Op-Ed: Baltimore and the language of change
A woman is loaded into the back of a van after being arrested for violating a 10 p.m. curfew Saturday in Baltimore.(David Goldman / Associated Press)
Police pour water over the face of a man after he was arrested and hit with pepper spray as police enforced a 10 p.m. curfew Saturday in Baltimore.(David Goldman / Associated Press)
Police carry a man after he was arrested and hit with pepper spray as officers enforced a 10 p.m. curfew Saturday in Baltimore.(David Goldman / Associated Press)
At the CVS corner, satisfaction breaks out with the news of charges filed against the police officers involved in the death of Freddie Gray. Glass artist Loring Cornish, 33, celebrates as police stand by.(Carolyn Cole / Los Angeles Times)
Community and religious leaders in Baltimore at the end of a prayer lunch and discussion regarding actions to promote reform and stop police abuse after the death of
Gwen Carr, right, mother of Eric Garner, who was killed by a New York City police officer last year, attends a prayer lunch and community meeting in Baltimore.(Carolyn Cole / Los Angeles Times)
The Rev. Al Sharpton leads a prayer lunch in Baltimore.(Carolyn Cole / Los Angeles Times)
Police presence remains high on the streets of Baltimore.(Carolyn Cole / Los Angeles Times)
A member of the National Guard monitors morning activity in Baltimore’s Inner Harbor area on April 29.(Mark Makela / Getty Images)
Riot police shields lay on a concrete bench in Baltimore’s
A man on a bicycle greets Maryland state troopers April 28 in the aftermath of rioting in Baltimore following the funeral for Freddie Gray.(Matt Rourke / Associated Press)
Jason Park, left, and his friend business owner Sung Kang leave his damaged store on Tuesday in the aftermath of rioting following Monday’s funeral for Freddie Gray.(Matt Rourke / Associated Press)
Residents clean the streets April 28 as law enforcement officers stand guard in Baltimore in the aftermath of rioting following the funeral of Freddie Gray, who died in police custody.(Matt Rourke / Associated Press)
A firefighter responds to a building front that caught fire as protests in Baltimore continue over the death of Freddie Gray.(John Taggart / European Pressphoto Agency)
Firefighters battle flames that broke out during riots in Baltimore.(John Taggart / European Pressphoto Agency)
Police and firefighters respond to a burning building as protests over the death of Freddie Gray continue in Baltimore.(John Taggart / European Pressphoto Agency)
A firefighter works to put out flames set by rioters in Baltimore late on the night of April 27.(John Taggart / European Pressphoto Agency)
A man shouts at police in front of a building that was looted and set on fire as protests over the death of Freddie Gray continue in Baltimore.(Michael Reynolds / European Pressphoto Agency)
Baltimore police officer push back protesters near Mowdamin Mall in Baltimore.(Drew Angerer / Getty Images)
Baltimore Police Commissioner Anthony Batts chases away protesters in a parking lot near Mowdamin Mall.(Drew Angerer / Getty Images)
Baltimore police officers walk in formation near Mowdamin Mall.(Drew Angerer / Getty Images)
A Baltimore police officer checks on a man who was injured near Mondawmin Mall during a protest following Freddie Gray’s funeral.(Drew Angerer / Getty Images)
Baltimore police officers chase protesters near Mondawmin Mall.(Drew Angerer / Getty Images)
Baltimore police officers in riot gear push protesters back near Mondawmin Mall.(Drew Angerer / Getty Images)
A demonstrator taunts police as they respond to thrown objects after the funeral of Freddie Gray in Baltimore.(Patrick Semansky / Associated Press)
A Baltimore police officer aims pepper spray at demonstrators after the funeral of Freddie Gray on Monday. Gray, 25, died April 19 after suffering a fatal spinal injury while in police custody.(Jose Luis Magana / Associated Press)
Demonstrators throw rocks at police after the funeral of Freddie Gray.(Jose Luis Magana / Associated Press)
Baltimore police officers push back demonstrators, some of whom were throwing rocks, after the funeral for Freddie Gray.(Jose Luis Magana / Associated Press)
For the last half-century, invoking the Rev. Martin Luther King Jr. to condemn or explain black urban uprisings has been a mandatory exercise. Recent events in Baltimore are no exception. Critics say that destroying property and attacking police desecrate King’s ideals and draw attention away from constructive, peaceful protests; looters and “thugs” are blamed for derailing the “legitimate” path to justice. To defend (though not condone) spontaneous rebellions, others trot out King’s remark that “a riot is the language of the unheard.”
