After the Grammys, it may be time’s up for the music industry
And now it’s the Grammys’ turn.
So far, the Recording Academy has largely avoided the sort of criticism over lack of diversity that’s been leveled at the Oscars. But hours after men swept all but one of the categories given out on live television, #GrammysSoMale was trending.
Kesha’s impassioned performance of “Praying” was certainly the highlight of this year’s Grammys, but the audience’s emotional response to the anthem of female-empowerment appeared to be skin-deep when the song lost to Ed Sheeran’s “Shape of You” for pop solo performance.
Indeed, of the 84 Grammy categories handed out Sunday only a dozen or so went to women or acts co-led by women, which is pretty much in keeping with the damning research paper recently published by Stacy L. Smith, Marc Choueiti and Kate Pieper of the USC Annenberg Inclusion Initiative. Looking at the gender breakdown of nominees, it found that just 9.3% of them between 2013 and 2018 were female.
Having apparently learned nothing from the many men forced to walk back tone-deaf commentary during the #MeToo movement, Recording Academy President Neil Portnow almost immediately made things worse. He responded to the hashtag by urging women to “step up.”
Just as if he hadn’t listened to Kesha’s song, or to singer, actor and producer Janelle Monae’s introduction: “To those who would dare try and silence us, we offer you two words: Time’s up.”
Identifying issues including wage inequality, discrimination, harassment and abuse of power, she declared, “It’s not just going on in Hollywood. It’s not just going on in Washington. It’s right here in our industry as well.”
Just like the #OscarsSoWhite campaign forced the film academy to reconsider its almost all-white, mostly male membership, this year’s male-dominated Grammy results prompted many variations on the same unanswered question: Who, exactly, is deciding the winners of music’s most coveted award?
But the leadership remains unwilling to offer basic data on its voters, such as race and gender.
At the Grammys post-telecast press conference, Portnow was asked directly about male domination on Sunday.
“I think it has to begin with women who have the creativity in their hearts and their souls,” he answered, “who want to be musicians, who want to be engineers, who want to be producers, who want to be part of the industry on an executive level — to step up, because I think they would be welcome,” Portnow said.
The backlash was swift.
“Neil getting up there and saying that women should ‘step up’ just shows just out of touch he is and how out of touch the organization is,” said Dorothy Carvello, the former record executive and author of the upcoming music-industry memoir “Anything for a Hit: An A&R Woman’s Story of Surviving the Music Industry.”
“Women in music don’t need to ‘step up’ – women have been stepping since the beginning of time,” recording artist Pink posted on Twitter. “Stepping up, and also stepping aside. Women owned music this year. They’ve been killing it. And every year before this.”
The Recording Academy did not respond to repeated requests for comment.
Further inflaming many critically-attuned music fans, for the coveted album of the year Grammy the academy overlooked widely regarded and topical hip-hop releases from Kendrick Lamar and Jay-Z in favor of Bruno Mars’ album of retro-focused pop, “24K Magic.”
The slight renewed long-held criticism that, absent a diverse membership, the Grammys were denying a major award to rap, the culture’s dominant musical genre for going on two decades now.
Over the years the academy has repeatedly been called out by Kanye West, J. Cole, 50 Cent, rap mogul Steve Stoute (he once spent $40,000 on an ad to criticize the awards) and Jay-Z, who went home empty-handed despite having the most nominations this year.
