The joke is on voters who trusted Trump’s healthcare promises

The small print on the red Trump cap.
Top of the Ticket cartoon
(David Horsey / Los angeles Times)

Oh, that Donald Trump; what a comedian! After spending a year on the campaign trail scoffing at the upbeat jobs numbers put out by the Obama administration, he is now boasting about the latest jobs numbers coming from the same sources.

When asked about this convenient contradiction during a news briefing, White House Press Secretary Sean Spicer said Trump had told him to offer this explanation: “They may have been phony in the past, but it’s very real now.” That got a good laugh from the reporters in the room. Even Spicer grinned.

Now, in an even more hilarious turnabout, Trump is discounting the Congressional Budget Office analysis that has determined the House Republican healthcare plan will, over time, reduce the total of insured Americans by 24 million. Trump rejects the CBO’s analysis because he has embraced the GOP healthcare bill as his own. That is very different from the way he, as a candidate, cited CBO numbers as if they were gospel when they made Obama look bad.


Monday, during the daily White House media scrum, NBC’s Peter Alexander got into a testy exchange with Spicer over the president’s very elastic and self-serving use of facts. First, they sparred about Trump’s unsupported allegation that Obama had wiretapped Trump Tower. Spicer tried to pretend that Trump’s allegation had not been a very specific and personal attack on the former president. Then they argued about the CBO’s healthcare estimates.

After Spicer had finished his verbal pretzel making, Alexander asked, “Can you say affirmatively that whenever the president says something, we can trust it to be real?”

“If he’s not joking,” Spicer said.

Well, an agile comedian can always find a gullible chump to be the object of his humor and, in the case of healthcare, the butt of Trump’s joke is the older, white working-class voter who cheered loudly when candidate Trump guaranteed insurance coverage for every American. “Everybody’s going to be taken care of much better than they’re taken care of now,” Trump said in the early days of the campaign, a promise he continued to repeat. Under his magical, imaginary scheme, premiums would go down and Medicaid would not be cut.


Now that there is a real plan to be scrutinized, Trump claims it matches his campaign rhetoric, even in the face of compelling evidence to the contrary. Numbers from the CBO are seldom perfectly accurate, but they are generally a good predictor of the costs of legislation. And, in the case of the GOP healthcare legislation (dare we call it “Trumpcare?”), not only will millions of people lose insurance coverage, but premiums will shoot up for older citizens who will lose much of their federal subsidy and Medicare funds for the working poor will be slashed.

And here’s the punchline: Many of those who get slammed by these changes will be people who believed Trump’s promises and gave him their votes; folks of modest means and limited education who are getting up in years and need the help of government to pay their medical bills when they get sick.

They trusted Trump. It’s too bad Sean Spicer was not around to explain Trump’s sense of humor to them back on election day. Their future president, he could have said, can be trusted, “if he’s not joking.”

Follow me at @davidhorsey on Twitter


Less than two months into Trump’s presidency, there is still no end in sight to his conflicts of interest


Faced with fear of a despotic government or apathy, I’ll take fear

Let’s normalize Trump

Get our weekly Opinion newsletter