Advertisement

Officers Say They Weren’t Consulted on Ticket Fixes

Share
Times Staff Writers

Six police officers who wrote moving citations this year that were later dismissed by Chief Bill Kolender and his top aides said on Tuesday they were never contacted before the tickets were canceled.

The officers contradicted assertions by Kolender and Assistant Police Chief Bob Burgreen that thorough investigations had been conducted before moving violations were dismissed. The Times reported Tuesday that the chief’s office had canceled at least 30 moving violations since the beginning of last year and that in some cases excuses had been fabricated.

On Monday, Burgreen told The Times that a lieutenant in the chief’s office inquires into each ticket dismissal request by “checking with the officer and the officer’s notes to determine what the officer had to say and, if necessary, asking a supervisor to go by and check a scene.”

Advertisement

But Officer Mark Butterfield said he was never contacted before Burgreen dismissed a ticket for running a stop sign issued to Cornelia Gossage, the wife of San Diego Padres pitcher Rich Gossage. The explanation on the official police dismissal form said, “Driver had stopped back of the limit line out of the sight of the issuing officer.”

Butterfield said: “It would be kind of stupid for me to sit in a place where I couldn’t see (the violations).”

Butterfield said Gossage was one of numerous motorists he has cited for driving through the stop sign at La Cuenta Drive and Clairemont Mesa Boulevard. He said he believed none of the citations had been thrown out of court, where most people must go to dispute tickets.

Officer Donald R. Cone was dismayed that his superiors canceled two citations without his knowledge, one of which was issued to the son of Padres General Manager Jack McKeon.

When told that a police official used the excuse that the officer stopped the wrong car in the McKeon case, Cone said: “I only stop people I know who have violated the law. If that is what they’re saying, that’s bull. I don’t like that at all. Especially if that’s what they’re saying and they never asked me about it.”

Asked Tuesday how his office could dismiss tickets without consulting the officers involved, Burgreen said he had no explanation.

Advertisement

“I don’t have anything to say because I haven’t done what you’ve done,” Burgreen said. “I can’t give you an answer now and I’m not going to try to.”

Reached at his home, Kolender said: “I will look into it. That’s all I can say.”

Kolender and his top officers are under investigation by City Manager John Lockwood in connection with dismissing thousands of parking tickets and at least 30 moving violations.

The Times reported on Tuesday that a number of influential San Diegans have gone to the chief’s office to take care of moving citations. The revelations followed a monthlong Times investigation which revealed Sunday that Kolender and his top aides routinely dismiss thousands of parking tickets for friends, family members, former police officials, influential businessmen and the media.

In some cases, officials in Kolender’s office fabricated excuses for dismissing the parking and moving violations, The Times found. In others, no explanation was given at all.

The Times has obtained a copy of an internal memo Kolender wrote in 1981 in response to an officer’s concerns that the Police Department had engaged in “ticket-fixing.”

Officer Ann Hollinger wrote she had issued a moving citation to “an extremely belligerent and verbally abusive” motorist, who had a high-ranking police officer immediately cancel the ticket on the basis of their friendship.

Advertisement

“I was under the impression that ‘ticket-fixing’ is not only a violation of department policy but that it is also illegal,” wrote Hollinger, who is no longer on the Police Department and could not be reached.

In a memo dated Feb. 25, 1981, Kolender wrote he had determined that the motorist who had the ticket dismissed was a police informant. The chief explained that informants are responsible for most of the dismissal requests received by the Police Department.

He added: “This department has long had a reputation for professionalism and lack of corruption. One of the first indicators of problems within a department is ‘ticket-fixing.’ . . . I would like to personally assure you that requests for dismissal of this type are the extreme exception and are done only if it is clearly in the best interest of justice.”

Several officers who spoke with The Times said they were bothered by reports of widespread ticket-fixing within the chief’s office.

“I specifically wrote a ticket to a woman who said, ‘I’ll have this fixed. I won’t go to court.’ That is exactly what happened. That really (upset) me . . . ,” said one officer, who asked not to be named.

Others said they were outraged by the practice within the chief’s office of dismissing citations without informing the officers who wrote the tickets.