Bruno Mars, center, accepts album of the year for “24K Magic” with his production team onstage.(Kevin Winter / Getty Images)
Khalid, from left, Logic and Alessia Cara perform “1-800-273-8255" as the suicide hotline prevention number appears on screen.(Kevin Winter / Getty Images)
Alessia Cara performs her part in “1-800-273-8255" during an in memoriam tribute.(Matt Sayles / Invision / AP)
Logic performs his suicide-awareness anthem “1-800-273-8255.”(Matt Sayles / Invision / AP)
Chris Stapleton and Emmylou Harris perform “Wildflowers” during an in memoriam tribute to Tom Petty.(Matt Sayles / Invision / AP)
Alicia Keys presents the award for record of the year to Bruno Mars for “24K Magic.”(Matt Sayles / Invision / AP)
Sza performs “Broken Clocks.”(Matt Sayles / Invision / AP)
Patti LuPone performs “Don’t Cry For Me Argentina” during a tribute to Leonard Bernstein and Andrew Lloyd Webber.(Matt Sayles / Invision )
Ben Platt, right, performs “Somewhere” during a tribute to Leonard Bernstein and Andrew Lloyd Webber.(Matt Sayles / Invision / AP)
Sir Elton John, left, and Miley Cyrus perform his “Tiny Dancer.”(Kevin Winter / Getty Images)
U2 appears via satellite as they perform “Get Out of Your Own Way” on the Hudson River.(Matt Sayles / Invision / AP)
Kesha (unseen) is hugged by Bebe Rexha, Cindy Lauper, Camila Cabello and Andra Day after performing her song “Praying.”(Timothy A. Clary / AFP / Getty Images)
Kesha performs “Praying.”(Matt Sayles / Invision / AP)
Chris Stapleton, left, accepts the award for best country album for “From A Room: Volume 1" from presenters Donnie Wahlberg and Hailee Steinfeld, who donned cowboy hats before calling his name.(Matt Sayles / Invision / AP)
Janelle Monáe told the audience that “time’s up for pay inequality, discrimination or harassment of any kind and the abuse of power.”(Timothy A. Clary / AFP / Getty Images)
Maren Morris, left, and Eric Church perform.(Matt Sayles / Invision / AP)
The Brothers Osborne perform as names of victims of tragedies appear onscreen.(Matt Sayles / Invision / AP)
Bryson Tiller, from second left, Rihanna, and DJ Khaled perform “Wild Thoughts.”(Matt Sayles / Matt Sayles/Invision/AP)
Rihanna performs “Wild Thoughts.”(Matt Sayles / Invision / AP )
Shaggy, left, and Sting perform “Englishman in New York.”(Matt Sayles / Invision / AP)
Comedian Dave Chappelle, left, accepts the comedy album Grammy for “The Age of Spin & Deep in the Heart of Texas” from Trevor Noah, right.(Kevin Winter / Getty Images)
Cardi B, left, and Bruno Mars, right, perform “Finesse.”(Matt Sayles / Invision / AP)
Cardi B performs “Finesse” with Bruno Mars.(Matt Sayles / Invision / AP)
Bruno Mars performs “Finesse.”(Matt Sayles / Invision / AP)
Pink performs “Wild Hearts Can’t Be Broken.”(Matt Sayles / Invision / AP)
Joe Saylor, left, Jon Batiste and Gary Clark Jr. perform a tribute to Chuck Berry and Fats Domino.(Matt Sayles / Invision / AP)
Alessia Cara accepts best new artist Grammy Award.(Kevin Winter / Getty Images )
Karen Fairchild, left, Jimi Westbrook, Kimberly Schlapman and Philip Sweet of Little Big Town perform “Better Man.”(Matt Sayles / Invision / AP)
Rihanna and Kendrick Lamar accept best rap/sung performance for “Loyalty.”(Kevin Winter / Getty Images)
Sam Smith performs “Pray.”(Matt Sayles / Invision / AP)
Host James Corden opens the 60th Grammy Awards.(Kevin Winter / Getty Images )
Lady Gaga plays piano as she performs onstage.(Kevin Winter / Getty Images)
Mark Ronson and Lady Gaga perform at the 60th Grammy Awards.(Matt Sayles / Invision / AP)
Comedian Dave Chappelle speaks onstage in between Kendrick Lamar’s performance.(Kevin Winter / Getty Images)
Kendrick Lamar, center, performs at the 60th Grammy Awards.(Matt Sayles / Invision / AP)
Kendrick Lamar opens the 60th Grammy Awards.(Matt Sayles / Invision / AP)
Paul Shaffer, left, presents the award for traditional pop vocal album to recording artist Tony Bennett, center, and audio engineer Dae Bennett for “Tony Bennett Celebrates 90,” at the(Theo Wargo / Getty Images)
Left to right, recording artists Zachary Scott Carothers, Eric Howk, Jason Wade Sechrist, Kyle O’Quin of Portugal. The Man, winners of pop duo/group performance for “Feel It Still,” accept the award(Theo Wargo / Getty Images)
James Fauntleroy accepts the award for R&B song(Theo Wargo / Getty Images)
Dwan Hill accepts the gospel performance/song award for “Let Them Fall in Love”(Matt Sayles / Invision / Associated Press)
Chris Stapleton accepts the country solo performance award for “Either Way” a(Matt Sayles / Invision / Associated Press)
