Get Opinion in your inbox -- sign up for our weekly newsletter
Opinion Editorial

L.A.'s $2-billion jail: It's not enough

A new L.A. jail won't solve all of the system's ills
To save money, L.A. should treat the mentally ill outside of jail

The cost of the new jail that Los Angeles County supervisors approved earlier this year is generally pegged at a staggering $2 billion, but that's really just shorthand. The figure doesn't include the cost of demolishing the decrepit Men's Central Jail, which a new facility would replace, and it doesn't include the cost of a replacement parking structure, which is an essential component of the project.

Nor does it include the opportunity cost of accommodating thousands of mentally ill inmates who could be treated as patients in the community, at less expense to the county, instead of as convicts or pretrial detainees in jail. Figures from across the country give encouraging evidence that people treated and supervised outside of jail are less prone to commit new crimes and cycle back through the jail system.

A recent how-to guide for potential diversion of the mentally ill away from jail underscores other potential costs and savings not included in the construction budget. The federal government picks up much of the cost for treating people in the community, the American Civil Liberties Union of Southern California and the Judge David L. Bazelon Center for Mental Health Law reminded county officials in their report, but not for the same people housed in jail.

Lest any county supervisors roll their eyes and say they already knew that, let's just say it was important to double-check. The supervisors were similarly on notice for more than a decade that the U.S. Department of Justice was monitoring the jails for inadequate treatment of mentally ill inmates and was filing regular reports on deficiencies. Yet board members claim to have been caught off guard last month by the department's warning that it was fed up with the county's sluggish pace of improvement and was seeking federal court oversight.

So it's important to point out that the costs of the new jail project are not limited to construction but are intertwined with the service that is provided and the policy decisions that are made. County supervisors should carefully read the ACLU-Bazelon plan for diversion of the mentally ill from jail, just as they should listen carefully later this month to Dist. Atty. Jackie Lacey's report on successful programs in Memphis, Tenn., Miami-Dade and other places where jail wings or whole jails have been closed, taxpayer money has been saved, crime has been reduced and, crucially, would-be inmates have received treatment in a community setting because decision-makers in those cities saw the wisdom of keeping mental patients away from jail.

Copyright © 2015, Los Angeles Times
Related Content
  • L.A.'s jails: Where not to treat the mentally ill

    L.A.'s jails: Where not to treat the mentally ill

    Los Angeles County supervisors talked for years about how it might make more sense to provide lower-cost healthcare at outpatient clinics instead of sending ambulatory patients to costlier beds at county hospitals. They talked — but did nothing until the mid-1990s, when soaring hospital costs pushed...

  • The mentally ill in our jails

    The mentally ill in our jails

    In L.A., a new district attorney and a recently appointed assistant sheriff for custody are taking a second look at policies that could divert low-risk mentally ill inmates into local treatment programs.

  • The death of Aylan Kurdi and the need for a moral policy on refugees

    The death of Aylan Kurdi and the need for a moral policy on refugees

    The photo was heartbreaking: A toddler in shorts and a red T-shirt lay face down at the edge of the surf, waves lapping at his head, his body settled into the sand like a piece of driftwood. His name, the world would learn, was Aylan Kurdi, and he and his Kurdish family were heading from Syria...

  • I've got the perfect job for Donald Trump right here

    I've got the perfect job for Donald Trump right here

    In a few days, the queen of England -- “Elizabeth the Second, by the grace of God of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland" and so forth -- becomes the longest-reigning monarch in the even longer history of that sceptered isle.

  • Making the most of a cigarette tax hike

    Making the most of a cigarette tax hike

    A bill that would more than triple the California cigarette tax was gaining little traction in the Legislature until it received a push forward from Gov. Jerry Brown's special legislative session on funding healthcare for the poor. The additional $2-per-pack tax imposed by the bill would initially...

  • Can Californians' privacy be protected in a wired world?

    Can Californians' privacy be protected in a wired world?

    State lawmakers have been trying for four years to provide Californians with more protection against warrantless snooping into their Internet-connected lives. The Legislature is about to take up the issue again, voting on a bill, SB 178, that would require state and local law enforcement agencies...

  • U.S. patience with Myanmar should only go so far

    U.S. patience with Myanmar should only go so far

    When the United States reestablished full diplomatic relations with Myanmar in 2012, the Obama administration was optimistic that the once-isolated Southeast Asian country, also known as Burma, was moving steadily along a path toward democracy. The ruling junta had recently turned over much of...

  • Living on $2 a day in America

    Living on $2 a day in America

    When we first met Ashley, she was 19 and a new mom, living with her mother, brother, uncle and cousin in one of Baltimore's public housing developments. Everyone in the home was out of work; no one was on welfare. The unit was furnished with only a three-legged table propped up against a wall,...