Top contenders share strong ties to Jewish community
Eric Garcetti jokingly refers to himself as a “kosher burrito.” Wendy Greuel’s mother accurately predicted that she would “marry a nice Jewish boy.” And Jan Perry frequently talks about how her conversion to Judaism affects her worldview.
The field vying to become Los Angeles’ next mayor is diverse in many ways, but one commonality that binds three of the top candidates is their long-standing ties to the Jewish community. All are highlighting their history in hopes of gaining an edge in this key voter bloc.
Jewish voters make up a small sliver of the city’s registered voters, about 6%. But they are receiving an outsized amount of attention because they vote in high numbers, even in low-turnout city elections, where they tend to account for nearly one-fifth of the ballots cast.
“It’s a very high turnout group with a very high propensity to vote,” said Raphael J. Sonenshein, executive director of the Edmund G. “Pat” Brown Institute of Public Affairs at Cal State L.A. “In theory, it would be very important if it was a monolithic group. But that depends on the political situation.”
Nationally, Jewish voters overwhelmingly vote Democratic and are highly focused on the security of Israel. In city elections, they are not as motivated by a single issue. But when they have coalesced behind a candidate, they have often been part of successful alliances to win citywide office, such as when they teamed with African American voters to elect Tom Bradley mayor. He was first elected in 1973.
If county Supervisor Zev Yaroslavsky were in this race, many political observers believe he would win the lion’s share of the Jewish vote because of his name recognition after nearly four decades in local elected office; his representation of the Westside and the Valley, the two geographic centers of the Jewish vote; and because he began his career as an activist working for Jews in the Soviet Union.
“Had Zev been in the race, this would have made it a more challenging situation for all these candidates,” said Steven Windmueller, professor emeritus of American Jewish affairs at Hebrew Union College-Jewish Institute of Religion in Los Angeles. “With him not in this race, that opens the door to everyone having a play in the Jewish community.”
Garcetti, Greuel and Perry lack Yaroslavsky’s identity in the Jewish community, and all have sought his blessing. He has not decided whether he will endorse.
“I’ve met with all of them, I know them all, I’ve worked with them all,” Yaroslavsky said. “They’re all good people.... One of them is going to be mayor, and I wish them the best of luck once they get that job because it’s going to be one monster of a job.”
The candidates have been regularly courting the community, reaching out through advertising in Jewish media, attending dinners for organizations that promote Israel and speaking at forums put on by Jewish institutions.
Like all politicians, they tailor their message to the audience. During a Tuesday mayoral gathering at the Sinai Temple in West Los Angeles, Garcetti and Greuel mentioned enjoying attending services there. Perry and Garcetti pledged that the principles of Judaism would guide them if elected mayor. Perry also described her conversion, saying that it was “a life-transforming experience, one that sustains me in my work and my life.”
At a January forum at the Beth Jacob Congregation in Beverly Hills, Garcetti spoke of his mother’s ancestors fleeing pogroms and attending the Breed Street shul, the teachings of the Talmud and his support for the Israeli soldier Gilad Shalit, who was seized by Palestinian militants and held in captivity for five years. Perry pledged if elected mayor to help families that cannot afford to send their children to private Jewish day schools. Greuel mentioned the Jewish high holidays and spoke of her pride in standing with the state of Israel.
The candidates’ statements may sound like pandering, but some Jewish voters give them a pass because of their track record.
“They’re not showing up at Jewish events in 2012 and 2013 because there’s an election looming,” said Sam Yebri, an attorney and chairman of the Jewish Federation’s New Leaders Project. “None of them are strangers to the Jewish community. They have been so involved, and their support is genuine. That’s exciting and refreshing, but it does make it harder.”
Garcetti’s father is Mexican and was raised Catholic; his mother is Jewish. The family attended temple during the High Holy Days but were not observant Jews. Joking that he was raised by an atheist and an agnostic, Garcetti says he sought to become closer to his faith in his youth, attending services with more observant cousins, making his parents send him to Jewish summer camp and joining a minyan (a Jewish prayer group) when he was a graduate student at Oxford University.
Perry was raised in a church-attending Protestant family in Ohio, occasionally getting in trouble as a child for questioning the doctrine. When she transferred to USC, Perry said she was on a quest for spiritual meaning in her life, which led her to long conversations with the rabbi at the Hillel Center, which led to two years of studying for her conversion.
Greuel is Christian but is married to a prominent member of Los Angeles’ Jewish community, Dean Schramm. One of the turning points of their courtship was when he asked if she would raise a child in his faith and she agreed to. Their son, now 9, attends Hebrew school weekly. Greuel said she was also shaped by working with people with strong ties to the community, including Bradley and the founders of DreamWorks.
Alex Davis, 19, said he had never heard of so many politicians who share his faith competing in the same contest.
“That’s awesome. It’s nice to, as a Jewish adult, have some representation in your elected government,” said the USC political science major, who is undecided about whom he’ll vote for. “It’s a unique thing that is inspirational. It seems like they’re very open about it, which is very cool.”
The candidates noted that the field reflected Los Angeles’ diversity.
“So one of us is Jewish, born to a Jewish mother but with an Italian last name. One of us is an African American woman who converted and who is Jewish. And you have a woman from the Valley who in the words of Groucho Marx is ‘Jew-ish,’ who’s married to a Jew,” Garcetti said.
“So there you go.”
The perils of parenting through a pandemic
What’s going on with school? What do kids need? Get 8 to 3, a newsletter dedicated to the questions that keep California families up at night.
You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times.