Members of Ladysmith Black Mambazo, winners of world music album for “Shaka Zulu Revisited: 30th Anniversary Celebration,” accept the award(Theo Wargo / Getty Images)
Jason Isbell accepts the American roots song award for “If We Were Vampires”(Matt Sayles / Invision / Associated Press)
Ice T performs with Body Count during the Grammy Awards pre-telecast show.(Timothy A. Clary / AFP / Getty Images)
Jazzmeia Horn performs during(Theo Wargo / Getty Images)
Justin Hurwitz accepts the compilation soundtrack for visual media award for “La La Land.”(Matt Sayles / Invision / Associated Press)
Stile Antico performs at the 60th Grammy Awards pre-telecast show.(Matt Sayles / Invision / Associated Press)
Reba McEntire accepts the award for roots gospel album for “Sing It Now: Songs of Faith & Hope.”(Matt Sayles / Invision / Associated Press)
Residente accepts the Latin rock, urban or alternative album for “Residente.”(Matt Sayles / Invision / Associated Press)
India Arie performs during the 60th Grammy Awards pre-telecast show in New York.(Timothy A. Clary / AFP / Getty Images)
Paul Shaffer performs at the 60th Grammy Awards pre-telecast show.
Paul Shaffer and the W.M.D. Band perform at the 60th Grammy Awards pre-telecast show.(Matt Sayles / Invision / Associated Press)
In the weeks before Sunday’s awards, Jay-Z was set to perform but ultimately pulled out. Producers said the rapper simply wanted to “enjoy” the night, but it’s hard not to flash back to last year when he watched his wife, Beyoncé, shut out in major categories — a snub felt by many, including the night’s big winner, Adele. “What the … does she have to do to win album of the year?” Adele said backstage.
Last year, Chance the Rapper became the the first black hip-hop artist since Lauryn Hill in 1999 to win the trophy for new artist. Song and record of the year trophies have never gone to rap artists. Had Jay-Z or Lamar taken the night’s biggest honor, album of the year, he would have only been the third rap artist to do so.
When asked whether the telecast needed to have more rap showcased on-air this year given the genre’s dominance in nominations, Portnow said he didn’t think so, at least not during this year’s 60th anniversary return to the East Coast.
“It’s got to be a balance,” he said.
For Portnow, the goal is “creating the night to be a real experience, and something special that people will talk about for years. We have to play to all of that.”
Acknowledging that he didn’t have personal experience “with the kinds of brick walls that [women] face,” Portnow suggested widening the opportunities for inclusion by creating mentorships and opportunities “not only for women, but for all people. And, moving forward, creating that next generation of artists who feel like they can do anything and say anything.”
Whether the Grammys are leading by example is debatable: Ratings for this year’s CBS broadcast dropped 24% over last year’s show.
The criticism of the results comes less than a month after the launch of the high-profile Time’s Up campaign, geared to shed light on gender discrimination and sex abuse in the entertainment business. The initiative made its intentions prominently known at the Golden Globes. To extend the message on Sunday, an organization called Voices in Entertainment invited Grammy attendees to wear white roses in support.
“We can’t change the number of nominees, but the conversation changed completely,” stressed Meg Harkins, a marketing executive at Roc Nation and a co-founder of the white rose initiative. “To see Janelle Monae’s speech and all those women up there wearing white and supporting Kesha was incredible.”
Harkins agreed that the Grammys voting process was at least partly to blame for the outcome. “I’m a voting member, I’m a part of this institution,” she said. “The qualification for voting membership has to be reviewed. We have to be more inclusive if we’re going to make it better.”
During her Grammy acceptance speech for new artist, Alessia Cara – the lone female victor of the CBS broadcast – called for more opportunity for artists because “everyone deserves the same shot.”
“There’s some artists that have started some incredible trends,” she added, “and they don’t get the same shot because they aren’t on the charts or are particularly mainstream.”
Times staff writers August Brown and Gerrick D. Kennedy contributed to this report.
Inside the business of entertainment
The Wide Shot brings you news, analysis and insights on everything from streaming wars to production — and what it all means for the future.
You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times.