Ohio’s GOP-drawn congressional maps, though declared unconstitutional, stand for 2024 election

Members of the Ohio Senate Government Oversight Committee listening to testimony
Ohio’s congressional maps were deemed unconstitutional for unfairly favoring the GOP, but they will continue to be used after Republicans in power refused a court order to create fairer maps before a deadline.
(Julie Carr Smyth / Associated Press)
Share via

Congressional district maps previously deemed unconstitutional by the Ohio Supreme Court will be used in 2024 after the high court dismissed legal challenges against the Republican-drawn districts.

The Ohio voting rights groups that brought the challenges moved to dismiss their own lawsuits against the Republican-drawn maps this week, saying the turmoil isn’t in the best interest of Ohio voters.

The maps were found to be unconstitutional by the court several times for unfairly favoring Ohio’s GOP.


The state’s highest court, which holds a 4-3 Republican majority, dismissed the cases Thursday without comment.

The Ohio Supreme Court has declared as invalid newly drawn legislative maps that would have retained Republican supermajorities in the state House and Senate.

Jan. 12, 2022

The American Civil Liberties Union of Ohio, on behalf of the League of Women Voters of Ohio and others, told the Ohio Supreme Court on Tuesday that they were willing to live with the U.S. House map approved March 2, 2022, which was used in last year’s elections.

The legal dispute has been going on for two years, with the court rejecting two separate congressional maps and five sets of Statehouse maps — describing districts for the Ohio House and Senate in Columbus as gerrymandered in favor of Republicans.

Despite the maps being deemed unconstitutional before the 2022 elections, they continue to be used due to Republicans essentially letting the clock run out
after refusing the court’s order to write up new, fairer maps by the prescribed deadline.

Ohio’s political landscape has only grown more conservative in the last few cycles. Both the state House and Senate currently have Republican supermajorities.

The state Supreme Court’s Republican chief justice, who had provided a swing vote against GOP-leaning maps, retired.