Whatever King might make of the fact that some Baltimore residents reacted violently to Freddie Gray’s death, the argument that rioters sabotage legitimate efforts at redress is hardly credible. If that were true, there would have to be something to sabotage — some evidence that these efforts were actually effective in bringing about change.
From 2011 to 2014, the city of Baltimore forked over $5.7 million to victims of excessive force, with no corresponding shift in police behavior. Nearly a week of nonviolent protests produced no explanation for Gray’s death, no adequate response from the city or police, and little media attention — except when the president of Baltimore’s Fraternal Order of Police described the demonstrators as a “lynch mob.”
By contrast, it was precisely the crisis generated by the violence in Baltimore that compelled States Atty. Marilyn Mosby to expedite her investigation and charge six officers with serious crimes ranging from assault to second-degree murder.
If a riot really is “the language of the unheard,” what have we failed to hear? In 1967, King spoke of the cries of the black poor in a society “more concerned about tranquillity and the status quo than about justice, equality, and humanity.” And in the aftermath of the 1968 Baltimore riots, sparked by news of King’s assassination, black residents registered “police practices” as their primary grievance.
These concerns are still with us. Today’s “unheard” repeat two mantras: Property matters more than black lives, and the police operate above the law. Besides a reputation for brutality, Baltimore’s finest resemble a street gang. In 2011, when former detective Joseph Crystal blew the whistle on two officers involved in beating a handcuffed suspect, Crystal was labeled a “snitch.” He was refused backup during drug busts, counseled by his union to change departments, and even had his security clearance withdrawn. He subsequently left the force and is now suing the Baltimore Police Department.
Gray’s death has made visible decades of unchecked police violence. In Baltimore and elsewhere, broken windows policing in practice is not about fixing things but about scaring people into submission in an effort to reduce crime without ever having to attend to the intolerable conditions that King described.
Fueled by the war on drugs, “zero tolerance” policing turns some neighborhoods into open-air prisons and strips vulnerable residents of equal protection, habeas corpus, freedom of movement, even protection from torture. Simply “loitering” in front of one’s residence can result in a citation or arrest, just as “running” in a “high crime area” — the act for which Gray was detained — constitutes probable cause.
This is not about crime; this is about criminalization. Yes, Gray had a record, like so many young black men in West Baltimore. But to be criminalized is to be subjected to containment, surveillance, and punishment — and deemed unworthy of protection.
The roots of current police policy can also be traced back to 1968. Just weeks before the rebellion, the Baltimore Sun ran an article about Police Commissioner Donald Pomerleau, who set out to create a department devoted to “service” rather than force.
He added more African Americans to the community relations board and even established “a Negro history course” to educate his officers. But reports of police misconduct dogged his department. As one independent investigator put it, “Police are thought to employ brutality frequently, and the backroom of the precinct house is known as a dangerous place for a black man.”
In the aftermath of the riots, the Maryland Crime Investigating Commission decided that aggressive policing, rather than jobs and social investment, could bring an end to civil unrest. The report recommended expanding the force, including more black officers, improving intelligence and crowd control training. It directed police to attack “any lawlessness ... quickly and aggressively.”
Strikingly, the report proposed reorganizing the force along military lines. The Baltimore police “lacked the command structure, the weapons, the knowledge of mass formation tactics which can disperse or contain an unruly mob.” One year later, the department announced it had invested heavily in military hardware, including tear gas grenades and “pepper foggers.”
Distinguishing between “thugs” and legitimate protesters, rioters and demonstrators, obscures more than it reveals. Despite Mosby’s announcement, everyone in the streets demanding justice for Freddie Gray, Eric Garner, Tamir Rice, Rekia Boyd, Michael Brown, ad infinitum, feels “unheard.” Their simple demand to “stop killing us” goes unheeded, as every day a new name is added to our gruesome body count. Whether we like it or not, these often unpredictable protests are not isolated acts of despair but a new movement attempting to bring the police into compliance with the principles of law, order and justice.
Robin D.G. Kelley is the Gary B. Nash Professor of U.S. History at UCLA and is completing a book titled “Mike Brown’s Body: A Meditation on War, Race, and Democracy.”
A cure for the common opinion
Get thought-provoking perspectives with our weekly newsletter.
You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times.