No blows captured by CHP dash cam in Kern County fatality
The dashboard camera of a California Highway Patrol cruiser recorded officers and deputies coming and going from a fatal confrontation last week in East Bakersfield, but it did not capture any blows, officials said.
David Sal Silva, 33, a father of four, was pronounced dead Wednesday, less than an hour after eyewitnesses reported seeing several Kern County sheriff’s deputies repeatedly strike the man in the head with batons as he lay on the pavement.
Deputies had responded to a report of an intoxicated man. In addition to the deputies and a Sheriff’s Department sergeant, two California Highway Patrol officers were involved in the incident.
CHP Capt. Mike Cardoza said the cruiser’s “dash cam” did not capture the incident because “it was out of the sight of the direction the car was pointing.”
Cardoza said the camera did capture deputies’ and officers’ movements to and from the scene. The video, however, won’t be released because it still remains evidence in the ongoing investigation, he said.
Cardoza said the CHP is conducting its own investigation into incident. He said he could not describe the CHP officers’ actions until the probe is completed but noted that “our involvement is very limited.”
Raymond Pruitt, a Sheriff’s Department spokesman, said the six deputies and the sergeant present during the fatal incident last week “have been released to full duty.”
The department has identified those involved as deputies Ryan Greer, Tanner Miller, Jeffrey Kelly, Luis Almanza, Brian Brock, David Stephens and Sgt. Douglas Sword.
Sheriff Donny Youngblood said a cause of death for Silva will be determined after toxicological tests, which could take up to 120 days to be completed.
Youngblood cautioned in an interview Monday that it is too early in the investigation to reach any conclusions about Silva’s death.
In an unusual move, sheriff’s officials detained two witnesses who had videotaped the incident on their phones. They were released after several hours and only after they surrendered their phones to deputies.
Witnesses to the incident have described a violent scene, in which deputies repeatedly struck Silva in the head with batons.
“I saw two sheriff’s deputies on top of this guy, just beating him,” eyewitness Ruben Ceballos said in an interview Monday. “He was screaming in pain ... asking for help. He was incapable of fighting back -- he was outnumbered, on the ground. They just beat him up.”
One woman frantically called 911, telling the operator: “The guy was laying on the floor and eight sheriffs ran up and started beating him up with sticks. The man is dead laying right here, right now. I got it all on video camera and I’m sending it to the news. These cops have no reason to do this to this man.”
The decision to take the witnesses’ cellphones has raised further questions about the sheriff’s handling of the incident.
“It makes it look like a coverup,” said David Cohn, a lawyer for Silva’s children and parents, adding that he has not been able to see the video. “What we’re all concerned about is, ‘Are these videos going to be altered? Are they going to be deleted?’”
Youngblood defended the decision to take custody of the phones as a way of preserving possible evidence. The sheriff said his office obtained a search warrant for the phones.
“We still have to secure the evidence, especially when the evidence can tell us whether we did it right or wrong,” Youngblood said.
He said his agency, to remove the appearance of any conflict, has asked the Bakersfield Police Department to analyze the phone videos.
KERO-TV Channel 23 in Bakersfield broadcast a security camera video from the scene showing grainy images of figures pummeling someone on the ground, with about 20 swings of what appear to be batons or sticks. It’s difficult to see Silva in the seven-minute video or how many of those swings connected.
Silva stopped breathing and was taken to a hospital, where he was pronounced dead at 12:44 a.m. Wednesday, the Sheriff’s Department said.
Get breaking news, investigations, analysis and more signature journalism from the Los Angeles Times in your inbox.
You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times.