Woman who accused Black teen of stealing phone at New York hotel is arrested

Booking photo of Miya Ponsetto
Booking photo of Miya Ponsetto, who wrongly accused a Black teenager of stealing her phone and then tackled him at a New York hotel.
(Ventura County Sheriff’s Office)

A woman who wrongly accused a Black teenager of stealing her phone and then tackled him at a New York hotel has been arrested in Ventura County.

Miya Ponsetto, 22, from the town of Piru in eastern Ventura County, was jailed Thursday, a spokesperson for the county sheriff’s office said. It wasn’t immediately clear what charges she might face.

The New York Police Department flew detectives out to California earlier Thursday with a warrant for Ponsetto’s arrest. The trip followed days of intense media coverage of the fracas at the hotel and demands by the teen’s family and activists that she face criminal charges.


Ponsetto’s lawyer, Sharen Ghatan, said in an interview before the arrest that her client was “emotionally unwell” and remorseful for her Dec. 26 confrontation with 14-year-old Keyon Harrold Jr. at Manhattan’s Arlo Hotel.

The teen’s father, jazz trumpeter Keyon Harrold, recorded the confrontation and put the video online.

In his video, an agitated woman is seen demanding the teen’s phone, claiming he stole it. A hotel manager tries to intervene. Keyon Harrold can be heard in the recording telling the woman to leave his son alone.

The bill approved by state lawmakers on Monday states that a person who knowingly makes a false and harassing 911 call on another person in a protected class — which includes race, color, ethnicity, religion, nationality, country of origin, ancestry, disability, gender, gender identity, gender expression or sexual orientation — can be charged with a misdemeanor and punishable by up to one year in a county jail and a fine of not less than $500.

Aug. 31, 2020

Ghatan confirmed that Ponsetto is the woman in the video.

Security video later released by the NYPD shows Ponsetto frantically grabbing at the teen as he tried to get away from her through the hotel’s front door. She’s seen clutching him from behind before both tumble to the ground.

Ponsetto’s missing phone had actually been left in an Uber and was returned by the driver shortly afterward, Keyon Harrold has said.


The altercation drew comparisons to cases such as that of Amy Cooper, a white woman who was charged with filing a false report after calling 911 and saying she was being threatened by “an African American man” during a dispute in New York’s Central Park in May.

There is a big difference between calling the cops on a Black person for no reason and speaking out to improve your neighborhood.

Jan. 2, 2021

Ventura County Sheriff’s deputies arrested Ponsetto after spotting her driving near her home in Piru, northwest of Los Angeles, said department Capt. Eric Buschow.

She drove two blocks before stopping her vehicle, then refused to get out of the car, Buschow said.

“She tried to slam the door on one of the deputies, and that’s when they just reached in and forcibly removed her,” he said, adding that the sheriff’s office would ask county prosecutors to charge her with resisting arrest.

Ghatan said that she spoke to her client earlier Thursday and that “she strikes me as someone who’s unwell.”


She said that Ponsetto “lashed out” from distress about her phone disappearing and that it wasn’t racially motivated.

It “could have been anyone,” Ghatan said.