Advertisement

Earthquake: The Road to Recovery : Emergency Systems Kicked In on Cue, Averting Chaos : Preparedness: Costly precautions prevent loss of water, release of sewage and hazardous chemicals.

Share
TIMES STAFF WRITERS

Toxic gas billows from dozens of plants and factories. Sewage spews into the streets and floods the ocean by the millions of gallons. And flames roar out of control, as fire hoses and hydrants run out of water.

Those dark scenes might have descended on Los Angeles in last month’s earthquake were it not for years of planning, scores of technological advances and several billion dollars in public works improvements, officials said.

Although dozens of deaths and devastating property damage understandably have received the most attention since the quake, many government officials, business people and others said residents should take some comfort in the calamities that were averted.

Advertisement

Los Angeles’ power, water, sewage and toxic control systems functioned almost flawlessly after the quake, and based on that experience, many officials are cautiously optimistic those key services will survive the much-anticipated Big One as well.

*

When Southern California was throttled at 4:31 a.m. on Jan. 17, power was lost throughout the city. That could have been disastrous for a city sewer system that carries nearly half a billion gallons of waste every day. But the system shifted almost seamlessly into emergency mode.

Backup generators have been installed at most of the 54 pumping stations along 6,500 miles of sewer lines to keep waste flowing even during power outages. And an internal power station was built at the Hyperion Treatment Plant, the oceanside facility in Playa del Rey that processes three-quarters of the 435 million gallons of sewage created in the city each day.

The work was part of court-ordered improvements to reduce the pollutants dumped into Santa Monica Bay--a $3.5-billion reconstruction job that is 60% complete.

The key to the emergency response was the Hyperion plant, which switched to the internal power system fueled by methane gas and dried sewage sludge.

“We didn’t miss a beat,” said Sam Furuta, assistant director of the city’s Bureau of Sanitation. “The internal power system came on and kept powering us throughout the incident.”

Advertisement

With the plant still on-line, it was able to serve its intended purpose as the backstop for two other sewage plants that do not have emergency generators. More than 37 million gallons of effluent was diverted from the Donald C. Tillman Water Reclamation Plant in the Sepulveda Basin and the Los Angeles-Glendale Water Reclamation Plant near Griffith Park. Those facilities had to shunt waste to Hyperion for half a day until they regained power.

If Hyperion had lost all power, the outcome would have been much worse. The plant would have been down for at least an hour and 45 minutes, long enough that it would have been forced to dump about 25 million gallons of sewage into Santa Monica Bay with only minimal treatment, public works engineers said.

Instead, the city system lost just 300 gallons, from a single sewer main that was crushed in southwest Los Angeles. The new backup generators, installed at pumping plants around the city, helped avert much larger spills.

“That prevented sewage from literally flowing in the streets,” said Mark Gold, staff scientist for the environmental group Heal the Bay and a frequent critic of the sewer system. “That would have created a much greater risk of some sort of public health outbreak.”

*

Southern California’s major water supplier, the Metropolitan Water District, also relied on new technology and innovation to weather the earthquake.

MWD officials feared that in a major catastrophe they would have to wait in line with other customers to order new pipe to replace damaged lines. They also worried that the makers of giant main lines were so distant that they could not deliver to Southern California promptly.

Advertisement

So, after the 1971 Sylmar quake, the giant agency created its own pipe-making plant.

With its own facility and metal supplies in La Verne when the quake hit, the MWD was able to fabricate and replace in just a day, two critical, seven-foot-diameter sections of pipe that had been damaged at the MWD’s Jensen Pumping plant in the San Fernando Valley.

Without that pipeline, much of the Valley would have been without water within about 72 hours, when reservoirs’ supplies would have run low.

The other major supplier, the city’s Department of Water and Power, suffered breaks in its two aqueducts that feed the Valley. With the MWD back in service so quickly, water was routed to all customers except those who suffered local damage to mains running under city streets.

