Column: Soft goals and inconsistency — Kings’ goaltending woes threaten to derail season

Kings goaltender Pheonix Copley watches play during a 4-0 loss to the Dallas Stars on Thursday night.
Kings goaltender Pheonix Copley watches play during a 4-0 loss to the Dallas Stars on Thursday night. The Kings have struggled to find consistency in net this season.
(Juan Ocampo / NHLI via Getty Images)

The Kings have a goaltending problem.

Pheonix Copley saved their season by winning 12 of 14 decisions following his Dec. 1 promotion from the American Hockey League, putting up numbers that were about average for an NHL goalie but looked like precious gems to the Kings, who had stayed afloat while Cal Petersen flailed his way to a demotion and Jonathan Quick showed signs of age and persistent shakiness.

The entire team played better in front of Copley than it had in front of Quick, probably subconsciously, and that diligence reduced the danger of the shots Copley had to face. Copley was never going to be the long-term answer in net, but his teammates rallied around the career minor leaguer who came out of nowhere to supplant two-time Stanley Cup champion Quick and gave them respectable goaltending when they most needed it.


Goalie Pheonix Copley was taken out of the game as the Stars gave the Kings their first shut out at Arena this season in the 4-0 loss.

Jan. 19, 2023

That happy bubble burst Thursday. Copley gave up a flurry of soft goals and was replaced by Quick in the second period of a 4-0 loss to the Dallas Stars in the Kings’ final home game before a six-game trip that begins Saturday in Nashville.

Copley yielded four goals in 17 shots, the last goal — a wraparound by former Junior King Jason Robertson of Arcadia scored at 7:27 of the second period — being enough to persuade coach Todd McLellan to yank him. Quick stopped all seven shots he faced. But that included only two shots in the third period while Dallas, which had blown a three-goal lead at San Jose on Wednesday, made sure recent history wouldn’t repeat itself.

McLellan had considered switching goalies after the Stars scored three times in the first period, but he wanted Copley to get more ice time in the goalie’s first game in eight days, which also was the team’s first game after a four-day break. That fourth goal, celebrated exuberantly by Robertson’s extended family in a suite high above the ice, was the breaking point for the Kings, who were shut out for the third time this season and first time at Arena. They won’t play at home again until Feb. 11 because they must vacate the arena for the Grammys and then have the NHL All-Star break and a week off.

Jonathan Quick allows four goals on 27 shots as the Kings saw their three-game winning streak end in a 5-2 loss to the New Jersey Devils.

Jan. 14, 2023

They’re still third in the Pacific division and only two points behind leader Seattle. But they’re also only one point ahead of Edmonton, which holds the first West wild-card spot. And the Kings’ goal differential dropped to minus-seven, which could come into play to break a tie in the standings and determine who makes the playoffs, or who ends up in which playoff position.

“Do we have a goaltending problem?” McLellan said, repeating a reporter’s question. “We have goaltending moments, but we have [defense] moments and forward moments that don’t go our way.

“Pheonix obviously has played well for us lately. It wasn’t his best night. Maybe his poorest that he’s had with us.”

Dallas Stars center Wyatt Johnston backhands a shot against Kings goaltender Pheonix Copley.
Dallas Stars center Wyatt Johnston backhands a shot against Kings goaltender Pheonix Copley during the first period Thursday.
(Ashley Landis / Associated Press)

Copley, to his credit, acknowledged his shortcomings. Rust from inactivity, he said, wasn’t to blame. “Just a tough effort by me. I guess it is always a little tough but that’s no excuse,” he said.

His teammates didn’t help much, making an array of small mistakes that added up. “We self-inflicted our own misery early in the game and tried to find our game as the game wore on,” McLellan said.

They lost battles. Didn’t win crucial faceoffs. Didn’t get the puck in deep, which led to Tyler Seguin’s goal from above the right circle at 6:54 of the first period. Seguin went top shelf for an unassisted goal at 17:20, and Esa Lindell found the upper-left corner at 18:44 to silence the crowd and give the Stars a 3-0 lead.

“Maybe things weren’t clicking as well as they have been, but the effort was there,” Copley said. “It was just the execution.”

The Kings, who took 34 shots at Dallas goalie Scott Wedgewood, didn’t consistently match the Stars’ intensity. “It was just a bounce here and there that we needed. And we didn’t quite earn it tonight too,” Kings captain Anze Kopitar said. “We definitely have to play better in order to win games.”


Philadelphia Flyers defenseman Ivan Provorov skipped pregame warmups when the team wore Pride-themed jerseys and used sticks wrapped in rainbow tape.

Jan. 18, 2023

Seeking silver linings, McLellan said he considered Quick’s relief effort some consolation. “Quickie played well. He didn’t get a lot of action, but he was in the game, he made some good puckhandling touches, and some stops right off the bat on the penalty kill,” McLellan said. “If there’s a positive, he got some good minutes in and can feel good about himself.”

The Kings’ upcoming six-game, 12-day trip is oddly structured, with games at Nashville, Chicago and Philadelphia in the first four days. They’ll have two days off before playing back-to-back games at Florida on Jan. 27 and at Tampa on Jan. 28, and they’ll finish at Carolina on Jan. 31. That will require some careful scheduling of their goalies.

“Common sense is that we can’t run one guy there. We know that,” McLellan said. “So, they’re both going to get to play in those situations. And then after that we’ll have more time. We get rest. We get practice. We’ll see where the team is at.”

They won’t go far if they don’t resolve their goaltending problem.