Opinion: Which NFL stadium proposal would screw up L.A. traffic the least?
An artist’s rendering of the proposed NFL stadium in Carson.
There’s been a lot of talk about which professional football team should return to Los Angeles, and which stadium proposal -- Carson or Inglewood -- is the better bet. Let the fans and the billionaire team owners figure that out.
Here’s what the rest of us should be asking: Which stadium is going to screw up traffic the least? Or, even better, which team owner/stadium operator is willing to do the most to help ease traffic by making it as simple as possible for fans to take public transit, rideshare, bike or walk to events?
Join the conversation on Facebook >>
Yet despite the region’s rapidly expanding rail network, neither project is within easy walking distance of a station. Inglewood, so far, has the advantage. The proposed stadium would be about a mile from one of the stops on the new Crenshaw Line. The developer has promised to run shuttles to connect the two. Both the stadium and the light rail line would open in 2019.
An artist’s rendering of the proposed Inglewood football stadium.
But buses may not be sufficient to handle tens of thousands of people on game days, nor will fans choose transit if faced with huge crowds and long waits for shuttles. If Inglewood is picked, the city and developers need to figure out how to get public transportation riders as close to the stadium as possible, without having to switch to a shuttle.
The proposed Carson stadium is near transit lines, but not close to any station. It’s about two miles from the Harbor Gateway Transit Center and about four miles from the Blue Line’s Del Amo Station. In November, stadium proponents said they too could run buses between the stadium and the transit stops, the Daily Breeze reported.
The one public transportation bright spot is the Los Angeles Memorial Coliseum, which could serve as the temporary home for the NFL until a new stadium is built. The Coliseum is right next to the Expo Line, providing an easy connection for anyone who wants to take the train to a game.
Professional football left Los Angeles in an era of cars. The Rams moved to Anaheim in 1980, the Raiders left for Oakland after the 1994 season and the Chargers shifted to San Diego in 1961. The NFL is on the cusp of returning to a more multi-modal L.A., with new rail lines and bus and bike lanes. If the NFL does commit to sending one or more teams back to Los Angeles, the team owners and host city need to make transportation choices a top priority, not an afterthought.
For more opinions, follow me @kerrycavan
MORE FROM OPINION
Welcome to the dawning of the Age of Anthropocene
Hillary Clinton and Ted Cruz are making the Supreme Court a campaign issue
‘Mission accomplished’ in recapture of Mexican drug kingpin ‘El Chapo’ -- but for how long?
A cure for the common opinion
Get thought-provoking perspectives with our weekly newsletter.
You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times.