Homeless measures take center stage in Mayor Garcetti’s 2016 budget proposal
Los Angeles Mayor Eric Garcetti on Wednesday released his proposed budget for the final year of his first term, pushing for significant boosts to anti-homelessness programs as part of a 2% increase in overall spending.
The $8.76-billion budget proposal, up from $8.58 billion last year, asks for no radical changes to most areas of city government. It would slightly increase Los Angeles’ municipal workforce to just over 33,000 — still well below the pre-recession 37,000 — keeping the police force at its existing level and adding 100 Fire Department employees.
Homelessness, an issue whose political importance far outweighs the relatively small share of city dollars it consumes, will probably receive the most attention as the mayor and City Council hash out the final budget in the weeks ahead. The debate could be intensified by Garcetti’s novel approach to finding money to tackle the problem, which relies on at least one revenue source that does not yet exist and on offering up a number of prominent city properties for sale or development as low-income housing projects.
L.A. has long endured criticism that it doesn’t spend enough on its homeless population, which grew 12% over Garcetti’s first two years in office. The mayor’s staff is touting his proposed budget as a major step toward reversing that trend, saying it would provide $138 million for homeless programs during the next fiscal year, which begins July 1. That would represent a roughly fourfold increase from this fiscal year, when the city set aside $34 million for homeless programs — an initial outlay of $18 million and an interim appropriation of $16 million that the mayor ordered late last year.
At a news conference Wednesday, Garcetti said his proposed budget “commits unprecedented resources to help get Angelenos off of our streets.”
Tens of thousands of people are homeless in L.A., the nation’s largest homeless population without access to any kind of shelter. City officials have adopted a $2-billion plan to house them over the next decade and are planning to place a bond or tax measure on the ballot this fall that would provide funding for that effort beyond next year. Garcetti and some council members also have said they wish to provide at least $100 million from the city’s budget over the next year to jump-start the effort before asking voters for more money.
Philip Mangano, who served as homelessness policy czar for President George W. Bush, called the proposed jump in spending “a big step in the right direction.” He said Garcetti was joining other mayors, such as Bill de Blasio of New York City, in redirecting significant government resources to meet a rise in homelessness.
LAPD Sgt. Jack Richter helps a homeless man in a wheelchair leave an area along 5th Street as the cleanup of skid row continues with city sanitation crews sweeping and later power washing the sidewalks.(Mark Boster / Los Angeles Times)
City sanitation crews have to sweep around some of the homeless on skid row during a cleanup with LAPD and city sanitation crews working along 5th Street between Stanford Avenue and San Pedro.(Mark Boster / Los Angeles Times)
Homeless residents living near 5th Street in downtown Los Angeles have to gather their belongings while city sanitaion crews and the LAPD conduct a cleanup of skid row between Stanford Avenue and San Pedro Street.(Mark Boster / Los Angeles Times)
City sanitation crews use a mixture of water and bleach during a cleanup of skid row with LAPD and city sanitation crews working along 5th Street between Stanford and San Pedro.(Mark Boster / Los Angeles Times)
A homeless man walks along 5th Street in downtown Los Angeles with his possessions on his back after a cleanup sweep on skid row.(Mark Boster / Los Angeles Times)
A homeless man living along 5th Street is arrested during a cleanup of skid row.(Mark Boster / Los Angeles Times)
Members of the city watershed protection team walk along 5th Street in downtown Los Angeles while a cleanup of skid row continues with LAPD and city sanitation crews powerwashing the sidewalks between Stanford and San Pedro.(Mark Boster / Los Angeles Times)
A homeless man on skid row scrambles away with a wheelchair during a cleanup effort along 5th Street between Stanford Avenue and San Pedro.(Mark Boster / Los Angeles Times)
LAPD officers find several stolen shopping carts in the homeless encampments on Stanford Avenue near 5th Street in downtown Los Angeles during a cleanup of skid row.(Mark Boster / Los Angeles Times)
City sanitation crews use hot water and bleach to wash the sidewalks along 5th Street, working around tents on skid row between Stanford and San Pedro.(Mark Boster / Los Angeles Times)
Mayor Eric Garcetti, left, and City Administrative Officer Miguel A. Santana during a news conference at which Garcetti discussed his proposed budget for the next fiscal year.(Francine Orr / Los Angeles Times)
City Administrative Officer Miguel Santana, left, and Mayor Eric Garcetti after a news conference at Los Angeles City Hall.(Francine Orr / Los Angeles Times)
“They’re trying to put their resources where their rhetoric has been,” Mangano said. “It’s the delivery we’ve been waiting a long time for.”
In L.A., he added, “The budget demonstrates leadership on the issue.”
Others question whether the budget projections are realistic, noting that half of the mayor’s proposed homelessness spending depends on uncertain sources of revenue.
The suggested homelessness budget, for example, assumes $20 million in revenue from so-called “linkage fees” — a levy on real estate developers that can be used to build low-income housing. L.A., however, does not currently collect such fees. Garcetti has advocated doing so, and the city is studying how such a fee might be applied, but it will be months before a final proposal reaches the council.
An additional $47 million in the budget is expected revenue from selling city property or using it in partnerships with private developers to build low-income housing. Garcetti and City Administrative Officer Miguel Santana have identified eight unused, underused or vacant city properties for that purpose. Half of the sites are in affluent Westside neighborhoods that have rebelled against proposals for affordable housing projects.
Mark Ryavec, president of the Venice Stakeholders Assn., said that although residents of the neighborhoods surrounding some of the properties may be amenable to their sale, they could balk at new projects to house the homeless.
“These are phony numbers,” Ryavec said. “The mayor and the council continue to try to make the public think they’re doing something about this when they’re doing almost nothing.”
At Wednesday’s news conference, Garcetti insisted the projected revenue from the development or sale of city properties was not a “pie-in-the-sky” number.
“This is a very conservative estimate,” he said. “This is real. We talked to council members. They’re supportive in their own districts, and we know that this will move this year.”
Councilman Mike Bonin, whose Westside district includes four of the eight city properties targeted, said it was too early to speculate on what sorts of housing developments might be appropriate. Opposition to such projects can be less intense if they cater to residents with a mix of income levels rather than just the chronically homeless.
“My experience, particularly over the past two years, is that people are incredibly hungry for solutions to homelessness in Los Angeles,” said Bonin, who is a member of the council’s Budget and Finance Committee. “They’re clamoring for it. They don’t want encampments in front of their homes and their kids’ schools.”
The proposed budget now goes to the Budget and Finance Committee, which will review and modify it in the coming months. The full council must pass a budget by June 1.
Get breaking news, investigations, analysis and more signature journalism from the Los Angeles Times in your inbox.
You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times.