Scottish voters reject independence from Britain
OpinionOpinion L.A.

Retailers abusing workers: Black Friday's just the tip of the iceberg

ThanksgivingBlack Friday (shopping)Macy's Thanksgiving Day Parade

The public sure is angry about the Black Friday creep into Thanksgiving day, with sales clerks and other store employees forced to leave family gatherings early or forgo them altogether in order to sell people goods that might be cheaper than they would be in a couple of weeks, or might not.

It’s not a heartwarming thought, for sure. But why doesn't the public get a whole lot angrier about the shenanigans stores inflict on their employees the other 363 days of the year (which will probably become 364 pretty soon, when stores realize they could get a head start on their after-Christmas sales by not waiting until after Christmas)?

Retail stores commonly hire as many part-time employees as possible so they won’t have to give benefits as basic as a sick day off. They require employees to keep their time free for the days they’re scheduled to work the next week — but the store thinks nothing of calling them on slow sales days to tell them not to bother coming in. Or worse, after the sales clerks have dressed for work and spent the time and money to commute to the job, the store sends them home mid-shift because too few customers are showing up. Those aren’t hours of paid vacation, you can be sure. People who already earn low, low wages are suddenly stripped of work hours with no opportunity to arrange in advance for other ways to make money.

PHOTOS: The Macy's Thanksgiving Day Parade's most controversial attractions

No one would remain employed very long if he or she called in to the boss minutes before the work day was to start, saying, “Someone else will pay me 50 cents more an hour today, so I’m not showing up.”

It’s basic courtesy, right? Maybe at the social level, people feel more comfortable canceling plans on one another at the last moment. But when it comes to business, time is money — and at these wages, money for basic sustenance. On both sides, schedules should be honored.

People have always worked holidays — gas station attendants, nurses, police, journalists — when they were needed. And with families so scattered and overwhelmed, I’m seeing more friends whose Thanksgiving gatherings are held the weekend before or two weeks after. What matters isn’t the formally declared holiday but the feasting time together in service of gratitude.

I’m no fan of the Thanksgiving shopping trend, but the outrage over holiday work hours seems like one of those easy hits, full of the symbolism that gets people posting on Facebook, talking boycott or calling for new work laws. Yes, the creep into this family and national tradition is a sad sign of greed, but it’s a smaller one than the really damaging effects of greed on low-wage retail workers all year long. Let’s not allow the easy outrage to distract us from the bigger picture.


On the origins of food

A chance to settle the plastic bag ban debate

The Sacramento Bee test: Is it possible to comment civilly online?

Copyright © 2014, Los Angeles Times
Related Content
ThanksgivingBlack Friday (shopping)Macy's Thanksgiving Day Parade
  • To the greedy retailers ruining workers' Thanksgiving: It's gonna cost you
    To the greedy retailers ruining workers' Thanksgiving: It's gonna cost you

    Office supplies retailer Staples announced Wednesday that, for the first time, it would be opening its doors at 8 p.m. on Thanksgiving this year.

  • Don't let Kmart spoil Thanksgiving
    Don't let Kmart spoil Thanksgiving

    Remember Thanksgiving? The American holiday that, despite its misbegotten roots, we celebrate by taking the day off from work and overindulging with family and friends before putting on sweat pants and declaring to never eat so much food again?

  • Don't turn down a Medi-Cal gift, Gov. Brown
    Don't turn down a Medi-Cal gift, Gov. Brown

    The 2010 federal healthcare reform law let states expand Medicaid, the joint federal-state health insurance program for the poor, largely at federal expense. California is one of 27 states that have taken up Washington's offer, and well over 1 million newly eligible residents signed up...

  • A simple fix for L.A.'s voter turnout problem
    A simple fix for L.A.'s voter turnout problem

    When fewer than 1 in 4 registered Los Angeles voters bothered to cast a ballot for a new mayor last year, it set off a round of soul-searching among city officials and political experts. Why were voters so disengaged? What would make them show up at the polls? What does it say about the...

  • For Superior Court, Jacqueline Lewis and Andrew Stein
    For Superior Court, Jacqueline Lewis and Andrew Stein

    Los Angeles County voters will see two judicial runoffs on their Nov. 4 ballot, and it's a shame they can't just pick the two best candidates of the four. That's because the two best are running against each other. Deputy Dist. Atty. Dayan Mathai is an accomplished prosecutor...

  • To fight Ebola, create a Health Workforce Reserve force
    To fight Ebola, create a Health Workforce Reserve force

    A recent projection of the West Africa Ebola outbreak is that it now may take 12 to 18 months to control and will infect 100,000 people. President Obama announced the deployment of 3,000 military troops, more than a hundred Centers for Disease Control and Prevention personnel and millions of...