Advertisement

Cone, a police veteran of nine years, said he wasn’t surprised to learn that ticket-fixing occurs at any police agency, but he said the practice bothers him.

“If they want to dismiss tickets without my permission, that bothers me. I’m the one who wrote the ticket. I should be the one to dismiss it.

“If they hired me and trust me enough to carry a gun and do a job . . . I don’t like being second-guessed by someone sitting behind a desk and trying to second guess what the conditions are at the time.”

Cone said he has been approached only once to dismiss a moving violation, and that was by a sergeant who wanted a citation dropped against a police informant.

The Times tried to contact 12 officers who had written tickets and had them dismissed by the chief’s office within the last year. The Times reached eight officers, two of whom would not speak for the record. None of the officers said they had been contacted by the chief’s office before the dismissals. Here are the cases:

- Cone cited Kelly John McKeon, son of the Padres’ general manager, in June for driving 49 m.p.h. in a 35 m.p.h. zone in the 5500 block of Waring Road. The written explanation on the dismissal form, signed by Deputy Chief Don Davis, said: “Further investigation reveals that another vehicle may have actually been the vehicle traveling at an excessive speed.”

Advertisement

Cone said he never talked to Davis about the ticket, and emphatically denied that he made a mistake.

He also said that he’s never lost a court case for any of the tickets written for that stretch of Waring Road, where speeding motorists have prompted citizens to request police patrols.

- Cone also wrote a ticket in July to Rodney Keith Carey, who was accused of driving 35 m.p.h. in a 25 m.p.h. zone in the 7300 block of Margerum Avenue. Assistant Chief Bob Burgreen dismissed the ticket, and the written explanation said “subject en route home due to emergency.”

Had that been the case, Cone said, he would not have written the ticket. “I would probably offer them a ride and get an authorization for . . . red lights and a siren.”

Cone described the 7300 block of Margerum as a narrow, curving residential street that has been the scene of several hit-and-run accidents. The problem with speeders has been so bad there, he said, that 104 homeowners have signed a complaint asking for increased radar patrols.

“Every ticket I’ve gone to court on that street, which has not been very many . . . I’ve not lost those, mainly because I bring up in the testimony that I’m working a speed complaint, that I’ve got several citizens who were worried enough that they complained about it,” he said.

Advertisement

- Officer Justus Allen issued a speeding ticket to John Edwin Anderson of Poway for driving 70 m.p.h. on California 163 at Balboa Avenue. Kolender’s office lieutenant, Charles Ellison, sent the ticket to a traffic division lieutenant with the note: “Per The Big Guy. Cancel.”

The ticket was dismissed by Burgreen because the “driver was en route to hospital on emergency--so excited he drove by hospital off-ramps.”

Allen said no one at the Police Department talked to him about the citations. He added that he could not recall the driver saying anything about an emergency during the traffic stop.

- Officer Butterfield cited the wife of Padres’ relief pitcher Gossage for rolling through a stop sign. Cornelia Gossage told The Times on Monday that the Police Department dropped the ticket when her husband agreed to make an appearance at a fund-raiser for the Make-A-Wish Foundation, a police charity.

On Tuesday, Gossage said his wife was wrong. “I did that Make-A-Wish Foundation for two years,” he said. “There were no favors done on this ticket, I can tell you that.”

Gossage said he took the ticket to Lt. Bob Jones, who he met through the foundation, because he thought there were “mistakes” in the citation.

Advertisement

Burgreen signed the dismissal slip, which said the violation took place “out of sight of the issuing officer.” Butterfield said he wasn’t contacted before the dismissal.

- Officer Von Lee Dishong cited Conrad Burgreen, the assistant police chief’s uncle, in February for making an illegal left turn off El Cajon Boulevard. Kolender signed the dismissal form, which said the “officer was in an inappropriate position to observe the violation.”

On Monday, Kolender said he dismissed the ticket because it was not legitimately issued.

“He complained about the ticket. We checked it out. I can’t remember the particulars. The man was right, so we canceled it. It’s just that simple.” But Dishong said no one talked to him about the ticket.

“It doesn’t make sense to write a ticket for something you can’t see,” Dishong said. “Especially me, because if I have any doubt at all, I’ll either give them a warning or I won’t stop them.”

Advertisement