“We saw the potential for this problem in 1971,” said Richard Balcerzak, assistant general manager. “This is a cheap solution, and one that really paid off.”

Another innovation may have prevented even further damage at the Jensen facility in Granada Hills--a critical transmission point for water in the California Aqueduct.

It had sustained major damage in the Sylmar quake, in part from the phenomenon of liquefaction--when solid ground turns to the consistency of quicksand as water tables are suddenly elevated. A flood and certain fatalities were only avoided because the plant had not yet gone on-line, MWD officials said.

Advertisement

*

To correct the problem, former MWD Chief Engineer Robert Mohle embraced a revolutionary design in which the water district drilled 1,100 holes in the ground, two feet in diameter and 60 feet deep. The “Mohle holes,” as they were quickly dubbed by MWD engineers, absorb water as it rises and limit the effects of liquefaction, Balcerzak said.

MWD engineers believe the holes helped neutralize the shock waves from the quake and minimize the damage.

“We feel pretty good about what we did,” Balcerzak said. “We fared pretty doggone good.”

An untold amount of additional funds have been spent by private industry to limit another potential earthquake disaster--the release of hazardous materials. Authorities say that widespread compliance with an 8-year-old state law helped limit hazardous releases to a handful of relatively minor incidents.

In Los Angeles, about 350 companies have been found to hold enough acutely hazardous chemicals to pose a potential public health threat if storage containers are damaged. About 200 that store the most dangerous compounds have completed the state-mandated risk management prevention programs to improve storage and responses to emergencies.

“In terms of hazardous materials it really went well,” said David Zocchetti, manager of the hazardous-materials unit for the state Office of Emergency Services. “In the last few years in Los Angeles a lot of resources have gone into these programs. And it really showed.”

*

The exceptions were a train derailment in Northridge that dumped two tankers of sulfuric acid, the upending of laboratory chemicals at Cal State Northridge and a liquid propane leak near the Van Nuys Airport. The only serious injury came when a man was burned after a crude oil pipeline ruptured and ignited in Pacoima.

Advertisement

But many more businesses reported no serious mishaps.

Officials said the Anheuser-Busch brewery in Van Nuys demonstrated the value of preparedness.

Three years ago the plant alongside the San Diego Freeway revamped an ammonia refrigeration system in order to limit any release of ammonia liquid or gas. Instead of a continuous loop for cooling beer, the system was divided into 25 separate compartments, each with automatic shut-off valves.

When the quake hit, one damaged section of the cooling system was immediately isolated from the rest. Just 500 pounds of ammonia was released from a system that holds about 100,000 pounds, according to initial estimates.

“It could have been many, many times more,” said one Busch official, who asked not to be identified. “Someone manually would have shut off the system eventually. We would not let it go on. But the system did it automatically.”

Years of planning also enabled the city’s electrical system to emerge from the disaster virtually unscathed. As the quake rocked thousands of power lines that crisscross the city, scores of transformers shorted out, showering the night sky with blue and white sparks. That touched off dangerous electrical surges, which began backing up through the power grid, threatening to damage critical electrical facilities.

The utility immediately went into its “automatic shutdown mode,” turning off power before it could cause any harm. Given the extraordinary force of the temblor, the process continued until the entire city was dark. But the system was saved.

Advertisement

Within minutes, engineers began the process of cranking the system up again. Many residents had electricity within 38 minutes. By nightfall, 60% of the city had power restored. And within 24 hours, 93% of residents had power.

Otherwise, restoring power from scratch, a so-called “black start,” could have taken days. The DWP avoided that in part because it has power-sharing compacts with utilities as far away as Oregon and Washington, said Marcie L. Edwards, an engineer at the DWP’s emergency control center.

Routing power from these sources around the worst of the quake damage, DWP engineers were able to kick-start their own generators. By 8 a.m., the first of the DWP’s generating facilities was back in operation.

“In the (electric) business that is almost unheard of,” Edwards said. Lots of utilities use similar series of sensors and switches, she said, concluding: “What’s important is that ours worked.”

Advertisement