Advertisement

Teens who died in Asiana crash were bound for L.A. church camp

Congregants pray during services at West Valley Christian Church, where Wang Linjia and Ye Mengyuan and others had been headed to attend a church camp.
(Brian van der Brug / Los Angeles Times)
Share

SAN FRANCISCO — Wang Linjia and Ye Mengyuan, 16-year-old girls from the eastern Chinese province of Zhejiang, were supposed to arrive at West Valley Christian Church and School on Monday for a three-week American adventure.

They were supposed to work on their English skills at the West Hills church-run summer camp in the mornings and tour local universities come afternoon. They were supposed to live with host families in the San Fernando Valley and go sightseeing on weekends. They were supposed to tour the Bay Area before heading south.

They were supposed to have fun.

But on Saturday morning, Asiana Airlines Flight 214 crash-landed at San Francisco International Airport with 307 passengers and crew members on board — including Linjia, Mengyuan and 32 other students from Jiangshan Middle School and their teacher.

Advertisement

Linjia and Mengyuan, whose bodies were found a mile apart, were the dramatic crash’s sole fatalities, although 182 other people were taken to hospitals after the incident. At least two of those were paralyzed with spinal injuries, and eight remained in critical condition Sunday, hospital officials said.

One of the dead girls was found on the runway, and officials said she probably was ejected when the Boeing 777 crash-landed before bursting into flames. The other, whose body was found closer to the wreckage, may have been run over by an emergency vehicle responding to the crash. Officials have not said which girl was which.

San Francisco Fire Department spokeswoman Mindy Talmadge confirmed that one girl’s body “did have injuries that were consistent with having been run over by a vehicle.... There were multiple agencies on the field yesterday, and the [National Transportation Safety Board] is conducting a thorough investigation of the entire accident scene.”

San Mateo County Coroner Robert J. Foucrault said an autopsy will determine the cause of death. His office is coordinating with the Chinese Consulate to obtain dental and fingerprint records for the two girls.

“What we are trying to do is determine whether this young lady died of an airline crash or of a secondary incident,” Foucrault said in an interview. “If it does involve a secondary incident, the people who may be involved should be aware of it, as well as the family.”

Flight 214 originated in Shanghai and stopped in Seoul en route to San Francisco. Asiana Airlines — whose president apologized for the accident during a televised news conference in Seoul — did not identify the two girls until early Sunday morning, more than 14 hours after the crash.

Advertisement

Those post-crash hours were frantic.

Kevin Cheng, who works for KNC Holidays Transportation, was supposed to meet the Jiangshan Middle School contingent and escort them to a Marriott hotel in San Jose. That’s where a tour bus was scheduled to pick them up Sunday and drive them to West Hills, a neighborhood in the city of Los Angeles in the west San Fernando Valley.

Moments after the crash, the teacher traveling with the Jiangshan group called Cheng on his cellphone to say that she and most of the students had escaped the burning plane. But the group had become separated, she told him, and she still was trying to find three of the students.

‘“We’re missing three, we’re missing three’ — she kept calling and telling me that, begging me to help find them,” Cheng said in Mandarin.

He jotted the names on a scrap of paper. He ran through the crowds of reporters and worried onlookers. He asked the airport to broadcast the three names. After Cheng had been at SFO more than four hours, his boss called him and told him he could leave.

Throughout the night, Cheng said, reporters from China called asking for news. Parents of the children on the plane were anxious and keeping vigil at home, they told him.

The Chinese Consulate in San Francisco released the names of the 141 Chinese citizens on board the flight in small batches as the passengers were confirmed safe. When Cheng woke up Sunday morning, he combed the alerts on the consulate’s website, searching for the names he had written down the day before.

Advertisement

Only one of the three students had been confirmed safe. He read the fifth alert when it popped up on his screen, searching for the other two.

“Not here,” he said during an interview from his home in San Jose. “Sixth batch, seventh batch, eighth batch,” he mumbled out loud as he read through the names. “Wow, that’s it so far. They’re not here.”

The other two names he had written down were Linjia and Mengyuan.

As the investigation into the cause of the crash continued Sunday, the flight’s last moments became clearer.

Wen Zhang was sitting in row 40 with her husband and their 4-year-old son. The little boy, she said, couldn’t wait to stay in an American hotel. Her sister’s family was in row 39. The group was planning a road trip: Los Angeles; Las Vegas; Sedona, Ariz.

But when the plane’s tail skidded across the runway on landing, a large hole ripped open in the fuselage just a few feet from Zhang’s seat. Bags and air masks tumbled down. Windows broke. The cabin went dark. Ashes flew.

“The plane’s tail touched the ground directly,” Zhang, 34, told reporters outside San Francisco General Hospital. “Everybody screamed.”

Advertisement

Her husband grabbed their son, Qixuan Xu. They walked out of the plane and onto the runway through a gaping hole where a bathroom had been. The little boy’s left leg was bleeding, crushed by the seat in front of him. The three were taken by ambulance to San Francisco General.

As of Sunday morning, the boy’s leg had been operated on. Zhang was still waiting to talk with her sister, who had been taken to Stanford University Medical Center.

“I feel lucky,” she said, “because we have six family members traveling on this plane, and we are OK.”

A drop of blood stained her green cardigan.

The wounded had arrived at San Francisco General in three waves, said Dr. Margaret Knudson, chief of surgery.

The most serious, life-threatening injuries were spinal fractures that caused paralysis, abdominal injuries and head trauma, Knudson said. Others suffered sternum fractures, caused when the seats in front of them collapsed.

Most of the 53 patients treated at San Francisco General had been sitting near the back of the plane. Two of those in critical condition had “road rash” all over their bodies, Knudson said, suggesting they may have been dragged along the pavement.

Advertisement

The surgeon, who treated trauma patients in Iraq in 2008, said that “whoever triages patients at the airport did a fantastic job.” At least two might not have survived had they arrived at the hospital much later, she said.

Stanford hospital treated 55 patients from the crash, 11 of whom were admitted. Two remained in critical condition. Seven others were admitted to Lucile Packard Children’s Hospital at Stanford; all were listed in good condition.

At West Valley Christian Church and School, where Linjia and Mengyuan would have gone to summer camp, church leaders have scheduled a prayer vigil for Thursday night. The West Hills congregation has also launched a fundraising drive in hopes of replacing the surviving teens’ luggage and clothing.

It is uncertain, said senior minister Glenn Kirby, whether the survivors would continue on to West Hills or simply return home to China. He said that it had been difficult for him to preach the sermon he had planned for Sunday morning, before Flight 214 crashed.

“I can only imagine as a parent how those parents feel,” he said. “I grieve with them, even though I’ve never met them.”

lee.romney@latimes.com

Advertisement

victoria.kim@latimes.com

rosanna.xia@latimes.com

Romney and Kim reported from San Francisco and Xia from Los Angeles. Times staff writers Maria L. La Ganga, Kate Mather and Laura J. Nelson in San Francisco and Bob Pool, Matt Stevens and Garrett Therolf in Los Angeles contributed to this report.

Advertisement