Jakarta’s municipal election, a test of Muslim-Christian relations, goes to a runoff

Incumbent governor Basuki Tjahaja Purnama speaks during voting on Wednesday in municipal elections in Jakarta, Indonesia.
(Oscar Siagian / Getty Images)

After a tense campaign marred by religious protests and phone-tapping allegations made by a former president, Indonesia’s capital will have to wait two more months to learn who will run the city of 10 million people.

Incumbent Gov. Basuki Tjahaja Purnama, known as “Ahok,” will face a runoff election in April against a former education minister who was backed by Islamist protesters, turning the election into a test of religious tolerance in the world’s largest Muslim-majority country.

Purnama, a Christian of Chinese descent and an ally of President Joko Widodo, won about 40% of the votes cast in Wednesday’s municipal election, according to unofficial results. That was roughly the same as his rival, Anies Baswedan, a Muslim whose reformist credentials came under scrutiny when Islamist supporters sought to have the sitting governor jailed over a speech in which he purportedly insulted Islam.


The vote was widely seen as a preview of Widodo’s 2019 reelection chances and a test of how Indonesia’s Muslims, who make up nearly 90% of Indonesia’s population, regard ethnic and religious minorities in positions of authority.

An man casts his ballot in the governor's election at a polling station in Jakarta, Indonesia, on Wednesday.
(Ed Wray / Getty Images)

Purnama, who served as deputy governor when Widodo led Jakarta before becoming president in 2014, is known for a blunt and outspoken style. Although lauded for a can-do attitude and willingness to confront recalcitrant bureaucrats, his policy to clear the sprawling capital’s slums and his minority status made him a target of controversy.

Massive demonstrations in late 2016 jammed central Jakarta with hundreds of thousands of white-clad Islamists calling for Purnama to be jailed over remarks they saw as insulting the Koran. Purnama was shown in a video telling voters they were being deceived by people saying the Koran prohibited Muslims for voting for a non-Muslim. In the weeks leading up to Wednesday’s vote, Baswedan appeared in public with some of protest leaders.

Purnama’s cause wasn’t helped when Widodo — who initially blamed “political actors” for the demonstrations — joined the rallies from the nearby presidential palace and prayed with protest leaders.

But Purnama rebounded in pre-election polls, a sign that the demonstrations were not a barometer for voter support in the capital “because those rallies consisted of many people coming from outside Jakarta,” said Titi Anggraini, head of Perludem, an election advocacy group.


Responding to a question from The Times as he arrived at his campaign headquarters after voting, Baswedan was reluctant to predict victory in the run-off.

“So far, the campaign has gone well and we will have to wait to see what happens,” he said.

The next round of voting, on April 19, could be decided by the roughly 20% of voters who backed a third candidate, Agus Harimurti Yudhoyono, son of former two-term President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono.

Yudhoyono’s campaign was marred by allegations that his father tried to have a former head of Indonesia’s anti-corruption agency framed for murder. The former president rejected the allegations and accused Widodo’s government of eavesdropping on his communications.

Many analysts contend that Yudhoyono’s votes are likely to go to Baswedan in the next round. But others say that Purnama’s strong showing suggested that he had support from many Muslim voters.

Ethnic Chinese Indonesians make up an estimated 1% to 3% of the archipelago nation’s 250 million people.


Christina Soelystio, a Chinese Indonesian who voted at the same polling station as the governor, said the campaign had caused concerns among her ethnic group.

“Some Chinese see it as change for the better, some for the worse,” she said. “Some are worried about the sensitive situation. But others are proud of [Purnama].”

Speaking after casting his ballot at a green-hued mosque in southern Jakarta, Hadi Nasution said he voted for Baswedan “because the Koran says to vote for Muslims” and he was more experienced than Yudhoyono, the other Muslim candidate.

Roughneen is a special correspondent.


Woman is arrested in death of North Korean leader’s half brother, Malaysian police say


Romania is engulfed by protest in a political awakening of the young

Ireland has become a mecca for U.S. tech companies. Can Trump lure them home?