviegoers weren’t interested in seeing the 30-year-old go on a cross-country trip with the 70-year-old Streisand, and gave the critically-reviled comedy an average grade of B-. The film, co-financed by Paramount and Skydance, had a budget of about $40 million.

“The Guilt Trip” marks Streisand’s first leading role since 1996’s “The Mirror Has Two Faces,” though she had supporting parts in the two “Meet the Fockers” films. The performer has focused more on her singing career over the last decade -- and may continue to do so after her film’s poor opening.

Heading into the weekend, “Monsters, Inc.” was expected to trounce “The Guilt Trip.” While the 3-D film is a re-release, there are few movies currently in the marketplace for young children, making it easy for the movie to capitalize on a family audience.

VIDEO: Holiday movie guide

But of the four animated movies that Walt Disney Studios has now re-released in 3-D, “Monsters, Inc.” did the worst by far. In September, the “Finding Nemo” re-issue opened with $16.7 million and ended up with $41 million -- not nearly as much as the $94 million the 3-D version of “The Lion King” grossed a year prior.


It is inexpensive for Disney to convert its cartoon classics into 3-D -- for “Monsters, Inc.,” the price tag was only about $3 million -- but the studio has to spend millions on marketing. Disney has already set a 3-D version of “The Little Mermaid” for release next September, but the studio may be contemplating how many movies it wants to re-release in the format after that date.

Paramount decided to open the “Cirque” film in limited release in an effort to spread buzz about the movie before Christmas, when showtimes will run all day long. Produced by 3-D expert James Cameron, the $18-million film was not financed by the studio, which is distributing it. The fictional tale includes the trademark acrobatics included in many of Cirque’s most popular productions.

“We wanted to impart that this was a unique and exclusive event,” said Paramount’s Colligan, adding that the movie is playing particularly well in suburban areas. “And now there are excellent pre-sale results for Christmas Day, which shows that these paid sneak previews really helped to juice things.”


‘Hobbit’ to again rule box office; ‘Zero Dark Thirty’ has big start

Senate leaders Feinstein and McCain condemn ‘Zero Dark Thirty’

3-D ‘Monsters, Inc.’ should scare off Barbra Streisand, Seth Rogen 


Get our daily Envelope newsletter